Live data from Hacker News

Why is Venus hell and Earth an Eden?

quantamagazine.org

251–260 of 358 posts

Re: Why is Venus hell and Earth an Eden?

#251

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If i remember right, according to one of Asimov's Foundation sequels, the Earth was unique due to its high level natural radioactivity, which allowed it to develop an ecosystem more vibrant than any other planet in the galaxy.

Wasn't Asimov a science fiction writer?

He was both a science and science fiction writer. Check out "View From a Height" for example. An excellent book.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/View_from_a_Height

Re: Why is Venus hell and Earth an Eden?

#252

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How do you deorbit Venus is such a way that your inflatable balloon city comes to a gentle stop, 30 miles up, and just floats there? Worse still, when people need to leave and return to Earth, how do you launch a rocket from the balloon city and return to orbit? How do visitors or pioneers deorbit and land at the floating city? If there aren't materials to effect a repair, how long until it sinks down into the hellzo…

> such a way that your inflatable balloon city comes to a gentle stop, 30 miles up, and just floats there? Literally how floating works. > Worse still, when people need to leave and return to Earth, how do you launch a rocket from the balloon city and return to orbit? By launching your rocket from the ballon city and returning to orbit. (I'm struggling to see the novel problem.) > Where are materials manufactured for…

You probably launch and land on a floating platform nearby. Nobody on Earth launches from a city. They launch and land in remote areas. Safety and noise. Lot of noise.

Then you fly to the colony balloon.

Re: Why is Venus hell and Earth an Eden?

#253

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> such a way that your inflatable balloon city comes to a gentle stop, 30 miles up, and just floats there? Literally how floating works. > Worse still, when people need to leave and return to Earth, how do you launch a rocket from the balloon city and return to orbit? By launching your rocket from the ballon city and returning to orbit. (I'm struggling to see the novel problem.) > Where are materials manufactured for…

I'm sure we can figure out stuff, but I guess my point is, why would we do that at all? How fucked up Earth needs to be than living on a floating oil platform above Venus is better? The point is already hard to make for the Moon or Mars.

People don't scale mount everest because there is an macguffin to be found there. They scale it to scale it. Because you can. For the adventure. To assert dominance over the universe.

We can talk about economical benefits or the survival of the species and those do matter. But it's also because colonizing another planet would be fucking epic and go down in history.

With the decline in religion we do need some kind of higher purpose and meaning to rally behind, and going off planet could fit that bill. In a time of increasing divisions it could foster brotherhood.

Re: Why is Venus hell and Earth an Eden?

#254
post #229

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Venus is room temperature with low radiation, if you dig in. Living on Venus was floating around as an easier alternative to living on the Mars surface. Room temperature is 21°C, I have no idea how many freedom fries units that is.

A shockingly useful "quick and dirty" estimate for C to F for temps humans are likely to encounter is 2x + 30. It's not precise at all, but for purposes of "what does that feel like outside" or "should I bring a sweater" it works pretty well. 21C would, by this estimate, be 72F. The true conversion is just shy of 70F, so, again, it's not correct but it's close enough for this kind of conversation.

for what it's worth: add 9 degrees F (or 18 if it's easier to remember) for every 5 degrees C (10 C, easier), and peg 32F to 0C. You get:

-40F=-40C

-22F=-30C

-4F =-20C

14F =-10C

32F = 0C

50F = 10C

68F = 20C

86F = 30C

104F= 40C

and then approximate in between from there. It's quick enough for me now that I skip the 2x+30.

Re: Why is Venus hell and Earth an Eden?

#255
post #229

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Venus is room temperature with low radiation, if you dig in. Living on Venus was floating around as an easier alternative to living on the Mars surface. Room temperature is 21°C, I have no idea how many freedom fries units that is.

> Room temperature is 21°C Debated, was 23 or 25 in my college textbooks: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_temperature > I have no idea how many freedom fries units that is. Kind of a bad attempt at humor? Imperial units is fine.

Imperialist here. Freedom fries was funny.

Re: Why is Venus hell and Earth an Eden?

#256
I've always wondered about the feasibility of adding a reflective solar shield between Venus and Sol to cut the feedback loop that keeps surface temps so high, eventually reducing cloud cover and revealing what lies beneath. In addition, such a project might be good practice in case we ever needed a modified version for Earth, and may even be useful to add energy to celestial bodies (e.g. heat up the dark side of an asteroid by placing it at the focus of a large parabolic mirror). Venus having an atmosphere and having almost the same mass as Earth has always made it, not Mars, my favorite target for terraforming and colonization.

Re: Why is Venus hell and Earth an Eden?

#257
post #41

Russian missions to Venus IMO are some of the coolest missions. That's some brave stuff to try to pull off.

can you apply 'brave' to unmanned missions? challenging, yes.

Taking a risk on a project that takes many years with a good chance of total failure can be brave.

Many people are risk averse and would find the total failure of many years of work at the very least very disappointing.

Re: Why is Venus hell and Earth an Eden?

#258

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How do you deorbit Venus is such a way that your inflatable balloon city comes to a gentle stop, 30 miles up, and just floats there? Worse still, when people need to leave and return to Earth, how do you launch a rocket from the balloon city and return to orbit? How do visitors or pioneers deorbit and land at the floating city? If there aren't materials to effect a repair, how long until it sinks down into the hellzo…

> such a way that your inflatable balloon city comes to a gentle stop, 30 miles up, and just floats there? Literally how floating works. > Worse still, when people need to leave and return to Earth, how do you launch a rocket from the balloon city and return to orbit? By launching your rocket from the ballon city and returning to orbit. (I'm struggling to see the novel problem.) > Where are materials manufactured for…

>Literally how floating works.

Yes, ignoring momentum. Do parachutes just get stuck in the air halfway down? When do you inflate it? If you inflate it, can you even deorbit? Do those pop when you deorbit? Do you cover the balloon with big heavy heat shield tiles?

I'm not claiming I understand this at all, but you seem to have some child's grasp of "how floating works".

> By launching your rocket from the ballon city and returning to orbit.

Launching from the solid ground shakes it (the ground) like a leaf. But you're going to launch a rocket from the balloon, and you can't quite see where there might be a problem.

>Why is this unique to Venus versus anywhere else in space?

If I can't get the materials to repair my building in a hurry, I go outside and I wait. Or I stay inside and I wait. And if I can't do that for my Venusian balloon city, I slowly sink into a zone that melts lead and bakes me alive. And if I get the materials after it has stared sinking, repairing it won't reinflate the balloon and have it rise again, because some significant fraction of the air has leaked out.

Re: Why is Venus hell and Earth an Eden?

#259
post #62

> For a time, the mantle would get hotter, since the shell around it would trap heat generated by radioactively decaying compounds inside it. As heat accumulates in the interior, the Earth in Kane’s simulations would experience an uptick in volcanism lasting for about 15 million years. That totally surprised to me. I had no idea radioactive decay played such a role for earth. It turns out I must have fallen sleep in…

If i remember right, according to one of Asimov's Foundation sequels, the Earth was unique due to its high level natural radioactivity, which allowed it to develop an ecosystem more vibrant than any other planet in the galaxy.

There was a mention of something like that in Starship Troopers as well.

Heinlein describes life on an earth-like planet with low radiation as being "like a kid who takes ten years to learn to wave bye-bye and never does manage to master patty-cake".

Re: Why is Venus hell and Earth an Eden?

#260
post #246
post #123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Too many dickheads with a bright idea of putting nuclear warheads on submersibles with a dead man’s switch on this planet.

Even in the event of a full-scale nuclear war, Earth would still be a more comfortable and safe place to live than Mars. It's like going to the gladiator pits to fight because someone was robbed and shot on the next street yesterday and you don't think your street is safe enough.

[dead]
Post reply on HN