I don't get why everybody is in love with cloud solutions for keeping their secrets. Encrypted as they may be. Self hosted, at home, or I don't trust it. It's really that simple.
The situation at LastPass may be worse than they are letting on
281–290 of 436 posts
Re: The situation at LastPass may be worse than they are letting on
#282Earlier quoted context omitted.
>It’s fine to store your passwords online for convenience, but as a user, it’s important to accept that it’s no longer your private password and will, at some point, leak. ehh. I store my passwords online but its on a file I encrypted offline with strong password (over 20+ characters) and key. I use keepass which is a locally encrypted and stored password manger, and I store the DB on Dropbox and download it to any o…
How does this work with mobile chrome/Firefox etc. Does it sync?
Re: The situation at LastPass may be worse than they are letting on
#283So is there any way to verify what this person is saying? I mean, from the way LastPass is evolving it doesn't seem unlikely to me -- but why is this tweet on HN? Is there any supporting evidence aside from an anecdote, does this Twitter account have a strong reputation of being credible, etc.? Without context, I just don't understand why this anecdotal thread should be considered credible. Disclaimer: I use FOSS pas…
It seems like a reasonably well written anecdote by someone who has some idea what they're talking about. It could obviously be false, but the consequences if he's right are potentially serious for a lot of HN users who might use LastPass. The consequences if he's wrong are a little extra reputational damage for LastPass, but that seems like a worthwhile tradeoff here. Not everything posted on HN has to be verified t…
Re: The situation at LastPass may be worse than they are letting on
#284So is there any way to verify what this person is saying? I mean, from the way LastPass is evolving it doesn't seem unlikely to me -- but why is this tweet on HN? Is there any supporting evidence aside from an anecdote, does this Twitter account have a strong reputation of being credible, etc.? Without context, I just don't understand why this anecdotal thread should be considered credible. Disclaimer: I use FOSS pas…
It seems like a reasonably well written anecdote by someone who has some idea what they're talking about. It could obviously be false, but the consequences if he's right are potentially serious for a lot of HN users who might use LastPass. The consequences if he's wrong are a little extra reputational damage for LastPass, but that seems like a worthwhile tradeoff here. Not everything posted on HN has to be verified t…
Re: The situation at LastPass may be worse than they are letting on
#285Re: The situation at LastPass may be worse than they are letting on
#286Earlier quoted context omitted.
Why not? I have a security background. I see nothing wrong with that statement. Although what he actually said was: "Initially I imagined I was targeted by a 0day or rootkit" which actually does not make sense, because it implies he thinks those two things are fungible. He's obviously not a security expert, but he's also obviously not totally technically incompetent.
It's quite unlikely someone would risk burning a viable 0day without either going wide (and then we would've heard from a few more people) or going after a well outlined target that would be guaranteed to be worth more than the 0day itself.
Re: The situation at LastPass may be worse than they are letting on
#287Earlier quoted context omitted.
It seems like a reasonably well written anecdote by someone who has some idea what they're talking about. It could obviously be false, but the consequences if he's right are potentially serious for a lot of HN users who might use LastPass. The consequences if he's wrong are a little extra reputational damage for LastPass, but that seems like a worthwhile tradeoff here. Not everything posted on HN has to be verified t…
It's like a novice programmer blaming the compiler for a bug in their application. It's very unlikely to be true. What would you have the people who are using LastPass do, stop using it? Because some crypto dude stored their highly valuable keys in a system that literally copies their keys to any system they log into, to systems that are notorious for having very leaky abstractions and vast vulnerability surfaces?
The big difference between the two examples is this: LastPass is known to have bugs. Huge amounts of data were stolen from them and we just found out that it was a lot more than we thought.
For all we know, they were storing passwords in the clear somewhere.
Trivia note: the first compiled language I used was PL/I, and the compiler was notoriously buggy and would crash on well-formed programs. Our teacher told us to put do-nothing statements in when this happened (`PUT SKIP(0);` if I recall correctly), and with some trial and error, those would fix it.
Re: The situation at LastPass may be worse than they are letting on
#288Earlier quoted context omitted.
Bitwarden, Keeper ($ but trusted at megacorps), and good ol' PasswordSafe are the safest solutions. I run BW with Yubikey 2FA and a local hosted sync server. KeePassX/C perhaps. Vault for secrets management. Never touched LastPass, 1Password or any of these other mickey-mouse commercial apps that invariably claim "military-grade encryption" or "unhackable" when their fundamental constructions are crap.
I do passwordsafe on google drive. I feel google does a good job w security / main risk a computer I’m using getting compromised
Re: The situation at LastPass may be worse than they are letting on
#289Earlier quoted context omitted.
>It’s fine to store your passwords online for convenience, but as a user, it’s important to accept that it’s no longer your private password and will, at some point, leak. ehh. I store my passwords online but its on a file I encrypted offline with strong password (over 20+ characters) and key. I use keepass which is a locally encrypted and stored password manger, and I store the DB on Dropbox and download it to any o…
How does this work with mobile chrome/Firefox etc. Does it sync?
If you have specific questions, feel free to ask.