Live data from Hacker News

Apple discriminated against US citizens in hiring, DOJ says

arstechnica.com

271–275 of 275 posts

Re: Apple discriminated against US citizens in hiring, DOJ says

#271
post #270

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're right, there are two tiers of people in the field - people who know how to write software and the others. Bootcamp is literally not a CS grad situation. And I have worked with bootcampers just over a year ago - I can only say that it's just a sea of trash. Most bootcampers are just not trained enough to think more than a minute into the future. As for "they aren't starry eyed", you're literally proving that th…

I know nothing about your company or interview process, but I'm speaking as someone just coming out of a long and painful job hunt. I'll agree only that there are a lot of bad candidates who come out of bootcamps. There are a lot of good ones too. A lot of bootcamps run on the model that they train the bare minimum for a student to get a job, so they can take a cut of the paycheck. What you get is socialites learning…

> I'm speaking as someone just coming out of a long and painful job hunt.

Sounds like you're speaking like someone that feels slighted by bad hiring, lashing out at groups that have nothing to do with you. I switched jobs twice in the last 3 years, it's not an easy process and I have 18 years of professional experience.

> There are a lot of good ones too.

Not nearly as many as we would like.

> Recruiters post insane expectations

That is changing fast and most of the jobs that I have seen have sane requirements now.

> H1B fresh out of grad school

Grad school - they're advanced degree holders(MS or PHD), that's already above a fresh CS BSc graduate.

H1b has not been a source of cheap engineering talent for years now. The salaries of H1b are legally above median, which squarely puts them out of the CS graduate category. It cost a company $20k for my L1b in 2016, H1b was about half with 30% chance of success and 6-12 month wait.

Saying that CS graduates compete with fresh H1b is ignorant at best.

Advanced degree holders do not compete with CS graduates, that are BSc... let alone bootcampers.

Re: Apple discriminated against US citizens in hiring, DOJ says

#272
post #270

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know nothing about your company or interview process, but I'm speaking as someone just coming out of a long and painful job hunt. I'll agree only that there are a lot of bad candidates who come out of bootcamps. There are a lot of good ones too. A lot of bootcamps run on the model that they train the bare minimum for a student to get a job, so they can take a cut of the paycheck. What you get is socialites learning…

> I'm speaking as someone just coming out of a long and painful job hunt. Sounds like you're speaking like someone that feels slighted by bad hiring, lashing out at groups that have nothing to do with you. I switched jobs twice in the last 3 years, it's not an easy process and I have 18 years of professional experience. > There are a lot of good ones too. Not nearly as many as we would like. > Recruiters post insane…

> lashing out at groups that have nothing to do with you

You make it sound like I'm lashing out against H1B holders. I'm not. It's the "There's not enough talent in US, so we have to seek elsewhere" sentiment from hiring managers that I strongly disagree with. There's tons of talent here, they might just be harder to find because hiring is so broken.

Re: Apple discriminated against US citizens in hiring, DOJ says

#273

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don't want to be the odd one out on a team since you'll be the first to get laid off. Either find a team with a good mix or stick to your own color.

Apple hasn't laid engineers off since the early 2000s IIRC. It didn't happen in 2021 because they didn't overhire like everyone else did, nor did their execs decide to punish their employees like everyone else did.

I was thinking more Amazon than Apple. Hiring an outsider to a team just to have someone to fire is supposedly common there.

Re: Apple discriminated against US citizens in hiring, DOJ says

#275
post #143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Riiiight. Yeah, that must be it. No other possible reason whatsoever.

Of course thats it. Are you this naive? By the way a judge blocked it.

Please don't respond to a bad comment by breaking the site guidelines yourself. That only makes things worse.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Post reply on HN