Live data from Hacker News

Light mode, Dark mode, and Gen-Z mode?

getfilteroff.com

241–250 of 350 posts

Re: Light mode, Dark mode, and Gen-Z mode?

#241

> I stare at the page for a second. My brain hurts. I hate it. It felt... distracting, maximal, cluttered, weirdly transparent. Little sparkles animate over the page. > "How old are you?" I asked. > "Twenty-five." > "Of course you are." You will never, ever, ever do good design while holding your audience in contempt. They are fully and completely entitled to their aesthetic preferences and those preferences have abs…

One is rather small sample size for what users want.

Re: Light mode, Dark mode, and Gen-Z mode?

#242
post #231
post #200

First things first: I don't think there's anything wrong with the design based on the screenshots. At least, nothing stands out as being so unusable that users would flee for your competitor. As for "Gen Z preferences", I don't think there's enough to go on here to prove that. I'm over 35 and have watched user interfaces go from the the fun, colourful and UNIQUE designs of the 2009-era iOS apps to the hyper-corporate…

Really on point here. Having worked at a company where our VCs demanded we "do what Google does" and then had to adopt the entire "design system" approach, it ends up robbing UIs of anything fun, because all UIs become "design by committee" by default.

This doesn't apply to all types of applications, but one person's fun may prevent another person from completing a task or even having a particular job. Yes, it's possible to design UIs that are both fun (whatever that means) and accessible. But it seems to me that boring, by-the-book UIs are more likely to be accessible by default.

Re: Light mode, Dark mode, and Gen-Z mode?

#243
post #129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's not new. Gen-Xers got the same thing. Boomers got the same thing. Lazy stereotyping wasn't invented yesterday. I don't think this blog post means to stereotype all of gen-Z though. I think they're just using it as a foil to talk about the counter-trend to early-21st-century minimalism. That was in turn a counter-trend to late-1990s / early-2000s eclecticism like old Geocities.

>Gen-Xers got the same thing GenX got ignored. The baton was passed from Boomers to Millennials. I guess we were all taking a bathroom break or something. GenX UI, at least on the Web, was TABLE layouts with spacer GIFs dictated to us by Boomers who wanted brochures. Our crowning design achievement still lives on in WiFi router Web management tools and phpBB. Yo, anybody going to the Phish concert? I need a ride.

> GenX got ignored. The baton was passed from Boomers to Millennials. I guess we were all taking a bathroom break or something.

There weren't enough of us. Also we were apathetic to everything. At least that's what I was told I wasn't really paying attention.

Re: Light mode, Dark mode, and Gen-Z mode?

#244
post #224

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We millennials are turning forty, for the first time, this year! I'm waiting with eager anticipation to hear what wrongs our whole generation is uniquely responsible for.

We're responsible for all the ills caused by things the Gen-Xers were apathetic about.

We Gen-Xers we’re apathetic due to witnessing the blatant greed of the Yuppies and we wanted none of that kind of thing.

Re: Light mode, Dark mode, and Gen-Z mode?

#245
There seem to be quite a few negative comments assuming contempt/stereotyping/whatever in what seems to me a tongue in cheek and equally self(cohort) mocking article. It seems fair enough to hypothesise generational taste differences, there's hardly anything new about that.

I like Filter Off, it's a breath of fresh air in the dating app space though the last time I looked at it it was mobile only which kind of dissuades those of us on the cheap end of the camera spectrum...

Re: Light mode, Dark mode, and Gen-Z mode?

#246
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think jamil was implying Boomers are too stupid to know how to install an ad-blocker. As a Gen-X, I’m inclined to agree.

Wow you're old as fuck and calling the slightly older group stupid.

I don’t think they’re stupid but somehow my dad, who could always program my grandpa’s VCR and put together high end AV setups in his youth can’t set up his own entertainment center equipment anymore.

I struggle with phone UIs but that feels like mostly because I can’t be bothered to guess at the “intuitive” ways I can touch a screen that do different things across apps. For instance, some of my video apps are double tap to fill screen, others are outward pinch (is there a word for that?), or a press of certain buttons, or they just don’t do it.

Re: Light mode, Dark mode, and Gen-Z mode?

#247
With product design becoming more data-driven, feedback-loop A/B testing etc, won’t the natural evolution of the field be toward UI/UX that’s tailored to each user client-side given their known profile of design and interaction preferences, learned by AI?

In other words, in the long run will this even be a problem anymore?

Re: Light mode, Dark mode, and Gen-Z mode?

#248
Honestly I am fifty years old and the "Gen Z" theme is much more appealing. The light one at the top of this post is incredibly boring and grey. Grey background, grey buttons, greyed-out photographs. The right screenshot is slightly better with the touch of blue but it's not very saturated. Little thumbnails. A tiny but of color from the image next to "Ready for date night?" but not much.

Hire an artist, get some kind of fun mascot drawn, make some font choices that aren't the same ten fonts that ship with iOS, get them to do some comps of really out-there ideas to make it a fun place to come look for someone to date. Right now it's just the Grey Zone. Come here to look for a grey person to have boring grey dates with. Woohoo.

Change the look now and then. For holidays. Big ones, little ones, local ones, made-up ones. A real-world meeting place would do this, why shouldn't you? Talk to the same artist about doing that.

Hell, even pick a day in the middle of winter to be Grey Dates Day and have a monochrome skin for laughs. Whatever. Get some color and whimsey in there.

(The post ends with "we're hiring a creative director" so I guess they're kinda looking for an artist now.)

Re: Light mode, Dark mode, and Gen-Z mode?

#249
post #200

First things first: I don't think there's anything wrong with the design based on the screenshots. At least, nothing stands out as being so unusable that users would flee for your competitor. As for "Gen Z preferences", I don't think there's enough to go on here to prove that. I'm over 35 and have watched user interfaces go from the the fun, colourful and UNIQUE designs of the 2009-era iOS apps to the hyper-corporate…

For Android, you’re talking about Material You, which is a bit more colorful and bubbly.

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/11/android-12-the-ars-t...

And as to grid systems…well, that isn’t exactly a recent development. Design and typography has been dealing and fighting about grid systems for a long, long time now. This is not a new discussion. At all. We just generally don’t think a lot about the full history of design.

https://www.moma.org/calendar/exhibitions/1013

Post reply on HN