231–239 of 239 posts
Snake oil. Good to read for sure. Seems all plausible too. But snake oil nevertheless. Here's why: The slot machine can drop any hard requirement that you specifically in your AGENTS.md, memory.md or your dozens of skill markdowns. Pretty much guaranteed. These harnesses approaches pretend as if LLMs are strict and perfect rule followers and the only problem is not being able to specify enough rules clearly enough. T…
Earlier quoted context omitted.
> LLMs aren't perfect rule following machines is the fundamental problem here I kind of get what you're saying, but let us not pretend that SW engineers are perfect rule followers either. Having a framework to work within, whether you are an LLM or a human, can be helpful.
If someone regularly ignored critical instructions even though they were written down and had been told to follow them, that person would be fired.
Earlier quoted context omitted.
No, I spent a thousand and now my profit margins are higher.
Remind me again how does that compare to landing someone on the moon ? Which is what you were implying earlier?
You're struggling with basic reading comprehension if you think so.
Earlier quoted context omitted.
> The slot machine can drop any hard requirement that you specifically in your AGENTS.md, memory.md or your dozens of skill markdowns. Pretty much guaranteed. Indeed. That said, I’ve had some success with agent skills, but I use them to make the LLM aware of things it can do using specific external tools. I think it is a really bad idea to use this mechanism to enforce safety rules. We need good sandboxing for this,…
Do you have any information on skills you've found useful here?
Earlier quoted context omitted.
Remind me again how does that compare to landing someone on the moon ? Which is what you were implying earlier?
I have never in my life implied anything I've done compares to landing someone on the moon. You're struggling with basic reading comprehension if you think so.
Earlier quoted context omitted.
I have never in my life implied anything I've done compares to landing someone on the moon. You're struggling with basic reading comprehension if you think so.
Cute ;) why don't ypu re-read again what you wrote in response to my comment ? But dont ask the LLM to summarise it for you.
Earlier quoted context omitted.
Cute ;) why don't ypu re-read again what you wrote in response to my comment ? But dont ask the LLM to summarise it for you.
I know exactly what I wrote. Clearly you didn't understand it. Maybe you ought to get an LLM to explain it to you.