Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Do you have a 3d printer?

news.ycombinator.com

241–250 of 281 posts

Re: Poll: Do you have a 3d printer?

#241

I've built the RepRapPro Mendel from a kit about 2 months ago. Don't have any "real" use for it - it's just a cool toy to have, considering it doesn't cost that much (paid 640 EUR for the kit). But it may come very useful if I try to build some hobby RC plane or quadcopter though. Anyway, it's been working nice so far, though I did spend many hours tuning the machine and getting to know the various software (CAD, sli…

Hello, I'm a reprap developer. What specific intelligence do you have in mind? Want to come in to #reprap on freenode and tell us about it?

I do come in #reprap often (nick ambro718).

For example, fan control could be made volumetric, based around how much filament is below the extrusion, not just the whole layer time. The bridge detection in Slic3r is a very restricted form of this - done more generally, fan speed would be increased for bridges, overhangs and non-first layers of bridges.

Another example, the physics of the extruder operation could be taken into account, to prevent fat corners and similar. I know some firmware can do this already, but I've never found it sufficient. I know it is somehow unclear whether this goes into the firmware of the g-code - but if it goes in the g-code, that means it should work with all firmwares. I think that ideally you could program anything you want in g-code, without the need to change firmware.

Bridge sagging could be accounted for in some way. I've seem cases where you have very sparse infill, and the first filled layer after that is very sagged - up to 3 top layer may be needed to get the top straight.

Finally, slicers are generally buggy (just check the Slic3r issue tracker!). I may sometime get a bit more involved with slicer development, but it's a whole new area, and lots of existing code that needs to be understood until I can make proper improvements.

Re: Poll: Do you have a 3d printer?

#242

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What do you suggest in arduino's place?

Raspberry pi. Or better, the new beaglebone black. Anything with more than 10 kb of ram, really.

I don't think you can compare RPI to Arduino at all. Arduino is certainly not an obsolete technology. There are lots of projects where prototyping with an Arduino and finishing the project with a super cheap AVR chip is the way to go.

Re: Poll: Do you have a 3d printer?

#243
post #193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're never gonna print that car at a Kinkos.

You wouldn't download a car.

Please don't leave 0 content/0 effort redditeqsue replies here. If you want to post memes and not contribute you can do that at Reddit.

Re: Poll: Do you have a 3d printer?

#244

Where's the option for "I don't have one now and don't have any plans to buy one, but that might change as the technology evolves." Never seems too strong a word in option 3.

Yes, I agree. At least when/if the technology becomes ubiquitous. If I'd had to answer this poll in 1995, and it had said "mobile phone" rather than "3d printer", I'd have said "never". I didn't (and don't) particularly need one, but it's almost assumed these days that everybody has one (at least where I live), so I got one. I can easily see a future where simple parts are not bought, but printed, and every household is expected to have a 3d printer, much like how they're expected to have a phone or a TV today. If that day comes, I'll probably get one - but it may be far off, or never happen at all.

Re: Poll: Do you have a 3d printer?

#247
post #238
post #193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You wouldn't download a car.

For some reason, your comment reminds me of those anti-piracy adverts they show on DVDs (in the UK) that you've legitimately bought: "You wouldn't steal a car." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2023878

If I could make a perfect copy of a car out of thin air, without depriving anyone of anything, I would "steal it". So would absolutely everyone, and the motor industry would have to change their business model.
Post reply on HN