Live data from Hacker News

Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend

twitter.com

241–250 of 282 posts

Re: Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend

#241

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a really bad misunderstanding of how governmental monopoly on violence affects the acceptance of its currency. The USD has value because you need to pay your taxes in USD, and if you don't pay your taxes, the government will take away your freedom. It has nothing to do with people in other countries transacting in that country's local currency.

That's also a myth that doesn't make sense. If it was about taxes people would just hold something else and converted some temporarily to pay their taxes leaving government with currency nobody wants. It's all about people's trust and willingness to store savings and make loans in a given current.

> would just hold something else and converted some temporarily to pay their taxes

Wouldn’t this expose those people to exchange rate risk that they could completely avoid by holding USD instead?

Re: Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend

#242

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's something deeply ironic about a flight to safety in the form of Tether , which has famously been described as being "quilted out of red flags". But if you can't redeem it and it's not backed by anything remotely approaching normal assets, I guess you can't have a bank run on it either... until the music stops and the insiders propping it up run out of chairs.

Tether is better run than any other stable coin. Yes, it could go to zero for many different reasons, but the main reason it gets so much flak (compared to other stables) is because it is less compliant with US regulators than USDC and the other major stable coins. Being less complaint with US regulators is also the reason it is used more than any other stable (highest volume by a wide margin); because people without…

If by "better run" you mean Tether is better at surviving despite being a massive fraud [0][1], then I agree with you.

[0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/crypto-companies-behind-tether-...

[1] https://archive.ph/rJifh

Re: Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend

#243

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Plenty of clearnet businesses accept crypto.

Sure, and paying with crypto is always going to be more painful unless you use an exchange, which is just a bank with less regulation(ok maybe not in the US, since banks are barely regulated there anyway). Which again means it will never catch on unless it just becomes a conventional currency. Which, btw is a sociological inevitability anyway(I will die on this hill, try me). Decentralisation never lasts, see countle…

The point of crypto is to you from making rules about other people’s money. The state sponsored looting stunt the canadian government pulled off last year would be impossible with crypto. Likewise would PDT laws and similar regulations governing what other people can choose to risk.

Re: Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend

#244

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You’re aware that ~$150B of $200B SVB deposits are not covered by FDIC insurance, correct? I don’t think SVB is going to end up 0, but pointing at 25% of investments being safe and saying “look regulation works so well” seems absurd.

All the people involved are institutional investors. 0% of people who have USD savings under $250k are affected by this. On the other hand, anybody who has a significant portion of their net worth tied up in cryptocurrency is affected by this.

Minor correction, people employed by companies that banked with SVB are also heavily affected here.

Re: Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend

#245

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You’re aware that ~$150B of $200B SVB deposits are not covered by FDIC insurance, correct? I don’t think SVB is going to end up 0, but pointing at 25% of investments being safe and saying “look regulation works so well” seems absurd.

All the people involved are institutional investors. 0% of people who have USD savings under $250k are affected by this. On the other hand, anybody who has a significant portion of their net worth tied up in cryptocurrency is affected by this.

... and all the people and companies those companies banking with SVB have to pay?

Re: Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend

#246

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tether is better run than any other stable coin. Yes, it could go to zero for many different reasons, but the main reason it gets so much flak (compared to other stables) is because it is less compliant with US regulators than USDC and the other major stable coins. Being less complaint with US regulators is also the reason it is used more than any other stable (highest volume by a wide margin); because people without…

> Tether is better run than any other stable coin. Only in the PR sense. A rug pull is inevitable. On the bright side, when it crashes it'll take what's left of crypto with it.

Agree that tether will inevitably go to zero, but I don't think it will be Bitfinix pulling out the rug. Tether is more useful for more people than any other stable for the time being. IMO it will be the last stable standing unless the US regulators go after them hard before going after others, which is very possible.

Re: Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend

#247
post #238

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tether is better run than any other stable coin. Yes, it could go to zero for many different reasons, but the main reason it gets so much flak (compared to other stables) is because it is less compliant with US regulators than USDC and the other major stable coins. Being less complaint with US regulators is also the reason it is used more than any other stable (highest volume by a wide margin); because people without…

if you think tether is well run, I have a bridge to sell you

Better run than other stables. I have some USDC to sell you. Do you have any tether?

Re: Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend

#248
post #239

Earlier quoted context omitted.

India is a developing country. Are you somehow under the impression that the US army will attack a coffee shop in New Delhi if they stop taking US dollars? Even in those parts of Mexico and Caribbean countries where the economy is heavily dependent on US tourism - and the US dollar will be accepted at retail shops; the price difference between paying in dollars and paying in local currency is going to be against the…

no but expect the US to start invading weaker countries that depeg from the dollar. the US is, at present, the world's reserve currency. that status is what creates the petrodollar. as countries move towards Russia or China, that hegemony is threatened.

What countries peg to the dollar that you think are in danger of being invaded?

Re: Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend

#249
Is the only way to make a true stablecoin is to create your own bank to hold the assets of the stablecoin?

The problem is a stablecoin holds reserves in a bank which the bank is then investing in non liquid assets which puts you in the current predicament. On paper USDC had these cash reserves, but in reality if you follow the trail all the way down you find out that those cash reserves are actually MBS’s and 10 year bonds.

A stablecoin which operated it’s own bank could guarantee that all reserves are actually being held in cash ready to wire transfer at a moments notice.

Re: Coinbase suspending USDC:USD conversions over the weekend

#250

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure, and paying with crypto is always going to be more painful unless you use an exchange, which is just a bank with less regulation(ok maybe not in the US, since banks are barely regulated there anyway). Which again means it will never catch on unless it just becomes a conventional currency. Which, btw is a sociological inevitability anyway(I will die on this hill, try me). Decentralisation never lasts, see countle…

The point of crypto is to you from making rules about other people’s money. The state sponsored looting stunt the canadian government pulled off last year would be impossible with crypto. Likewise would PDT laws and similar regulations governing what other people can choose to risk.

Random, unsourced, singular examples do not an argument make. Try again.

Btw how invested are you in crypto? Valid question, y'know, enumerating biases.

Post reply on HN