Live data from Hacker News

Why the United States has the best research universities

aeaweb.org

261–262 of 262 posts

Re: Why the United States has the best research universities

#261
post #51
post #8

The US has the best research universities in part because it's socially accepted, even expected, to call anything remotely good "the best" over here. People are a bit more restrained elsewhere. For universities, they're admittedly the best by several objective measures too, but the willingness for self-promotion helps :)

Again...personal experience but I can speak to this a bit. I went to an undergraduate university that would be wouldn't be considered highly ranked, but was nationally known in one subfield. I remember being surprised at one point to see a number of articles in major science media sources from MIT about a 'breakthrough'. I read the articles and they were 100% describing something that we did on a regular basis in und…

Speaking as someone involved in the US research university system, there's something deeply concerning about this piece.

It's a bit like an article circa 2006 about the awesome strength of the US stock market.

Re: Why the United States has the best research universities

#262

Earlier quoted context omitted.

US views on China repeatedly remind me of old-regime European commentary on a younger US.

Here's an example: "The following comparison will illustrate my meaning. During the campaigns of the Revolution the French introduced a new system of tactics into the art of war, which perplexed the oldest generals, and very nearly destroyed the most ancient monarchies in Europe. They undertook (what had never before been attempted) to make shift without a number of things which had always been held to be indispensab…

Nice quote, and fun read - thank you.
Post reply on HN