Live data from Hacker News

Anti-Anti-Adblocker uBlock filter to get rid of the annoying YouTube message

twitter.com

261–270 of 433 posts

Re: Anti-Anti-Adblocker uBlock filter to get rid of the annoying YouTube message

#261
post #182

If one were to make the ideal alternative to YouTube. What should the specs be like?

Here’s a crazy idea… I don’t want to give any money to Google, but I would happily pay double the amount in taxes to get public infrastructure of comparable quality.

That is crazy

Re: Anti-Anti-Adblocker uBlock filter to get rid of the annoying YouTube message

#262
post #170

Earlier quoted context omitted.

+1 I wouldn’t even notice the subscription costs, but at this point Google has only succeeded in alienating me. I have disproportionately negative feelings about this.

If you had willingly jumped from ad block to premium any time in the last 5 years would you still feel alienated? Reacting to google blocking ad-blockers as a reason not to subscribe to premium is just rationalizing not paying creators for content. I personally don't even remember what ads are like on Youtube and have zero idea how they've changed since the Youtube Red days.

I had Red through my google play music subscription but then they turned music into a YouTube nonsense app that removed features I liked and tripled the costs.

I'd subscribe to YouTube premium if it didn't bundle a music subscription and associated cost.

Re: Anti-Anti-Adblocker uBlock filter to get rid of the annoying YouTube message

#263
post #92

Maybe it's just A/B testing, but I got the "3 strikes and no more video playback" thing, which this DOM element blocking doesn't work around it seems :( After years of procrastinating, I'm finally gonna get around to setting up a basic homelab to run pihole. Thanks, youtube execs and bean counters, for kicking my lazy ass into gear on this! In a way, I kinda wish that ads worked as well as youtube suggestions. If one…

Mate if you get so much value from YouTube that you'll jump through these hoops just to use it without ads, why not just subscribe to premium? Personally it's by far my most bang-for-buck service.

Can't subscribe to premium without getting and using an account first.

Re: Anti-Anti-Adblocker uBlock filter to get rid of the annoying YouTube message

#265

If one were to make the ideal alternative to YouTube. What should the specs be like?

Host video, give money to people who upload videos. These are both incredibly difficult, and why Youtube and Twitch have basically zero competition.

Turns out, that's exactly what YT Premium and Twitch Turbo do.

Re: Anti-Anti-Adblocker uBlock filter to get rid of the annoying YouTube message

#266
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Mate if you get so much value from YouTube that you'll jump through these hoops just to use it without ads, why not just subscribe to premium? Personally it's by far my most bang-for-buck service.

Content on YouTube is shaped by the incentives Google sets on the platform. So what we get, mostly, is junk that best sells ads, best gets clicks, eyes, attention etc. etc. Just like TV was before pay cable came along. Notice how TV got better when you just paid HBO to show you good shows? Paying Google to watch YouTube without ads is like paying ABC to watch The Bachelor without ads. The content is still trash.

If the only content you find on YouTube is trash that sounds like a you problem. My feed is filled with high effort content.

Re: Anti-Anti-Adblocker uBlock filter to get rid of the annoying YouTube message

#267
post #25

It’s funny to look back on all the people who were doing the “see, the world didn’t fall apart just because apple had to allow sideloading” over the last month. Like the law didn’t even come into effect yet and google is already flexing their monopoly power / browser monoculture, but people think that just because the internet didn’t explosively destruct overnight that everything is gonna be just fine. See also, the…

We'll end up with a Firefox add on to bypass this. And failing that, a piratebay of YouTube videos

Who even uses Pirate Bay anymore?

Re: Anti-Anti-Adblocker uBlock filter to get rid of the annoying YouTube message

#268

If one were to make the ideal alternative to YouTube. What should the specs be like?

Peer to peer social network for indexing, querying and sharing torrents, using personal computers/phones/rented seed services to seed files, with a distributed indexing algorithm that branches out from contacts to their contacts to some depth in a recursive fashion, and a distributed search that queries your contacts as well as special index nodes that are well connected in the larger social network.

Then we'd have things like PeerTube built on top of this distributed social network, which would handle fetching video thumbnails, metadata, etc and presenting it in a YouTube style interface.

Re: Anti-Anti-Adblocker uBlock filter to get rid of the annoying YouTube message

#269

Maybe it's just A/B testing, but I got the "3 strikes and no more video playback" thing, which this DOM element blocking doesn't work around it seems :( After years of procrastinating, I'm finally gonna get around to setting up a basic homelab to run pihole. Thanks, youtube execs and bean counters, for kicking my lazy ass into gear on this! In a way, I kinda wish that ads worked as well as youtube suggestions. If one…

I'm pretty sure pihole doesn't block YouTube ads, they seem to be served server side but I could be wrong

Youtube-dl (well, yt-dlp, the non-dead version) will ignore the ads.

Re: Anti-Anti-Adblocker uBlock filter to get rid of the annoying YouTube message

#270

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Open the video in an incognito tab, the limit is probably linked to your youtube/google account.

That's the footgun in google's strategy. In the all-stick no-carrot spirit of modern marketing incentives, they made their unpaid access worse without improving Premium. That only works if the garden has walls, and logging in to youtube is optional. Now youtube use falls into three options: 1) Don't log in to google, block ads. Data collected by google is lower value, resulting in less targeted internet-wide marketin…

This is only true, until they stop video playback for not-logged-in users.

Twitter is pretty much useless unless you have an account, can't even see replies anymore.

Post reply on HN