Live data from Hacker News

Why adults still dream about school

theatlantic.com

261–270 of 340 posts

Re: Why adults still dream about school

#261
post #13

I've been told that people who actually do fail out of school tend to not have these kinds of dreams, or at least at a reduced rate. I've asked some aquaintences over the years and their experiences didn't contradict that assertion. Could be an interesting research topic.

The early psychoanalysts made this observation and Freud mentions it as well. They did not have large sample sizes though; see e.g. https://sci-hub.se/https://doi.org/10.1080/00332747.1961.110...

Re: Why adults still dream about school

#263
post #9

Is this another American thing? I don't know anyone who ever dreams about school (non-US obviously)

UK here - took me quite a few paragraphs to remember that in the US "school" can also mean university. I was wondering when the article would actually get on to the subject of school.

Re: Why adults still dream about school

#264

I feel like this is because school, especially college, and particularly exams, is about as high-stakes as most people's lives ever get, so they look back at that time as peak-anxiety. Think about it: you're being evaluated and the result of that evaluation shapes the next step in the pipeline, and ultimately the trajectory of the rest of your life! Well, at least that's what the university officials, professors, you…

I disagree with this. In school I didn't feel much anxiety and didn't try very hard at exams. I didn't think my life would be over if I didn't do this or that. I simply didn't have those thoughts back then.

Now I'm older I understand what stress is and I do feel like my actions (or inaction) could ruin the rest of my life. There have been several key moments in my adult life that I can pinpoint as high stakes and peak anxiety. Yet I still have the school dreams. I had one just last night, in fact.

Re: Why adults still dream about school

#265

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeschooling_international_... Apart from a few countries you can.

Like, apart from the whole Europe.

Europe isn't a monolith. Have you read through the notes for countries with more restrictive regulations, particularly the yellow and blue labels? With reasonable-enough provisions to ensure equivalency to the public school system, it seems like most countries permit homeschooling.

Re: Why adults still dream about school

#266
Most countries decided to go for an education system that consistently causes PTSD in a large part of the population yet most ppl thinks there is nothing wrong with it. In the name of competitiveness the wheel needs to keep spinning and crush more and more souls.

Re: Why adults still dream about school

#267
post #23
post #13

I've been told that people who actually do fail out of school tend to not have these kinds of dreams, or at least at a reduced rate. I've asked some aquaintences over the years and their experiences didn't contradict that assertion. Could be an interesting research topic.

I pretty much flunked outta college my first time around and "Failing and having to repeat grade X" and "Slept through the final" are two of my most common reoccurring nightmares

Same, I was kicked out of my first try at college for low grades and have had variations of the school dreams in the article

Re: Why adults still dream about school

#268

Is this a US only thing? It's certainly not something that has ever bothered me and none of the people I know who attended a university ever mentioned such a thing. So I think this dictum applies: When a title asks "Why" first ask "If".

It is culture-specific, but not US-only.

BTW, given the current state of psychology, 50%+ of psychology is culture-specific. (See "How emotions are made")

Re: Why adults still dream about school

#269

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hell, I have dreams that I've forgotten to attend class all semester long in grad school and the final exam is tomorrow, and I never even went to grad school! It's like my brain subconsciously realized the undergrad panic dreams no longer make sense as that's too long ago, so now they've evolved to something more suitable for later in life, even though I never did that thing.

> I have dreams that I've forgotten to attend class all semester long This one is a recurring dream for me and sometimes the context is middle or high school which makes even less sense.

Yes, I have this recurring nightmare maybe once a year and I graduated more than a decade ago. I am all stressed out because I realize I haven't attended one of my classes even once because I completely forgot about it.

Re: Why adults still dream about school

#270

Most countries decided to go for an education system that consistently causes PTSD in a large part of the population yet most ppl thinks there is nothing wrong with it. In the name of competitiveness the wheel needs to keep spinning and crush more and more souls.

While that's entirely true, is there an educational system right now that doesn't scar its students as severely?

You say most countries, but if you forget homeschooling I'd say this is pretty much 100% of systemic education on the planet right now.

Post reply on HN