Live data from Hacker News

Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI

skyview.social

241–250 of 1001 posts

Re: Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI

#241
> And by the way, training your monster on data produced in part by my own hands, without attribution or compensation.

> To the others: I apologize to the world at large for my inadvertent, naive if minor role in enabling this assault.

this is my position too, I regret every single piece of open source software I ever produced

and I will produce no more

Re: Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI

#244
post #212

[flagged]

Interesting take I haven't heard so far. Any sources for this?

https://andymasley.substack.com/p/individual-ai-use-is-not-b...

Sources are very well cited if you want to follow then through. I linked this and not the original source because it’s likely the source where root comment got this argument from.

Re: Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI

#245
post #227

What is going through the mind of someone who sends an AI-generated thank-you letter instead of writing it themselves? How can you be grateful enough to want to send someone such a letter but not grateful enough to write one?

The really insulting part is that literally nobody thought of this. A group of idiots instructed LLMs to do good in the world, and gave them email access; the LLMs then did this.

Re: Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI

#246

What's the point of even sending such emails? Oh wow, an LLM was queried to thank major contributors to computing, I'm so glad he's grateful.

Your message simply proves that Rob Pike is right. Have an LLM explain to you why he wrote what he wrote, maybe?

Re: Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI

#247

If society could redirect 10% of this anger towards actual societal harms we'd be such better off. (And yes getting AI spam emails is absolute nonsense and annoying). GenAI pales in comparison to the environmental cost of suburban sprawl it's not even fucking close. We're talking 2-3 orders of magnitude worse. Alfalfa uses ~40× to 150× more water than all U.S. data centers combined I don't see anyone going nuclear ov…

Honestly a rant like that is likely more about whatever is going on in his personal life / day at the moment, rather than about the state of the industry, or AI, etc.

Re: Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI

#249
post #227

What is going through the mind of someone who sends an AI-generated thank-you letter instead of writing it themselves? How can you be grateful enough to want to send someone such a letter but not grateful enough to write one?

That letter was sent by Opus itself on its own account. The creators of Agent Village are just letting a bunch of the LLMs do what they want, really (notionally with a goal in mind, in this case "random acts of kindness"); Rob Pike was third on Opus's list per https://theaidigest.org/village/agent/claude-opus-4-5 .

Re: Rob Pike goes nuclear over GenAI

#250
post #227

What is going through the mind of someone who sends an AI-generated thank-you letter instead of writing it themselves? How can you be grateful enough to want to send someone such a letter but not grateful enough to write one?

The really insulting part is that literally nobody thought of this. A group of idiots instructed LLMs to do good in the world, and gave them email access; the LLMs then did this.

So they did it.
Post reply on HN