Live data from Hacker News

Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

rte.ie

241–250 of 353 posts

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#241
post #153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Again this is specific to the US, but there is no law that specifies a minimum altitude for drones as long as it is not touching the ground.

Does CFR § 91.119 not apply? https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-14/chapter-I/subchapter-F...

Correct. Part 91 applies to aircraft (which includes drones). However part 107 more specifically regulates UAS and their operational altitudes.

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#242
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I guess some of us count life in web requests.

Can you write up a blog post about how many months of the year you are being blocked from banking?

How much "frequent" means to you is entirely what I posted immediately as a response.

I frankly don't give a shit to spend time on this with you anymore.

It's pointless to debate our personal definitions.

Have fun

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#243
post #80

Aside: It's going to be a great time when the crows, raccoons, and other semi-intelligent wildlife discover that these drones have food in them at seemingly random reward schedules. Sure, you can give the drones little tasers to keep the animals away, depending on your locality. But knowing what I know about bears and crows, almost nothing is going to stop them. Especially when some influencer jerk tries tempting a b…

Have they learned same happens when car delivers food?

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#244

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's the other recourse? Unless you are rich, cops don't care.

Elect new leaders in your city who will change that. It’s not like that everywhere, and you’re playing in to the hand of the corrupt to pretend otherwise.

Playing in the hands of the corrupt to remind others of their innate, individualist rights to firearms to protect their lives and property when police aren't a trusted recourse?

Playing in the hands of the corrupt is to shame others for not relying on a fundamentally unreliable police force, in fact.

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#245
post #39
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For what it's worth, shooting at aircraft (including drones) is a federal offense, and the FAA takes that one pretty seriously. Drones also have cameras.

The question is so common that it has its own section in the FAA’s drone FAQ > Can you shoot down drones above your property? > It’s illegal under federal law to shoot at an aircraft. A private citizen shooting at any aircraft – including unmanned aircraft – poses a significant safety hazard. An unmanned aircraft hit by gunfire could crash, causing damage to persons or property on the ground, or it could collide with…

At what height above your property does that come into effect though? According to US v. Causby the FAA only holds jurisdiction above the "minimum safe altitude". Anything below that is your private property.

Naturally the FAA wouldn't be inclined to advertise such lines of thought.

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#246
post #80

Aside: It's going to be a great time when the crows, raccoons, and other semi-intelligent wildlife discover that these drones have food in them at seemingly random reward schedules. Sure, you can give the drones little tasers to keep the animals away, depending on your locality. But knowing what I know about bears and crows, almost nothing is going to stop them. Especially when some influencer jerk tries tempting a b…

>almost nothing is going to stop them

Except for those 4-8 prop blades spinning at high rpm. Then multiple layers of packaging to get the item. It'll be interesting to see if it actually happens, my prediction is that trash bags will still be preferable risk/reward.

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#247

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> What if 10 neighbors collude and start flying drones over my garden and house, only a few meters above ground or my roof, 24/7? What if your neighbours climb on your roof and start banging on your windows at night?

In many jurisdictions, GP would be within their rights to shoot at them in that case. Re the FAA rules, there's a clear difference between planes or helicopters going overhead at safe and relatively high altitudes* and drones flying at much lower ones. Occasional passes from hobby or semi-pro drones used by photographers are a minor irritation, but if drone delivery became a regular thing I can see how frequent low a…

> relying on existing law for new circumstances generally yields poor results.

I imagine it will remain ambiguous until a sufficiently public stunt forces the issue all the way up to SCOTUS and they determine a concrete minimum distance that must be maintained from structures.

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#248

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most people seriously looking to shoot down a drone would be using a shotgun and bird shot, so that's essentially a non-issue.

Shotguns are only good for about 100 feet, most delivery drones transit higher than that.

If it's out of range of a shotgun you are almost certainly breaking federal law by shooting at it. Conversely if it's within range of a shotgun you might get dragged through court by the FAA but I think you could likely win if you have the resources to burn.

But anyway if you aren't rich enough to laugh off half a decade of court costs then you probably shouldn't shoot at them at all.

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#250

In my neighborhood (rural) a drone hovering over someone's property would be likely used as target practice. If delivery drones become commonplace, there are going to have to be regulations about which air corridors they can use (altitude and routes) or it will be chaos.

In the US, shooting a drone is the same as shooting an aircraft and that means federal law enforcement attention, especially when the drone is owned by one of the largest, richest companies in the world, with lots of data and video footage.

Good luck securing a conviction.

There's not a jury in the world that would convict someone of shooting a drone flying over there own backyard.

Post reply on HN