Live data from Hacker News

Being sued, in East Texas, for using the Google Play Store [video]

youtube.com

281–290 of 431 posts

Re: Being sued, in East Texas, for using the Google Play Store [video]

#281

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would totally want this too, but legally, can Google do something here when they are not a party in this litigation?

I believe the defendants are able to hire any lawyer. In that case Google would be able to provide support without issue. I could be wrong.

[deleted]

Re: Being sued, in East Texas, for using the Google Play Store [video]

#282

Can these services just be disabled in East Texas to avoid their jurisdiction? At the very least, it would force the patent trolls into more neutral territory.

That's a very interesting idea. I wonder if it's a viable option. edit: It'd actually be pretty effective if you stop to think about it, even if it doesn't technically prevent litigation. Just think: "Sorry, this product isn't available in you're area due to patent litigation concerns". Part of me wonders if that happened with Netflix, Google Maps, etc. wouldn't the people start hating the patent litigation instead o…

That is kind of the nuclear option of the big internet companies. I'm sure they realize that they have this power, but they can only use it rarely, maybe once, before there is public outcry against this "abuse of power". They're probably saving this card it for a bigger issue.

Re: Being sued, in East Texas, for using the Google Play Store [video]

#283

I find it oddly funny how Google hasn't stepped in to support their "clients", I'd think they'd help shutdown patent trolls so developers can continue to improve and distribute applications

Seriously - what the fuck Google? It's only a matter of time until a patent troll writes a for loop on the store index to send out infringement suits DMCA-takedown style.

Google offers pretty handcuffs that developers mistake for bracelets.

Consider how Google is helping the OEMs get Android updates out. Consider how easy it is to call google customer care.

The real question should be: what the fuck developers? Why do you keep hitching yourself to such an unreliable partner? When is it enough?

Re: Being sued, in East Texas, for using the Google Play Store [video]

#284

America needs to follow New Zealand's example: Ban software patents!

In the video, he says that the politicians stopped the issue from even being voted on. That's without Silicon Valley stepping in to really lobby against that kind of ban (NZ has no equivalent of SV)

Re: Being sued, in East Texas, for using the Google Play Store [video]

#285

So, no attempts to bring Davis in front of the Texas BAR association for unethical practices? I'm also curious why numerous developers have not demanded an Insurance Protection Product / Plan that would take a premium in return for subrogation (defense) if a frivolous Patent Suit is filed. I'm rather certain the market exists and while it may be for larger businesses or players, developers forming a Mutual Company an…

There are firms that offer patent infringement insurance services. The cost is astronomical (7 figures per year).

I have a fair amount of experience with patent trolls.

I've seen companies sued for using facebook, where the damages are X dollars times the number of facebook followers/posts/comments they have. (So the level of risk is very hard to estimate for an insurer, because interaction numbers on the internet can spike easily)

Also, the the troll will practically _always_ offers a settlement that is roughly equivalent (or a few percent cheaper) than the legal fees to defend and win the case. -So a company has two options: Spend Y dollars to make it go away; or Spend Y*0.99 dollars and a year of wasted time to _maybe_ win. The system is setup such that Patent Trolls can't lose and companies can't really win.

Re: Being sued, in East Texas, for using the Google Play Store [video]

#286
post #267

Earlier quoted context omitted.

#define supposing if #define whereas else

I know nothing about C. You can alias keywords like that?

In C, #define basically does string substitution, so absolutely.

You can also do even more weird things with it, like X macros

Re: Being sued, in East Texas, for using the Google Play Store [video]

#287

TLDW - Patent troll sues Xplane creator after he migrated his app to the Google play store. They claim they own the general idea of the Google play store. Law firms create these cases for billable hours for their lawyers and some of their parent judges in Texas. Patent trolls and law firms in the end want to receive a settlement by targeting app creators and not Google themselves who are well equipped to defend thems…

Logically, how is this even possible? Xplane does not own Google Play Store and Xplane is not aware that Google is violating a patent then how is Xplane responsible for the patent violation? This strikes me a 15 minute conversation in front of a judge. "Sir, I did not know Google was violating a patent and I have withdrawn my application after being told so" and that should be the end of it.

Because this particular judge refuses to throw out illegitimate patent cases because he's corrupt as fuck. He recently retired, but presumably someone else just filled his place.

Re: Being sued, in East Texas, for using the Google Play Store [video]

#288

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know nothing about C. You can alias keywords like that?

Boost has macro header libs that allow pretty much anything within the macros system limits to be computed. Lookup Boost preproccessor and youll be even more impressed.

My dad used to tell idiots that he was very impressed with their ideas; one day, he pointed out to me that the impression was not always a positive one.

Edit: Not saying Boost is idiotic; just that you may not be positively impressed with their use of preprocessor magic.

Re: Being sued, in East Texas, for using the Google Play Store [video]

#289
post #153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It might make the world a better place overall but likely cause problems for the beater.

One of those post-bucket list things to do, maybe, after you've been diagnosed with a terminal illness that still leaves you a month or two of personal autonomy.

The potential silver lining of my breast cancer! I volunteer!
Post reply on HN