Live data from Hacker News

Kagi releases alpha version of Orion for Linux

help.kagi.com

281–290 of 325 posts

Re: Kagi releases alpha version of Orion for Linux

#281
post #220

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Orion does not collect telemetry data [0]. [0] https://orionbrowser.com/privacy

How do you know that? Source is closed. Is a network analyzer enough to determine?

> Source is closed. Is a network analyzer enough to determine? Or do a search and give arguments why it's not enough ?

Re: Kagi releases alpha version of Orion for Linux

#282

Previously, my comments on Kagi were about one thing: counting queries felt like a chore, so I stayed away. I did give it a try mainly for the privacy angle. After that, I switched to Perplexity and was happy for a year, until the familiar VC backed pattern showed up: ads, even for paying users. This year I upgraded to Kagi Ultimate, and honestly, it feels like they’ve found the sweet spot. I hesitated at $25 at firs…

Interestingly I have not noticed ads on Perplexity yet, but it could be due to a number of reasons including using ublock and not being located in the US. Kagi seems more appealing to me in the way they do business, but I got a free year and lower prices for academia through Perplexity, so it does not make sense to switch.

Re: Kagi releases alpha version of Orion for Linux

#283
post #189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Kagi founder here. Orion isn't open source yet primarily because we're a 5-person team that spent 6+ years building this and created significant IP doing so, and we're not in a position to defend our work against a well-funded company using it as a base (we care very much about the business model of the browser surviving). Restrictive licenses help in theory but enforcing them against a company with a larger legal bu…

I'm a kagi user, and as many have said, I will not use Orion until it is open sourced. I understand your position, but a web browser is so important a software that it must be open. I also think that you can still sell it even if it is open source. Also, you might be able to secure funding from governments that want to move away from closed source solutions. Anyway, still congratulation for v 1.0, and I hope it will…

> Also, you might be able to secure funding from governments that want to move away from closed source solutions.

people with no skin in the game trying to sell bridges.

Re: Kagi releases alpha version of Orion for Linux

#284
post #220

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How do you know that? Source is closed. Is a network analyzer enough to determine?

Because their entire continued existence depends on maintaining a reputation of preserving privacy?

I usually like to accuse people of the wildest privacy conspiracies, but here in the case of Orion, one day the founder approached me together to work with him, and I tried to see how far is he willing to do in practice (“ok maybe we could do X and Y or Z”).

He stopped me and explained to me that is his business model, and… it was to sell apps / subscriptions. He has no interest into anything else and strongly explained that the user pays and that’s it.

Eventually I didn’t work with him but I have a very positive opinion of him, so at least, based on my experience as a potential employee strongly trusts

Re: Kagi releases alpha version of Orion for Linux

#285

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hmm good point. The issue is also the distinction between widevine L1, i.e hardware-backed DRM and L3 (the software backed one). Correct me if I'm wrong but to stream 4K, studios require a hardware root of trust and a verified media path. They need a guarantee that the video frames are decrypted inside a trusted execution environment and sent directly to the display without the OS kernel or user space being able to r…

> They need a guarantee s/need/want/ but yes.

I really wish more people would appreciate this distinction.

Re: Kagi releases alpha version of Orion for Linux

#286
post #9

It seems weird to run a closed-source browser on an open-source operating system when so many open alternatives exist—I certainly wouldn’t do it, and I’m a Kagi customer. Does Kagi plan to open-source Orion on Linux?

Kagi founder here. Orion isn't open source yet primarily because we're a 5-person team that spent 6+ years building this and created significant IP doing so, and we're not in a position to defend our work against a well-funded company using it as a base (we care very much about the business model of the browser surviving). Restrictive licenses help in theory but enforcing them against a company with a larger legal bu…

> We also see limited upside from community contributions - the number of people who can meaningfully work on a WebKit browser is small

But the number of people who can contribute to the app UI is bigger, and that's also an area seriously lacking

Re: Kagi releases alpha version of Orion for Linux

#287
> Customize Everything Your Way Limitless customization that goes far beyond themes. Configure every detail to work exactly as you need.

That would be awesome!, but would be nice to have a list of things comprising "everything", Vivaldi is the best browser in this regard, and still they have plenty of gaps.

Re: Kagi releases alpha version of Orion for Linux

#288
Loved Orion but had to switch to Zen because they had an awful Picture-in-picture implementation and no mouse gesture support, both features I use heavily

Regardless, anything that works toward dethroning the 2 worst spyware distros in the world i.e. windows and osx I must support heavily

Re: Kagi releases alpha version of Orion for Linux

#289
This is great news. I just reinstalled orion yesterday. It was stuck crashing at every launch until I manually deleted the application files on macOS. That being said, I really like orion and kagi, but I agree with others that they should open-source orion.

Re: Kagi releases alpha version of Orion for Linux

#290
post #89

This is a healthy thing to happen to the Linux browser ecosystem imho. We talk a lot about browser diversity, but on Linux and Windows, it is a lie. You have firefox (gecko) and fifty flavors of chromium. Webkit on Linux has essentially been relegated to embedded devices or the GNOME epiphany browser, which I'll admit while is a noble effort, lags a bit in the stability and power-user features department. Big reason…

> Webkit on Linux has essentially been relegated to embedded devices or the GNOME epiphany browser Don't forget about https://falkon.org . It's a browser I enjoy using. WebExtension support will be big if it lands in Orion though. EDIT: apparently Orion is not open source. Not particularly interested in a closed source browser, TBH. In 2022 they said they plan to open source "when there is merit"[1], whatever that me…

Also Ladybird is quite an interesting alternative. Anyone here using it day to day?
Post reply on HN