Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: 50 job applications, 15 interviews, 7 onsites, and no offer – what next?

news.ycombinator.com

241–249 of 249 posts

Re: Ask HN: 50 job applications, 15 interviews, 7 onsites, and no offer – what next?

#241

You should seek advice from people who are looking for jobs right now, or people who got freshly hired (within the last 2 months). If you listen to people who aren't in the market now then you won't hear anything relevant. Things change, the market moves up and down, if you're not in it then you're disconnected from reality. Reality is - it is not a candidate's market anymore for many reasons. It is early 2017, thing…

Can you elaborate on the visa thing?

Sure, I'm referring to the H1B visa. Applications start on April 1st and usually end a day after (when the economy is good like this year). After they reach their quota the visa application shuts down until April next year.

So from January to March companies also look at candidates who need sponsorship. If you already have an H1B it doesn't count, this is only for new applications.

Though, this year Trump will change everything on April 3rd. Premium processing (15 days) will be stopped, which will make H1 visa transfers harder and more painful for companies. We're talking about a few months to transfer a visa from one employer to another. If you're an H1 holder, you will most likely be stuck with your current employer because companies will never wait a few months for you to start.

With that being said, in April the job market will settle down a little bit. Less candidates and maybe even more jobs out there.

Re: Ask HN: 50 job applications, 15 interviews, 7 onsites, and no offer – what next?

#242
post #228

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When multiple people take it a different way than I intended, then I must assume that it's my fault and I did a bad job of communicating my idea. I could rephrase what I meant to say as simply try to talk less about what you need and talk more about what the company needs. Let the company ask you about what you need. As other people have pointed out, getting a job is similar to dating. Mutual interest makes a good pa…

> As other people have pointed out, getting a job is similar to dating. Mutual interest makes a good pairing, and two parties that are only self-interested makes a bad pairing. This is a common analogy, but one I fundamentally disagree with. Dating is about creating a deep personal bond with a single other person. Getting a job is business, and business is fundamentally about two or more self-interested parties comin…

I don't disagree. :) I'm intrigued and want to hear more of your take, though we might be too deep in the comments to have a meaningful conversation.

The analogy isn't perfect, of course, but I only think interviewing and dating are similar in some ways, not all ways, and they aren't the same thing. Of course.

It's true that business is about finances and not bonding, and there are definitely times where it's best to keep that abundantly clear, I think you add a good perspective.

It's also true that I have declined to hire some people primarily due to their negative attitude and declared lack of interest in the company or the job they're applying for, and I know others who've made exactly the same call. I also screwed up a job interview once by being overtly disinterested, and regretted it and it stuck with me.

So, we can certainly disagree about how it's characterized, I don't mind what we call it, but it's still true that coming to a job interview disinterested or only as a self-interested financial arrangement is less likely to score you the job you want.

I can say from personal experience that starting a company truly is similar in many ways to getting married, with all the trials and tribulations. To come to that relationship primarily as a self-interested party simply may not functionally work at all, and it's certainly very common for business partners to be mutually emotionally invested.

Having interviewed some people recently for a more co-founder type of position, the process was more literally like dating than any engineer hiring I did before. People were in fact looking for a personality match, and requested that I take personality tests to validate that. People do look for an alignment of vision, and do evaluate me on the basis that we'll be spending a lot of time together should we pair up. We talked business too, but the evaluation of common goals and personality match, general likability, work ethic, goals and dreams for the future, these things were the primary traits I was judged by, not my technical skills, and not the financial equation. And not by my ass either, so yes, it's not dating, but it was surprisingly close. ;)

Re: Ask HN: 50 job applications, 15 interviews, 7 onsites, and no offer – what next?

#243
post #85

If you're willing to apply to another company (LocalMotion by Zipcar, San Mateo, CA), I'll give you comprehensive honest feedback on your onsite, whether or not you get the job. We're looking for more Product people.

Whats your email, sounds interesting.

jchu at zipcar dot com

Re: Ask HN: 50 job applications, 15 interviews, 7 onsites, and no offer – what next?

#244

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's wrong with posting as throwaway. Probably the author of the post want to avoid racial bias over his name ?

An up vote on a throwaway doesn't earn your main account any internet points, so it's be a thrown away up vote.

What's the use of the point if it stops u from expressing your opinion without racial bias.

Re: Ask HN: 50 job applications, 15 interviews, 7 onsites, and no offer – what next?

#245

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's wrong with posting as throwaway. Probably the author of the post want to avoid racial bias over his name ?

An up vote on a throwaway doesn't earn your main account any internet points, so it's be a thrown away up vote.

What's the use of the point if it stops u from expressing your opinion without racial bias.

Re: Ask HN: 50 job applications, 15 interviews, 7 onsites, and no offer – what next?

#246
Hi, fully understand your desire to move on from a frustrating situation. Good luck, keep at it, man. Based on your post, it seems like you can land the interview, including final in-person ones. I suspect your body language probably communicates that you are too desperate. Hiring managers (consciously and unconsciously) resist hiring folks when they sense desperation. My recommendation to you is getting a coach to provide pointers for in-person interviews.

Re: Ask HN: 50 job applications, 15 interviews, 7 onsites, and no offer – what next?

#247
Your depression and hatred of your current role is impacting your energy and the impression you're making on people. Perceptive people pick up on that, especially face to face. Change your outlook and also push for critical feedback when they reject you. You have nothing to lose by asking every person you interact with in the process for feedback after they've passed on you. Some will ignore your request and some will offer you some actionable advice. Change your outlook. It's going to work out. Good luck.

Re: Ask HN: 50 job applications, 15 interviews, 7 onsites, and no offer – what next?

#248
Was in a similar boat, also Indian, I don't know what the cutoff for FOB is, I been hear 7 years now. This happened about 5 years back, after I learned this one weird trick that I am about to espouse, I couldn't close interviews. Since then I have been getting multiple offers each time I look for a job, and I am currently in a senior role at a "Fortune 10 best places to work for”.

(Accent yes, but no one has asked me to repeat anything in many years. In recent times folks have asked me if I was born in the US. So let's get that out of the way)

Ok, what is the one weird trick. Its actually two.

1. Know yourself: I wasn't really into software engineering, I was a scientist, and I really wanted to get into SE because those jobs were more abundant, esply when you are junior you can't crack into the scientist job unless you have a Phd - I dropped out. When I am at an interview, I couldn't help but convey that deep down I really didn't want this job. This will show, you could pretend on the phone, its harder when in person. Folks still do it, I couldn't. Understand who you are, and that you really want this job, you are hungry for it. Go ahead and show it, let them feel your animal energy! For all his faults, and almost all of his person is a fault, the current US president has "raw animal energy” (RAE), which people like, love even. You can get a job you are not even qualified for by just having this RAE. So get to know some of that in your own personality.

2. Dude(or girl) I can't stress this second point enough. One of the biggest things that is different about Indian culture is this. In India if you are confident and know a lot - you are trained to show that power by being Quiet. Silent. Calm. This is the case with many cultures. It is not however the case with American business culture. Please read my point above about bringing out your animal awesomeness. In the US, I don't know how else to say this: being bombastic is what will pass for confidence. (Bombastic from an Indian perspective, of course it is just awesomeness from the American perspective). Show your energy, jump around. I know, it will be very unnatural if you are new to it. So I’d recommend acting classes like some of the other comments, but I didn’t take any. I was able to channel my inner panda by just being aware of this problem.

Think of your personality itself as having an accent. It is not a crime to have an accent, but if you can tone it down, it helps everyone involved. This is what you need to do. You have to not only be confident, you have also to convey it effectively in the language of the culture you are in.

Re: Ask HN: 50 job applications, 15 interviews, 7 onsites, and no offer – what next?

#249
post #80
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We do recruitment software, and one of the features that just never seems to take life is asking managers why they have rejected a candidate - even though that would be extremely useful for fine tuning the process. It seems people just don't like to be pinned down.

It probably boils down to feelings, which seems unfair to introverts and those who tend to undersell themselves (but is probably how 'society' works).

Yeah, when you're interviewing and have more than one technically qualified candidate, you pick based on "culture fit", i.e., "do they seem likeable?"

A freeform box for rejection rationale will probably never get a good response rate, because it's work for people to make up a plausible-sounding explanation for why they liked someone else more (and this explanation is rarely if ever reflective of reality; people make up intellectually-satisfying stories to justify their impulsive/emotional decisions). However, a radio box that offered rejection reasons like "bad technical fit", "bad culture fit", or "good candidate for the future; not enough slots right now" may see better response rates.

Post reply on HN