Live data from Hacker News

Why I Would Raise Chickens

gatesnotes.com

271–272 of 272 posts

Re: Why I Would Raise Chickens

#271
post #209

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be more clear: The commerce clause was interpreted such as to allow the federal government to impose limits on agricultural production even when the food is being used to feed your own animals. We already have numerous such restrictions (e.g., brewing beer). A key point in this, in fact, was that it doesn't matter if it's being produced for your own (animals) consumption vs. for sale. But that has nothing to do wi…

you should read deeper into Wickard . SCOTUS decalred washing your dishes to be considered commerce. For more information on the extent of the Commerce Clause into your life, I'd suggest looking at Clarence Thomas' dissent in Raich v. Gonzalez . it's an eye-opener.

Oh, absolutely. (I've read wickard, but not the dissent you mention). I was trying to clarify that the issue was not that it is somehow illegal to eat your own food. The issue was that there was a federal limit that was being violated, and - as you note - the commerce clause was used to justify why even a seemingly local use was subject to federal regulation.

Re: Why I Would Raise Chickens

#272
post #70
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's almost certainly about being a nuisance to your neighbors. Roosters crow super obnoxiously. Like.. wow. If you've ever tried to sleep with one nearby you know what I'm talking about. Just handle that edge case (e.g. don't keep a rooster around) and NO ONE will care if you have chickens that don't bother anyone :) Especially if you're into sharing the eggs!

So what do you do when roosters are born...kill them?

they are quite tasty.
Post reply on HN