Live data from Hacker News

Remove United from your flight results

dropunited.com

271–280 of 293 posts

Re: Remove United from your flight results

#271

Earlier quoted context omitted.

More than once my plane has been late on southwest and every time my connecting flight waited for me to arrive before departing. What a nice way to end a trip.

Between the two clauses I honestly can't tell if you're complimenting or criticizing the airline. In any case, I love the no-hassles baggage policy (checking in bags is far more comfortable assuming they don't get misplaced) and seat selection (especially when traveling alone). The easy to understand frequent flyer program and relatively friendly staff help as well.

Too a point, I can forgive being late because of bad weather or logistical reason. But I absolutely hate being stranded in a layover city.

Re: Remove United from your flight results

#272
post #270

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some stranger on the internet can have you killed by the people entrusted to protect you.. and the solution here is to not joke about it? Screw that. This is hilarious. Why do I get the feeling that SWAT protocols would change overnight if a high profile CEO was the victim.

I see your point.

Wow did I miss something. Anyone care to describe the deleted comment with a little more clarity?

Re: Remove United from your flight results

#273
post #258
post #182

While I didn't have terrible experience comparable to some recent events, I also want to share mine. Last year when I was flying United I printed my boarding pass from one of the kiosks at the airport, and it assigned me to a seat where there's slightly more legroom, normally I believe these are upgrade seats, but I assumed there's no other seats so it gave me that one. After I and several others boarded the plane, o…

The only way I've found to protect against this is by being paranoid. Whenever someone asks for my boarding pass, I show them my phone, while the paper copy is safely in my pocket.

yes I've thought about this as well after the event, now I keep a printed copy in my pocket and use the one on my phone in case something like this happens again (on a different airline)

Re: Remove United from your flight results

#274

All airlines in North America sucks. Take cue from Emirates and learn from them. See how they treat economy class customers. I wont think twice to fly Emirates , Etihad or Qatar.

It's too bad airlines like Emirates, JAL, and Lufthansa can't do domestic US flights and put most of our crappy airlines out of business.

Re: Remove United from your flight results

#275

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The "cap" is a limit on how much the airline must pay, not on how much they can pay in order to involuntarily dis-board a passenger. There was nothing stopping them from paying the passenger who "bid" $1600 to solve the problem they created in the first place.

Are you sure? Most of the articles I've read indicated that the cap was UP TO 400% of the ticket price with a maximum of $1,350 which seems to indicate that the cap is a maximum. Although I will say if the airline offered cash instead of vouchers I'm sure more people would have volunteered.

"DOT's denied boarding regulation spells out the airlines' minimum obligation to people they bump involuntarily."

https://www.transportation.gov/airconsumer/fly-rights

Re: Remove United from your flight results

#276
post #272
post #270

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I see your point.

Wow did I miss something. Anyone care to describe the deleted comment with a little more clarity?

Sarcastically said someone should be swatted so they know what it's like. Clearly not the most elegant argument.

Re: Remove United from your flight results

#277

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Compared to the other two big US airlines, yes -- United has an earned reputation for slashing mainline service in favor of regional affiliates. People occasionally joked (only half joking) that if previous CEO Jeff Smisek were only legally allowed to, he'd have outsourced long-haul international flights to 50-seat CRJs. This also played a role in United's frankly abysmal on-time ratings; in order to have enough capa…

he'd have outsourced long-haul international flights to 50-seat CRJs... Smisek did do it with the long-range 757s he gained in the Continental merger. Smaller plane, less crew...and just enough range to get back if the headwinds are light. If not, it's an unscheduled 90 minute refuel in Canada. Add the time to clear immigration and customs, and now you have 200+ people with a missed connection. http://www.airliners.n…

United isn't the only airline which did/does use 757s on transatlantic flights. And the fact that US east coast to western Europe was within range for the 757 is a big reason why airlines are pushing Boeing for something else in the same class.

Meanwhile, airlines are also looking at Airbus, which is talking up a long-range variant of the A321neo for exactly this purpose.

Re: Remove United from your flight results

#278
post #157

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not arguing the fact that United did a really bad thing. I definitely agree with that. I'm only arguing the supposition that United is a uniquely bad company.

I'd like to know if United is a uniquely outsourced airline. I think that is quite possible and if it is, then it lends considerable weight to the likelihood that it is a uniquely bad airline. This is the kind of problem a company can get into when the people making the key decisions operate in terms of "metrics" that don't track reality well enough. Plus when a lot of the work is done by outsourced vendors, they pro…

Certainly compared to pre-merger American. American Eagle, their regional arm, was a wholly-owned subsidiary. They picked up some other carriers under the Eagle flag when they merged with US Airways, though Eagle is still large (now called Envoy Air).

Re: Remove United from your flight results

#280

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Chicago PD wasn't involved with this at all. It was "aviation police". No connection.

Whoever they are it is a sad state of affairs. Obviously United is primarily to blame for all of this - the CEO is so disingenuous - but who are these goon like people who just follow orders without asking a single question. They could have asked, what has he done? Is he a murder suspect, has he done something awful? If the answer back was just, 'we've overbooked' then the trivial nature of it all should have made th…

"but who are these goon like people who just follow orders without asking a single question. "

To a first approximation, everybody. Unfortunately.

http://www.spsp.org/news-center/press-releases/milgram-polan...

Post reply on HN