Live data from Hacker News

700M users and Premium

telegram.org

251–260 of 330 posts

Re: 700M users and Premium

#251

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And what about all the times you talked about things on WhatsApp and Facebook didn’t start showing you ads about whatever? Confirmation bias is a hell of a thing; it works in many different ways. Personally over years of usage I’ve never had WhatsApp convos trigger ads.

Majority of people I talk to are Messenger, LINE, and Telegram. So I only have a few people on Facebook. The Business accounts 100% cause me to get advertising on facebook. For example last week the butcher I used to purchase from in Singapore messaged me from his business account advertising arrival of new meat. Boom I get advertising for meat products in Singapore and Taiwan. The issue is, I have only 3 chats happe…

Business account chat logs are read by Facebook because the chats are sent via other means than WhatsApp. I don’t believe you can verify identity on business accounts either anyway so that’s moot.

As for your other examples, as I said, it’s all very circumstantial and coincidental. Not evidence. Your accusation is more serious than you think, and serious accusations need serious evidence.

Re: 700M users and Premium

#252

Telegram blows my mind. Say what you want about their security; they have the absolute best UX of any (primarily 1-on-1) messaging app, bar none. Discord is a close second. But the quality and polish of telegram blows me away to this day. And it’s lots of small features and details such as built in translation for messages in a foreign language, all the smooth animations, quick look and summaries of channels with agg…

Telegram UX still has a lot of place to improve. E.g. I hate being unable to pin more than five chats an having to hunt the rest as they jump around.

You can pin more chats with premium; it’s in the announcement.

Re: 700M users and Premium

#253

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You must have missed all the very suspicious information about Durov's close ties with Russian authorities, and that Telegram developers worked from the same office with VK in Saint-Petersburg when he claimed that they are in Germany. [1] Good choice for a dissident! (No) [1]: https://medium.com/@anton.rozenberg/friendship-betrayal-clai...

>You must have missed all the very suspicious information about Durov's close ties with Russian authorities That's rather fine in the event you don't want the Five Eyes to spy on you and you don't care if Putin reads your messages when he eats his breakfast.

agree.

messenger privacy is not a function of technology unfortunately.

the only real choice is which powerblock (us,ru,ch) can read your conversation

Re: 700M users and Premium

#254
post #222

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why only the choice between WhatsApp and Telegram? What about Signal, Wire, Threema?

Threema costs money, which is a showstopper for mass adoption.

"Costs money" sounds nice - I would prefer a service where I am a customer rather than a commodity.

Re: 700M users and Premium

#255

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder if you would also claim "rule of law" when let's say North Korea tries banning the German news infrastructure world-wide, or Iran bans depiction of unveiled women on the internet, or China starts going against Wikipedia with an enforceable worldwide ban because Tiannamen never happened. It is the nature of an international network that you cannot reasonably expect your government's laws to have any say on a…

well I don't think that and nobody demanded that. Telegram merely has to comply regionally concerning in this case German users or content shown to them. Tech companies differentiating their products to comply with local laws is common practice.

> nobody demanded that

European (and for that matter, Canadian[1]) courts wanting stuff gone internationally is well-documented[2]. It is not unconceivable that German enforcement agencies would use similar tactics. Once you give them the small finger, they will take the whole arm.

[1] https://scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/16701/inde... [2] https://www.heise.de/news/Gericht-Facebook-muss-bei-Rechtsve...

Re: 700M users and Premium

#257

Telegram blows my mind. Say what you want about their security; they have the absolute best UX of any (primarily 1-on-1) messaging app, bar none. Discord is a close second. But the quality and polish of telegram blows me away to this day. And it’s lots of small features and details such as built in translation for messages in a foreign language, all the smooth animations, quick look and summaries of channels with agg…

Checkout it's memory footprint on desktop. It is not using typical web tech (aka electron). It's just C++ & QT.

List of third-party tech in their desktop stack listed here:

https://github.com/telegramdesktop/tdesktop

Re: 700M users and Premium

#258

Telegram blows my mind. Say what you want about their security; they have the absolute best UX of any (primarily 1-on-1) messaging app, bar none. Discord is a close second. But the quality and polish of telegram blows me away to this day. And it’s lots of small features and details such as built in translation for messages in a foreign language, all the smooth animations, quick look and summaries of channels with agg…

> Say what you want about their security; they have the absolute best UX of any (primarily 1-on-1) messaging app, bar none. > Discord is a close second. But the quality and polish of telegram blows me away to this day. User experience is, well, subjective to the user. For tech savvy, primarily desktop users, Telegram and Discord can be great choices. This is however probably not true for the majority of the populatio…

>This is however probably not true for the majority of the population.

Apparently it is true for 700M people

Re: 700M users and Premium

#259

Telegram blows my mind. Say what you want about their security; they have the absolute best UX of any (primarily 1-on-1) messaging app, bar none. Discord is a close second. But the quality and polish of telegram blows me away to this day. And it’s lots of small features and details such as built in translation for messages in a foreign language, all the smooth animations, quick look and summaries of channels with agg…

> Say what you want about their security; they have the absolute best UX of any (primarily 1-on-1) messaging app, bar none. That is precisely because they don't give a shit about security. While others like Whatsapp bother with e2ee and resulting device sync problems and inability to do server-side search, Telegram just stores everything on a server without (meaningful) encryption and boldly claims that 'it is the mo…

The most secure messenger...that just so happens to be developed by a Russian company headquartered in the same building as VK, a known Kremlin-controlled social media network!

https://theoutline.com/post/2348/what-isn-t-telegram-saying-...

Re: 700M users and Premium

#260

Telegram blows my mind. Say what you want about their security; they have the absolute best UX of any (primarily 1-on-1) messaging app, bar none. Discord is a close second. But the quality and polish of telegram blows me away to this day. And it’s lots of small features and details such as built in translation for messages in a foreign language, all the smooth animations, quick look and summaries of channels with agg…

> Say what you want about their security; they have the absolute best UX of any (primarily 1-on-1) messaging app, bar none. That is precisely because they don't give a shit about security. While others like Whatsapp bother with e2ee and resulting device sync problems and inability to do server-side search, Telegram just stores everything on a server without (meaningful) encryption and boldly claims that 'it is the mo…

e2ee in whatsapp is a joke. e2ee with close source clients, closed protocol, backup functions, sorry... that's not real e2ee, that's a marketing ploy.

signal does marginally better.

real e2ee is possible with XMPP and Omemo iirc. but as others have pointed out that's not UXy enough to compete with Telegram for the mainsteam.

Post reply on HN