Live data from Hacker News

Airbnb is banning indoor security cameras

theverge.com

251–260 of 527 posts

Re: Airbnb is banning indoor security cameras

#251
post #48
post #22

I'm worried this ban will only affect honest hosts. Anyway, what Airbnb should really ban is hosts charging a mandatory cleaning fee when also requiring their guests to do the cleaning. We just stayed at one this weekend, and like almost all our previous bookings, the host asked us to: - Take off all bedding and towels and start a load of laundry - Do all the dishes and start the dishwasher (but required to hand-wash…

At this point the cleaning fees are just a scam to make the listing fee seem artificially lower. People did the same thing on eBay by making the items almost free but the shipping expensive, until they fixed the eBay interface, e.g. by letting you sort by price + shipping and showing shipping fees before you click.

I'm not a fan of how AirBnB has displayed pricing in the past, but don't lose sight of how bad hotel pricing is: taxes and fees not displayed until the checkout page, "resort" fees added at any time, etc.

There are no good guys here.

Re: Airbnb is banning indoor security cameras

#252
post #251
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At this point the cleaning fees are just a scam to make the listing fee seem artificially lower. People did the same thing on eBay by making the items almost free but the shipping expensive, until they fixed the eBay interface, e.g. by letting you sort by price + shipping and showing shipping fees before you click.

I'm not a fan of how AirBnB has displayed pricing in the past, but don't lose sight of how bad hotel pricing is: taxes and fees not displayed until the checkout page, "resort" fees added at any time, etc. There are no good guys here.

Maybe that's the US hotel booking experience, I live in Europe and haven't encountered those dumb fees.

Re: Airbnb is banning indoor security cameras

#253

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Cleaning fees aren't a "scam" - most property owners really do need to pay someone to clean the property at the end of a stay. I'm willing to pay a cleaning fee (though really it should be rolled into the cost of the stay) but not also be required to do the cleaning myself.

If you rent an apartment in my neck of the woods, then this is exactly what the law is. If your landlord charges a cleaning fee you can feel free to let them clean it up at the end of the rental period.

The only reason anyone does the cleaning is because the host can then leave a poor review. Does the law cover this angle?

Re: Airbnb is banning indoor security cameras

#254

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, scam is the right word. It could pretty easily be rolled into the advertised nightly rate.

I get an itemized bill from the grocery store, but that doesn't make it a scam.

What if they charged you a fee because they now have to restock the bananas that you removed from their display?

Re: Airbnb is banning indoor security cameras

#255
post #22

I'm worried this ban will only affect honest hosts. Anyway, what Airbnb should really ban is hosts charging a mandatory cleaning fee when also requiring their guests to do the cleaning. We just stayed at one this weekend, and like almost all our previous bookings, the host asked us to: - Take off all bedding and towels and start a load of laundry - Do all the dishes and start the dishwasher (but required to hand-wash…

I don’t understand why this is a worry. There’s no such thing as an in-room security camera in a hotel. Airbnb should have had a clear ban on indoor security cameras a long time ago.

You might as well say that “laws only apply to law-abiding people.” That’s not a reason to not have laws.

Re: Airbnb is banning indoor security cameras

#256
I find it sad how Airbnb has taken a market that worked (in many places) and re introduced all the problems that have been resolved through decades of regulations being put in place for hotels etc.

Chances of finding a camera in a hotel room are near zero while at Airbnb you have no idea what kind of pervert the renter is. At this point prices for Airbnb have rissen so high why not get a hotel?

It's like we don't learn at all from history or just like to forget so we can make an extra buck.

Re: Airbnb is banning indoor security cameras

#257
post #165
post #22

I'm worried this ban will only affect honest hosts. Anyway, what Airbnb should really ban is hosts charging a mandatory cleaning fee when also requiring their guests to do the cleaning. We just stayed at one this weekend, and like almost all our previous bookings, the host asked us to: - Take off all bedding and towels and start a load of laundry - Do all the dishes and start the dishwasher (but required to hand-wash…

There is no situation where cameras are acceptable in another person's living space, so whether this only affects honest hosts is irrelevant; as long as it reduces usage, it is a good thing. Imagine hotels arguing for allowing cameras in their suites because they are "honest".

I believe the argument is that dishonest hotels will simply say "Yep, we got rid of cameras too!" without actually doing so.

Re: Airbnb is banning indoor security cameras

#258
post #207

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That’s how you get a bad review and charges for $800 to replace a napkin. Airbnb will side with the host, not you.

This doesn't actually happen even discounting the hyperbole. Airbnb sides with guests for little things. And hosts are much more affected by a bad review than a guest is.

Of course not a napkin, but it’s happened to me that they pushed made up charges on to me. So you can’t tell me it doesn’t happen. A friend of mine came to visit me and stayed at a place for one night. They hit him with smokers damage. Not only he doesn’t smoke but also he was there only to sleep. How Do you even fight that?

Re: Airbnb is banning indoor security cameras

#259
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At this point the cleaning fees are just a scam to make the listing fee seem artificially lower. People did the same thing on eBay by making the items almost free but the shipping expensive, until they fixed the eBay interface, e.g. by letting you sort by price + shipping and showing shipping fees before you click.

Airbnb is a marketplace with a much wider range of "products" than standard hotels. I have found stays that fit my needs far better than any hotel ever could. I am both a host on Airbnb and frequent guest. Airbnb's UI needs to guide prospective guests toward specifying what they are looking for so that prices (and price sorting) actually meets their expectations. If you search for a specific date range with # of gues…

I've used Airbnb 25 times. 12 of those times had issues. Issues like

"parking space included" - show up, no parking

"wifi included" - show up, wifi is sitting next to window and stealing from neighbor

listed on quiet road - after booking address is changed to unit on busy road

heater is so loud it sounds like a vacuum cleaner making getting any sleep hard

I no longer use AirBnB period. Hotels have extra rooms, reception, cleaning, etc. I'm not saying hotels are perfect but at least for me, the positive experience rate is 90% vs AirBnB which is 50%

AirBnb also lost the price wars, at least as the places I've looked.

Post reply on HN