Live data from Hacker News

Mozilla 2023 annual report: CEO pay skyrockets, Firefox market share nosedives

lunduke.locals.com

251–260 of 349 posts

Re: Mozilla 2023 annual report: CEO pay skyrockets, Firefox market share nosedives

#251

Wow, nearly 7 million. That’s incredible for a nonprofit CEO. Much, much large orgs have CEOs that get paid 10-15x less. This should be criminal. The taxpayers are being stolen from.

Which taxpayers exactly are you referring to?

Whoever is funding them can claim charitable donations as part of a write-off - I guess that's opportunity cost to the treasury?

Mozilla is a tar pit designed to prevent alternative browsers forming. Firefox deserves better.

Re: Mozilla 2023 annual report: CEO pay skyrockets, Firefox market share nosedives

#252
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the situation is simple. They are rendering one service that their users value, and it is making Firefox. They should ask (not require) payment for that service. Yes, what they should do is basically to run a Patreon subscription, clearly marked "For the continued development of Firefox". At a very accessible level of $3 / mo on average , and merely 5M subscribers over the world, they'd have $15M monthly, or…

They have a donate button. Which is all about subscriptions. Which is why I went away without even doing a one time donation, as my original intention was. I deeply resent being pushed into subscriptions and you should too.

One-time donations must always be an option.

But it's a recurring revenue what allows you e.g. to hire developers. Sad but true.

Re: Mozilla 2023 annual report: CEO pay skyrockets, Firefox market share nosedives

#253

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wouldn't that be easy to verify by just looking at the relative market shares of different browsers and checking if there is an 'unknown' browser whose market share is increasing proportionately to Firefox's decrease?

Not if the metrics come solely from analytics like GA. It would appear as an absolute decline in browser numbers instead (which would probably be indistinguishable from noise in most samples).

All I'm saying is you just need a table like this:

    | Year | Firefox | Chrome | Other |
    | 2020 |     20% |    75% |    5% |
    | 2021 |     19% |    75% |    6% |
    | 2022 |     18% |    75% |    7% |
This would make it pretty obvious, no?

Re: Mozilla 2023 annual report: CEO pay skyrockets, Firefox market share nosedives

#254

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not if the metrics come solely from analytics like GA. It would appear as an absolute decline in browser numbers instead (which would probably be indistinguishable from noise in most samples).

All I'm saying is you just need a table like this: | Year | Firefox | Chrome | Other | | 2020 | 20% | 75% | 5% | | 2021 | 19% | 75% | 6% | | 2022 | 18% | 75% | 7% | This would make it pretty obvious, no?

No, because there are multiple independent variables there: OEM mobile browsers, for example, and the fact that the overall number and distribution of observed browsers is not static.

Re: Mozilla 2023 annual report: CEO pay skyrockets, Firefox market share nosedives

#255
post #188

Earlier quoted context omitted.

at least boot2gecko made 1000x more sense than a painfully vague "focus on AI"

I love FF and T-bird hard, but I have this mental image of a huddle full of brilliant, 20-year-plus systems engineers sitting in a room staring at a whiteboard with 'AI?' in the middle of it. "Ok, everybody popcorn up some ideas. Don't be shy." [one of them opens a laptop and begins fiddling with a flame graph]

So Bighead and Gavin Belson?

https://youtu.be/CFsRif1wVGs?si=5939fsuM2AigbB_9

Re: Mozilla 2023 annual report: CEO pay skyrockets, Firefox market share nosedives

#256

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> if more people used their browser more they might invest more in it Let me donate to support Firefox. Firefox, only. Hell, she can even skim off the top for her pay. They don’t do this because it would trash the gravy train. So Firefox is held hostage to support a litany of nonsense that lets them travel to conferences to speak about AI.

Okay, so what is complaining achieving here since you already acknowledge they won’t let you donate to Firefox directly? I’m not crazy about it either but I don’t lose sleep over it. It’s a browser and management could be better. I know it’s a touchy subject and people may not like to hear it but until I’m downvoted into oblivion I’m going to say this discussion is not worth rehashing time and time again. The donatio…

> what is complaining achieving here since you already acknowledge they won’t let you donate to Firefox directly?

That usage isn’t what’s constraining Firefox’s resources. Management is. Use Firefox if you like it. (I do, in part.) But don’t argue that if more people use it Mozilla will give a shit; it’s already a material fraction of their revenues and they’re ignoring it.

Re: Mozilla 2023 annual report: CEO pay skyrockets, Firefox market share nosedives

#257

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Okay, so what is complaining achieving here since you already acknowledge they won’t let you donate to Firefox directly? I’m not crazy about it either but I don’t lose sleep over it. It’s a browser and management could be better. I know it’s a touchy subject and people may not like to hear it but until I’m downvoted into oblivion I’m going to say this discussion is not worth rehashing time and time again. The donatio…

> what is complaining achieving here since you already acknowledge they won’t let you donate to Firefox directly? That usage isn’t what’s constraining Firefox’s resources. Management is. Use Firefox if you like it. (I do, in part.) But don’t argue that if more people use it Mozilla will give a shit; it’s already a material fraction of their revenues and they’re ignoring it.

I will. If usage increased enough they would. The more users they have the more important their search becomes, gives them greater leverage and an audience to market products at. Unlike Google/Microsoft/Apple, they do not have a strong platform to reach users with and need something to coalesce a consumer-centric Mozilla ecosystem around.

At the moment, it is unclear how much extra money, devoted to improving what, would increase Firefox’s market share significantly and am not surprised to see them explore other options. Brave, Vivaldi, etc, don’t seem to have figured it out either.

I choose not to be cynical, nor will I allow myself to be upset about it one way or another and wish others would do the same.

Being negative is more likely to scare off new users/contributors than change Mozilla.

Re: Mozilla 2023 annual report: CEO pay skyrockets, Firefox market share nosedives

#258

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is definitely a downward usage trend from Mozilla own stats. https://data.firefox.com/dashboard/user-activity

Right; nobody is claiming that Firefox is doing well. But that downward trend is not proportionate with the claimed global downward trend; it's much smaller.

Firefox has lost over 20 million users in 2 years.

Jan 3 2021 210,085,100

Jan 1 2023 193,199,300

Dec 17 2023 185,599,100

Re: Mozilla 2023 annual report: CEO pay skyrockets, Firefox market share nosedives

#259
Owncloud was forked to become Nextcloud and seems to have gotten better for it.

Openoffice was forked to become Libreoffice and seems to have gotten beter for it.

Time to fork Firefox [1] and take over where Baker dropped the ball because she thought the rules of the game could be changed to make it no longer necessary to play to win.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38533785

Re: Mozilla 2023 annual report: CEO pay skyrockets, Firefox market share nosedives

#260

Wow, nearly 7 million. That’s incredible for a nonprofit CEO. Much, much large orgs have CEOs that get paid 10-15x less. This should be criminal. The taxpayers are being stolen from.

Mozilla Corporation is not a non-profit. It engages in many business relationships and brings in about half a billion dollars a year. How much should the founder-CEO of a 25 year old company with half a billion a year in revenue be making?
Post reply on HN