Live data from Hacker News

FTC Puts Hundreds of Businesses on Notice about Fake Reviews

ftc.gov

251–260 of 281 posts

Re: FTC Puts Hundreds of Businesses on Notice about Fake Reviews

#251
post #134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would have called this conspiracy territory, but then it broke that Amazon was doing exactly that in India. https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/amazon-i...

I would have called this conspiracy territory It is a conspiracy theory. Some of them are just true.

Touché

Re: FTC Puts Hundreds of Businesses on Notice about Fake Reviews

#252

Generally I'd say product reviews are one of those ideas like passwords that work but don't survive introduction to the general public and mass use. The problems of authenticity are obvious, but I've also noticed that people who rely on word of mouth from their friends and colleagues are generally happier. And why wouldn't they be? A colleague tells you this e.g. monitor is perfect for your line of work so you get it…

> I try to buy stuff in shops now.

Plus, it's better for your local economy -- your friends and neighbors.

Re: FTC Puts Hundreds of Businesses on Notice about Fake Reviews

#254

Generally I'd say product reviews are one of those ideas like passwords that work but don't survive introduction to the general public and mass use. The problems of authenticity are obvious, but I've also noticed that people who rely on word of mouth from their friends and colleagues are generally happier. And why wouldn't they be? A colleague tells you this e.g. monitor is perfect for your line of work so you get it…

Stop trying to make no passwords happen. It won't happen

"But people will never let their on-prem servers go into an obscure, shared Cloud".

Re: FTC Puts Hundreds of Businesses on Notice about Fake Reviews

#255

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Email a login link or temp pw. Passwords gone.

Maybe I'm missing something. You're just replacing the "password" by asking the user to login their email. It doesn't move us any closer to a "no password" world, unless there is also a proposal on how to make email password-less?

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2...

Re: FTC Puts Hundreds of Businesses on Notice about Fake Reviews

#256

Generally I'd say product reviews are one of those ideas like passwords that work but don't survive introduction to the general public and mass use. The problems of authenticity are obvious, but I've also noticed that people who rely on word of mouth from their friends and colleagues are generally happier. And why wouldn't they be? A colleague tells you this e.g. monitor is perfect for your line of work so you get it…

This is a big reason I think influencer marketing is picking up steam. Everyone knows that reviews and SEO can be gamed, with little to no consequence. If an influencer tells you something is good, at least their reputation is on the line. If they continually sell out, they kill the golden goose.

So, as dumb as it sounds, influencer reviews are higher signal to me than typical online reviews.

Re: FTC Puts Hundreds of Businesses on Notice about Fake Reviews

#257

Generally I'd say product reviews are one of those ideas like passwords that work but don't survive introduction to the general public and mass use. The problems of authenticity are obvious, but I've also noticed that people who rely on word of mouth from their friends and colleagues are generally happier. And why wouldn't they be? A colleague tells you this e.g. monitor is perfect for your line of work so you get it…

Stop trying to make no passwords happen. It won't happen

Password reset is almost as good as no passwords but with the added benefit of MFA.

Re: FTC Puts Hundreds of Businesses on Notice about Fake Reviews

#258

As a rule, I always check the four, three, and two star reviews since they have the least propensity for a scammer to create and waste time. 1 and 5 star reviews usually are an inane mix of "They're TERRIBLE" or "FANTASTIC" with no additional information, whereas the 2,3, and 4 star reviews will normally go into specifics that warranted the stars being removed. Not only that, but they are normally much fewer in numbe…

I just read the 1 and 2 star reviews looking for trends. Most of them are complaining about things the product doesn't have (but they knew that before they bought it), or specific little things they don't like about the product (but no one else cares). But there are some specific things that many people will complain about, and those are the reviews that matter, because those are the real problems with the product. If I think I can't live without the problems that many people are complaining about, I'll pass on the product.

Re: FTC Puts Hundreds of Businesses on Notice about Fake Reviews

#259

Generally I'd say product reviews are one of those ideas like passwords that work but don't survive introduction to the general public and mass use. The problems of authenticity are obvious, but I've also noticed that people who rely on word of mouth from their friends and colleagues are generally happier. And why wouldn't they be? A colleague tells you this e.g. monitor is perfect for your line of work so you get it…

This is a big reason I think influencer marketing is picking up steam. Everyone knows that reviews and SEO can be gamed, with little to no consequence. If an influencer tells you something is good, at least their reputation is on the line. If they continually sell out, they kill the golden goose. So, as dumb as it sounds, influencer reviews are higher signal to me than typical online reviews.

> at least their reputation is on the line

I don't think it is though, the sort of people who follow influencers generally aren't blessed with the greatest critical thinking skills.

Re: FTC Puts Hundreds of Businesses on Notice about Fake Reviews

#260
post #113

Good. Now also fine game companies releasing broken products. Fine any company selling products with "warranty void if removed" stickers. Mass shut down fake sale websites that do not sell the product imaged. I want to see the ftc breaking down doors and deleting entire companies off the face of the earth for their illigal practices. I can dream of course.

> Now also fine game companies releasing broken products. Do you have any example where this happened?

This really is something you just Google, it's not uncommon at all. I just Googled "broken game release" and all I saw were examples. Cyberpunk was a recent high profile one.
Post reply on HN