Live data from Hacker News

I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee

ergoemacs.org

251–260 of 315 posts

Re: I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee

#251
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which is the worst, unforgivable sin (even worse than being old). It doesn't matter what you have done, if there is no corporation to witness to your ability and you do not have a fresh face. Hence "entry-level" positions requiring 5 years of experience, and yet you are unemployable forever if you don't have a job within 5 years of graduating. It might as well be law.

Is having corporate experience really that much better though? I mean, obviously working for someone for several years implies some level of competence, but your work is nearly always locked away and you can't show it off. Ideally you'd want someone who does both; working for someone, which demonstrates the ability to work on a team, while also contributing to open source and making their own content, upon which you…

> Is having corporate experience really that much better though?

Yes, a thousand times yes. At a minimum it gives you insight into some product/set of products that are commercially viable and people use. You get experience with at least one build system, and code architecture someone took to market. It also gives you a paycheck that frees up worries about food and housing. In the least demanding of these jobs you can use the down time to learn other technologies by building a MVP of the current product in another technology or contributing to open source projects your corporate job uses. The insight gained from one "real job" is a million times more helpful than trolling github and trying to figure out what a given project is used for in the real world.

Re: I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee

#252

I am willing to 'out' myself as a human being who has struggled with serious mental illness my whole life, if there's a chance it could help this person. I have also had a long and prosperous career, including 5 years as a senior engineer and lead at Microsoft. These two things are very nearly orthogonal. I.e. my medical history has very little to do with my employment history. But being compassionate does not requir…

He could do with some help in the near term, but in the long term he should be fine.

He needs to socialize more in an environment that will get him a job that allows him to pursue his passion and get out some more.

Perhaps some unobtrusive ads on his website geared to stuff which fits in with the leisure interests and hobbies of Lisp hackers and relate geeks should serve him well.

It will require a notice to Adblock & Noscript users that they should unblock ads and Javascript from his page as they are unobtrusive

Re: I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee

#253

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is having corporate experience really that much better though? I mean, obviously working for someone for several years implies some level of competence, but your work is nearly always locked away and you can't show it off. Ideally you'd want someone who does both; working for someone, which demonstrates the ability to work on a team, while also contributing to open source and making their own content, upon which you…

Practically speaking, yes, having corporate experience is much better. After leaving the school (I didn't graduate), I spent 2 years doing self-directed learning about computing. I have commit access to PyPy and LLVM, am credited in release notes of Mono and IronPython, and hundreds of open source commits to show off. I still had a lot of trouble landing a job. I got lucky in the end, but it was rough. You seem to ov…

I have had mostly the same experience.

On the plus side: a lot of companies care about Open Source experience and are able to evaluate it.

On the down side: companies who do it are still the minority, and you'll get a lot of competition from similar folks, who'll likely have written even more open source code than you did, and if they have had a real paid-for work experience will probably be preferred

Re: I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee

#254

I don't think anyone should judge him based on the small amount of information available. I understand that his situation is mostly his fault, but there may be other things at play. Why be so fast to condemn someone when an unfortunate sequence of events could've put some of us into a similar situation? I'm not defending Xah Lee's irresponsibility nor I am defending people who condemn him, I just want to say that we…

he still hasn't learned his lesson. he's actively asking people to send money to him in a way that skirts the lien the irs has filed against him. if the irs notices this and gets pissed, it absolutely puts his 'helpers' in harm's way. by continuing to not file taxes, the probability of irs aggression only increases with each passing day. i'm all for giving people a 2nd chance, but he still hasn't realized that it's h…

If you "buy" one of his tutorial I don't think you will get in trouble. Just don't donate or send him a check if you worry about IRS coming after you.

Re: I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee

#255
post #201

I interviewed/phone screened Xah Lee about 2 years ago. I'd never heard of him, so I skimmed over his resume and checked out his site an hour or two before the call. I remember when I was looking at his site I was seeing various articles around math and programming, and then articles about things like "2 girls 1 cup". The breadth of articles completely threw me off. He seemed to have this unfocused interest in EVERYT…

>"...internal feedback..."

Not so internal anymore! Don't get me wrong, I read your comment with interest, but then was struck with how we are talking about him as if he _was_ dead. Apparently he likes his life to be public but actual job interviews somehow strike me as private.

Re: I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee

#256
Best thing someone can do for this guy is to help him fill his taxes declaration retroactively and create a fund for him to write an Emacs book for e.g. Seems quite competent writing about Emacs, so it should be right on his alley.

Maybe someone from Apress, Pragmatic or Packt Publishing can contact him about an Emacs book.

Re: I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee

#257
post #161

Earlier quoted context omitted.

An eye for an eye, a pain-in-the-ass for a similar ass pain. "He had it coming" seems a punishment far out of balance for "making me mad on the internet".

He made a lot of people mad on the internet, enough that nobody is willing to hire him.

Well, I just bought his Emacs tutorial to help him.

Re: I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee

#258

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, I have a feeling he might have burned a few bridges. https://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-list/2005-April/355...

After reading his original post (of unnecessary expletives and excessive nitpicking) can't say I feel sorry for him

Yeah, I can't either. But he does seem to have an eye for (un)readable documentation - the things he's criticizing are completely useless for a new reader.

The invective needs to seriously get toned down, though.

Re: I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee

#259
post #127
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He is known as annoying Usenet troll by many. I don't classify him as pure troll, however. He don't troll for the sake of trolling and he can be helpful. He is very opinionated and argumentative and don't adjust his thinking very well. He might have mood disorder. http://xahlee.org/PageTwo_dir/Personal_dir/xah.html

Like Erik Naggum, which is considered a troll by many, and also a great writer w/ deep knowledge of programming languagess if can get past the troll part.

Also some folks thought the disease he had (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ulcerative_colitis) played a part in his usual "bad mood".

Re: I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee

#260
post #187

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why is porn something to hide? I dont understand it, is it because its shameful?

I think it is just US "puritan" culture. In general it is not a good idea to let a potential employer know that you are actively watching porn ... What you do in private is nobody's business, but if you do it publicly ... this could rise a red flag for an US employer.

Correct. I enjoy a fap as much as the next man but I'm not going to advert early or inadvertently blog it, because puritans and PR. No judgment of him, just that it's not helpful when approaching employers.
Post reply on HN