Live data from Hacker News

Kagi Assistant is now available to all users

blog.kagi.com

271–280 of 294 posts

Re: Kagi Assistant is now available to all users

#271
post #12

Anyone used both Kagi assistant and perplexity and can share how was the experience?

I've subscribed to Kagi for 2 years and subscribed to Perplexity for 2 months. I liked Perplexity a lot—in particular, I think its search AI search is faster and maybe a little better than Kagi's. But the lack of standard search and not being able to do non-search AI work led me to drop it and just keep Kagi. And then Kagi released Ki, their multi-step assistant, which is close to as good.

Re: Kagi Assistant is now available to all users

#272

> A note on our fair-use policy > Basically our policy states that you can use AI models based on your plan’s value. Although I likely won't use Assistant, stuff like this is why I love Kagi. My relationship with them as a customer feels refreshingly transparent; I can't think of any other consumer SaaS provider that automatically answers my reflexive "how does this make money?" question. (Compare, say, Discord. It's…

Having a good ethos before significant funding rounds is one thing , it is lot harder once you raise a ton of external money.

It is not big bad VC either, VC funding while demanding is still lot more forgiving than Private equity or public markets . It is nature of a free economy to be as efficient as possible which in turn makes it affordable and accessible to class of users who would not have been do so before .

Re: Kagi Assistant is now available to all users

#273
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As an existing happy subscriber to Kagi, this statement is illogical. I currently pay for x. Soon I’ll get x + y for the same money. That’s better.

I am also an existing happy subscriber to Kagi. I currently pay for unlimited X. Now I pay for limited X, where I can't even see if I'm approaching limits or not. Anyway, my main point is that I'm getting LESS for the same money.

No! Are you wilfully misrepresenting this?

You currently pay for unlimited X.

Now you get unlimited X + limited Y.

More.

Re: Kagi Assistant is now available to all users

#274
post #196

Kagi search is great, but I'm not willing to pay more than $5/mo for search and 300 searches isn't enough. I have no interest in Kagi AI. Adding more searches would've caused me to sign up again. A rate limit instead of a monthly limit would prevent the "search anxiety" that creeps in as your available searches dwindle. Make it so and you can have my money again.

I'm gonna guess you aren't their target audience, so you both win thanks to the filter of capitalism. $10 a month to avoid google and microsoft AND get a decent AI assistant is a bargain to me. Plus it's a small tech company trying to make a good product for a certain audience and I can dig that. I hope they succeed and become wealthy.

Re: Kagi Assistant is now available to all users

#275
post #211
post #200

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I suspect that Kagi’s price point might be a close approximation of what these services actually cost to provide without being subsidized by ad services and data harvesting; free search can only really sustain itself under those conditions. Heavy users who block ads have been getting subsidized by other users for decades now, and this has led these users to expect these services to be provided at an unrealistically l…

If they can't scale 300 searches for way less than $5 in costs, they are doing something very wrong. Consider that you can get 1M tokens of inference for less.

the $5 is the cheap drugs that your dealer is offering. They hope you'll start popping for the good stuff for $10, which is often less than I pay for a single lunch, and I use it constantly

Re: Kagi Assistant is now available to all users

#276
post #227
post #200

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I suspect that Kagi’s price point might be a close approximation of what these services actually cost to provide without being subsidized by ad services and data harvesting; free search can only really sustain itself under those conditions. Heavy users who block ads have been getting subsidized by other users for decades now, and this has led these users to expect these services to be provided at an unrealistically l…

Yes, but don’t twist it: it’s VC money, greedy corporations and personal data exploitation that enabled all that. Not those who came to expect expensive services for free.

Kagi is not funded by big VCs, please read here: https://blog.kagi.com/safe-round

Re: Kagi Assistant is now available to all users

#277
post #262

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would the number of integrations be the price point and not token tiers? I might want to connect my account to 100 services to test them, but only perform a couple uses each before forgetting about it.

I agree that makes sense, but it makes potential subscribers to the third parties nervous. I like Kagi Assistant because my payment is capped. I get nervous plugging my pay-as-you-go API keys into random software because of the risk they rack up a $1000 bill doing something I wouldn’t have paid $20 for them to do. The other three things are that economies of scale make it cheaper for Kagi to buy a bajillion tokens, G…

So let me lock it down. When I add the key, let me tell my provider this service is allowed 3% of my capacity before it’s locked out.

Re: Kagi Assistant is now available to all users

#278
post #223

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I really feel like the software model is going to start to break in a couple of ways in the near future. Instead of vertical software slices, many people are going to want their single “horizontal” agent that they pay for (e.g Gemini Advanced, Claude) and connectivity to all of their other services. MCP (which I personally think is a mediocre protocol, so it will probably win) as the glue for a bunch of services we O…

I prefer identity as the top layer. Give me an identity portal that acts as an account manager, access to api layer, let me perform password resets, and let me avoid 2fa if I’m logged into my identity manager account. It should allow bidirectional control: both what services have access to my identity, and what services anything in my identity are granted access to access. Things like LLM, cloud storage etc should be…

I mean, that sounds basically like Oauth provided by the LLM provider, right? The provider just needs to build out the features.

Re: Kagi Assistant is now available to all users

#279

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And what is the cheapest model to use? Llama 70B?

https://help.kagi.com/kagi/ai/llm-benchmark.html gemini flash, 4o-mini, mistral small for super cheap qwen-qwq for strong models

Thanks

Re: Kagi Assistant is now available to all users

#280

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> it is not reasonable to assume that unlimited means unlimited sure, but I am not abusing the unlimited plan. it is reasonable to assume that "unlimited" means that a normal user like myself will not run into limits.

If you’re not abusing it and are just using it like a normal user, you won’t hit the limit. As far as you’re concerned, nothing will change, so I’m not sure why you think this is bad for you.

You seem very confident I will not hit the limit. So presumably you know where the limits are? Where are they?
Post reply on HN