Live data from Hacker News

AI demands more engineering discipline. Not less

charitydotwtf.substack.com

231–234 of 234 posts

Re: AI demands more engineering discipline. Not less

#231

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unskilled people are not irrelevant if you intend on working with other people, in which case you will need to deal with them in one way or another. I will probably be dealing with them in the future more than in the past because chatbots bypass the process by which unskilled people generally become skilled people.

Suppose I don't use AI, but have to work with people who are using it. Is AI demanding more/less engineering discipline of me?

I don't know anything about you, but I told you my experience a couple of messages back, which you effectively decided not to respond to.

Re: AI demands more engineering discipline. Not less

#232
post #127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"High performers". Can't believe we have normalized this vocabulary, among us, "hackers".

Most of us work for business and on teams where performance matters.

> Most of us work for business and on teams where performance matters.

It truly does:

performance – the action of entertaining other people by dancing, singing, acting, or peformative coding

The problem is, that shouldn't matter. If you work somewhere it does, well, you probably have to. But that's OK, it doesn't stop you from working to uplift the goal and conversation and deliverables, through these other definitions of performance:

performance – how well a person, machine, etc. does an activity

Now we get into how to define well, but activity, looking busy, may not be as valuable as outcomes.

performance – how well a person, machine, etc. does a piece of work

This is getting close, but here we need to define the nature of work, the qualia of work. It's not how well someone codes a line of code, or how well someone programs a piece of software. It's not even how well the engineer a solution.

What matters is return on equity, meaning: how well does what is delivered enable the business to turn capital investment in bringing ideas into being, into returns on that capital.

For good measure (pun intended), track long term, so resilience, maintainability, and evolvability, and really any ongoing costs, including delay costs, opportunity costs, or cash flow costs, are part of the definition of how well.

That matters.

Note this can be shorthanded to both GPT and Claude, and will change the machines’ suggestions.

Post reply on HN