Live data from Hacker News

Part of my code makes Copilot crash

github.com

281–290 of 411 posts

Re: Part of my code makes Copilot crash

#281

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Small children do not take hormones or have gender related surgery. Adolescents under medical oversight can. These treatments have very low regret rates and reduce suicides.

>These things never happen, and when they do, it's a good thing.

Adolescents are not small children. And do you think fewer adolescents killing themselves is bad?

Re: Part of my code makes Copilot crash

#282
post #122

So I've just tested it, and I can confirm, yes, copilot refuses to give suggestions related to gender. Now I know a lot of people are calling this absurd, but looking more closely, there are two PR nightmare scenarios. 1. Copilot makes a suggestion that implies gender is binary, a certain community explodes with anger and an entire news hype cycle starts about how Microsoft is enforcing views on gender with code. 2.…

No post body was provided.

Re: Part of my code makes Copilot crash

#283
post #254

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quoted post unavailable.

> They do now. Giving puberty blockers before puberty doesn't do anything. At this point, please cite a source for this epidemic of six year olds taking GnRH. > No, that's why I made sure to specifically write "teenagers" No, you specifically wrote > significant amounts of small children taking hormones and having gender reassignment surgery Also changed: > That's the case until now, since only a few years ago there…

No post body was provided.

Re: Part of my code makes Copilot crash

#284
post #122

So I've just tested it, and I can confirm, yes, copilot refuses to give suggestions related to gender. Now I know a lot of people are calling this absurd, but looking more closely, there are two PR nightmare scenarios. 1. Copilot makes a suggestion that implies gender is binary, a certain community explodes with anger and an entire news hype cycle starts about how Microsoft is enforcing views on gender with code. 2.…

It's a total nonsense, how can someone be angry at a soulless machine? Is it a real thing to face anger towards an AI like it was a real human? It's a serious mental problem then, cause the anger is actually directed inward in this case

Re: Part of my code makes Copilot crash

#285

Aren't we missing the forest for the trees here? We're zeroing in on how silly is it for copilot to trigger its content filter on the word "gender". To me the real issue is that copilot has a content filter in the first place. It's unwelcome and unnecessary.

I find this filter to be a fine concept. It can prevent automated vulgarity generation if used correctly. However, that filter should be manageable by the user, not hashed and encoded in some weird scheme. Just put down a file called "bad words.txt" and let the user pick their preferred amount of AI suppression.

Re: Part of my code makes Copilot crash

#286

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Small children do not take hormones or have gender related surgery. Adolescents under medical oversight can. These treatments have very low regret rates and reduce suicides.

Ehm... Sorry to break it to you, but people who think they were born the wrong sex are increasingly treated with hormones before the onset of puberty (with puberty-delaying treatments it's kind of the point). Not arguing whether it's good or bad, but by definition they are children at that point in time.

Puberty blockers are hormone agonists. Not hormones.

Re: Part of my code makes Copilot crash

#287

Aren't we missing the forest for the trees here? We're zeroing in on how silly is it for copilot to trigger its content filter on the word "gender". To me the real issue is that copilot has a content filter in the first place. It's unwelcome and unnecessary.

I don't think it's silly. Whatever Copilot says, is said by Microsoft too, by extension. And so, it makes sense for Microsoft to not make themselves liable for whatever people make their product spit out. Especially after happenings like this:

"Microsoft's AI Twitter bot goes dark after racist, sexist tweets"

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-microsoft-twitter-bot-idU...

Re: Part of my code makes Copilot crash

#289

Besides the absurdity of the code crashing because of the word "gender". My problem and curiosity with all of this is... "What was going on in the head of the person writing the parser?" I mean, were they thinking that if someone is writing code, let's say, for a gender dropdown and it was only ["male", "female"], it would try to suggest to us to add 26 more genders instead (and worse, suggest a list of genders to ad…

The ____ church did interfere in all matters of life, big and small, none to trivial to no be guided by a enormous ritual rule book, always threatening disciplinary actions by the believing masses and social ostracizing. Hurting the feelings of the true believers, was the ultimate sin, a sin often committed, but only punished if the sinner did not recant and change his ways, in a brutally public and official way. It…

I'm heavily religious and I agree with you entirely. I see many parallels between life inside the strict religious community I live in and what is happening at large in society.

I think the goal of any sufficiently large society should be that any religion or ideology can rise. Many people can become a part of that, yet the religion or ideology is unable to persecute those how don't agree with it.

I also have no idea how you achieve that. It's my utopia and like most people's vision of a utopia is probably not possible in reality.

Re: Part of my code makes Copilot crash

#290

What was that bot that MSFT stood up on Twitter that trolls and memers fed to turn alt-right? I know they eventually took it down and that it stirred up a lot of controversy. I would not be surprised if someone found some Copilot output stemming from "gender" and reported to MSFT/GitHub for them to simply short circuit or "break" after finding certain keywords.

This was it:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tay_(bot)

Post reply on HN