Live data from Hacker News

Stop Sloppypasta

stopsloppypasta.ai

261–270 of 275 posts

Re: Stop Sloppypasta

#261

It's ironic, because the site has all the hallmarks of an LLM generated website.

Oh, I 100% acknowledge the site itself was LLM generated. I'm not a web designer, so I needed a lot of help making a visually appealing site, even if that design language is at this point LLM trope. However, the essay and the guidelines were all human-written!

You need to make it look more like Grugbrain dev: https://grugbrain.dev/

Authentic human brutalism =)

Re: Stop Sloppypasta

#262

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some people use AI as they use anything else. Careless, without putting the effort in, making things somebody else's problem. This existed before AI, it just accelerated the stupidity.

Well said, carelessness of the user persists regardless of the tools they're using. The cracks may show in other ways though.

In a lot of domains, carelessness used to be associated with incomplete, terse, or minimal output. Not so now.

Re: Stop Sloppypasta

#263
post #61
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's about as polite as you can get, and it's still risky: people get defensive, the output might NOT be from an LLM, etc. That's the asymmetry of the problem: Writing with AI delegates the thinking to the reader as well as all the risk for correcting it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law

Damn, then we automated bullshit generation

Re: Stop Sloppypasta

#264

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What are these youtube channels, care to share their names?

John ag and that survivalist raccoon were the two I had in mind.

hmm, those are definitely AI made. There's one channel I watch periodically that's hard to tell:

https://www.youtube.com/@MedievalWay

Here's a sample video.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wKdKr4VONc4

I suspect the voice is AI, the thumbnails definitely are, but unsure of the rest of the content. It's really interesting and the content in the video seems legit (looked up the "forgotten vegetables" and was surprised to find that we did forgo a lot of tasty things to satisfy the machine harvesters).

Guessing it's likely a phd student with too much time on their hand.

Re: Stop Sloppypasta

#265
More than often when I get asked a question is something that AI can easily answer. Rather than just responding “ask AI” I actually put effort into pasting their question into AI and verifying the response in case they don’t have the context to verify themselves.

Another reason is if I’m using a custom setup with different knowledge bases and tool, I don’t want to respond “setup X, then ask AI”

I think this should be flipped around and instead be “stop sloppy asking”

Re: Stop Sloppypasta

#266
post #265

More than often when I get asked a question is something that AI can easily answer. Rather than just responding “ask AI” I actually put effort into pasting their question into AI and verifying the response in case they don’t have the context to verify themselves. Another reason is if I’m using a custom setup with different knowledge bases and tool, I don’t want to respond “setup X, then ask AI” I think this should be…

I'd love to hear more about these other knowledge bases and tools

Re: Stop Sloppypasta

#267

Earlier quoted context omitted.

John ag and that survivalist raccoon were the two I had in mind.

hmm, those are definitely AI made. There's one channel I watch periodically that's hard to tell: https://www.youtube.com/@MedievalWay Here's a sample video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wKdKr4VONc4 I suspect the voice is AI, the thumbnails definitely are, but unsure of the rest of the content. It's really interesting and the content in the video seems legit (looked up the "forgotten vegetables" and was surprised t…

Great case in point. I think the whole "forgotten/banned garden plant" genre appeared post ai. Probably too difficult to get together enough visuals for a full length video on an obscure plant before.

Re: Stop Sloppypasta

#268
post #96

I’ve encountered an even more nightmarish version of this recently: ai generated tickets. Basically dumping the output of “write a detailed product spec for a clinical trial data collection pipeline” into a jira ticket and handing it off. Doesn’t match any of our internal product design, adds tons of extraneous features. When I brought this up with said PM they basically responded that these inaccuracies should just…

This is a perfect example of where the real work and challenges are in software development.

AI makes it worse. This is where people will lose tons of productivity with AI and many people are completely clueless. It'll hit them like a ton of bricks one day.

Re: Stop Sloppypasta

#269

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reading this, honestly, I'd say the problem is you then? Velocity is everything.

This is something even my manager wouldn’t say. I think he is feeling embarrassed from all the evidences. To be fair you didn’t read them. I agree that velocity is everything and as a manager they shouldn’t slow the team down.

I don't know what your evidence is, but I'm fairly sure I'm on the polar opposite. I see it working and it's the new norm.

Re: Stop Sloppypasta

#270

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I do find it interesting that people don't mind AI content, as long it's "their AI." The moment someone thinks it's someone else's AI output, the reaction is visceral...like they're being hoodwinked somehow. The problem is that getting an AI to answer a question is trivial. If I wanted to know what an AI has to say about the topic, I would just ask myself. Sending AI output has, as the author writes, the same connot…

I'm starting to realise I might have completely misunderstood the whole lmgtfy thing. I thought it was a semi-rude way to call someone out for asking lazy questions instead of trying to find the answer themselves.

No, you completely had it correct. And sending an AI response to a question is the same semi-rude way to respond.

The context here is that the person logging the ticket (or asking the original question by using AI to do it) is the one who is ALSO being a lazy piece of shit, and deserves and equally lazy useless response in the form of a LMGTFY or AI response, because they were too lazy to actually think about their original query and spend time to craft a succinct but useful ticket/query.

Post reply on HN