Live data from Hacker News

The quiet renovation at Bitwarden

blog.ppb1701.com

241–250 of 333 posts

Re: The quiet renovation at Bitwarden

#241

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Does a bear shit in the woods?

Interesting, where are you from? Where does this proverb come from? I know this proverb as (translating from Polish): You're asking the boar if he's shitting in the forest.

It's an extremely common phrase in the US, along with "Is the Pope Catholic?" Sometimes the two phrases are humorously mixed together.

Re: The quiet renovation at Bitwarden

#242
post #82

I started looking for a replacement when I noticed how much RAM the extension was using. >1GB for a password manager seems ridiculous. I'm currently debating between Keepassium and Strongbox but I wonder if there is something better.

Strongbox already got bought out, but it's still very good and you can store the file wherever you want.

Re: The quiet renovation at Bitwarden

#244
Besides vaultwarden, I have been testing both AliasVault and peerpass, there’s also passbolt for self hosting. That being said, keep a copy of your vault in keepassXC, and better, don’t put your eggs in one basket so 2FA in keepassXC and passwords in one of the above.

Re: The quiet renovation at Bitwarden

#245
post #205

At this point it is too high of a risk to store my password elsewhere. I've been screwed over by dashlane, lastpass, potentially bitwarden now, I am with 1password now, but I've had my passwords in all these places, and I've had to change them each time, probably missing a few. I like 1password, it is by far the highest quality product I've used in this category. I moved from BitWarden back then because their browser…

keepass files + syncthing works very nicely for me. For non technical people, I just recommend to use the browser built in password managers. traviso has a good writeup why: https://lock.cmpxchg8b.com/passmgrs.html

[deleted]

Re: The quiet renovation at Bitwarden

#246

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If I stay offline for more than 30 days, can I still access my local passwords? Honest question, because if that's the case it's nice, but I think you'd need to somehow authenticate before accessing your local vault.

If you’re self-hosting, and not using their official clients, your database stays functional in perpetuity.

Which client? Is there a unofficial client for android that doesn't expire?

Re: The quiet renovation at Bitwarden

#247
post #208
post #206

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How were you screwed over by these products?

Rug-pulls, security incidents, lost passwords, I also don't know if they've kept my passwords behind when i deleted my accounts. The risk of them having them is too high, so i had to swap all of them.

Interesting! I've been a LastPass and then 1Password user since 2009ish.

I left LastPass because of UX paper-cuts, but I've never lost passwords on either of them.

Honestly, it's something I don't want to think about and just need it to work on mobile and desktop, so the switching friction is very high for me. I'm not going to shop around and try different password managers.

Is "rug pull" a cost thing? I'm generally frugal, but pay for a family plan and don't think twice.

Re: The quiet renovation at Bitwarden

#248

When I first learnt about Bitwarden about 3 years ago, I started hosting Vaultwarden right away. Right now I have one instance for myself and another for my friend's company. Everything runs as smooth as butter. If you can self-host something, do self-host a Vaultwarden instance. If you are (like me) somewhat paranoid about the fact that Vaultwarden hasn't got a proper security audit on its codebase, just run it behi…

> If you are (like me) somewhat paranoid about the fact that Vaultwarden hasn't got a proper security audit on its codebase [...]

It was audited in 2024: https://www.heise.de/en/news/Password-manager-BSI-reports-cr...

Re: The quiet renovation at Bitwarden

#249
post #216

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’ve used Vaultwarden for at lesst 7 years, I’m sure for longer but I’m not sure how long. Never had an issue with Vaultwarden itself. Restored from backups several times for a variety of reasons (migrating host, corrupt hard disk, re-installs) and that always worked first try. In regards to hardering, the wiki has a good guide: https://github.com/dani-garcia/vaultwarden/wiki/Hardening-Gu... .

That guide is wild. By default it allows public registration, shows password hints, requires a reverse proxy for robust TLS but then passes tokens via GET params, runs in the container as root. Recommends fail2ban because it doesn't have any coverage against brute force. Recommends using a custom path for security. This feels less like a guide on hardening Vaultwarden than a guide on why I should be skeptical about i…

Since it's authored by the vaultwarden collaborators, I would not trust the project any bit of my passwords.
Post reply on HN