Live data from Hacker News

TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues

cnn.com

231–240 of 1001 posts

Re: TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues

#233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> the rest of the world have easy access to. Except for China, where TikTok is nothing like the TikTok for the rest of the world

A bunch of people around the world used 小红书 for months when they were worried about a twitter ban. They got the same version of the app that people in China got. I haven't seen any formal studies but my impression, at the time, was that Chinese people were far better informed about the US than Americans were about China.

Well, yes, China doesn't have open media for its citizens. Chinese people will on average be less well informed about China, even accounting for the extent of Americans who choose trashy propaganda channels.

(reminded of ex-tech influencer Naomi Wu, who basically went dark with a post along the lines of "the police have told me to stop posting")

Re: TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues

#234

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Especially with extremists, you should have a solid foundation of argumentation, because they will not ignore even little fails and weaponize everything against you if necessary.

Especially with extremists, a solid foundation of argumentation will do you no good because the facts are beside the point.

It's not about the extremists, it's about everyone else. Extremists usually have to convince people to give them power, to follow their BS. And by experience, even extremists sometimes can change their mind.

Re: TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues

#235
post #169

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> the rest of the world have easy access to. Except for China, where TikTok is nothing like the TikTok for the rest of the world

Do you think anti-ICE videos are being blocked in China?

probably not, in fact, the CCP likes to promote content that shows the "US in disarray", while simultaneously censoring and suppressing any content that is critical of the CCP or that exposes its bad actions

Re: TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues

#236

Earlier quoted context omitted.

_you_ have access to it, for an increasingly large number of people TikTok is their only source of news. Same as Fox News or CNN, one news source. Censorship of TikTok is inevitable given the owners, and it will inevitably lead to a new news bubble.

I think you’re greatly overestimating the number of people who only use one social media platform and never check any other news source at all. TikTok users are also known for being experts at evading filters and censors. Remember the rising popularity of “unalived” when talk of suicide was filtered out on the platform? I’m not saying this ICE censorship is good, because it’s not! I’m saying it’s ridiculous to claim…

> I think you’re greatly overestimating the number of people who only use one social media platform and never check any other news source at all.

When it comes to the _younger generation_, I don't think it's an over-estimation; they don't read news sites at all.

Re: TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues

#237

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> the rest of the world have easy access to. Except for China, where TikTok is nothing like the TikTok for the rest of the world

Which used to be seen as "Ew, China has their own version? Crazy censorship" but after some time it seems like the US is aiming for the very same thing. Classy.

> Which used to be seen as "Ew, China has their own version? Crazy censorship"

It used to be marketed as that by "China evil" people. Western politicians have always seen this as an arms race. They claim infinite brutal censorship and suppression in China in order to claim that not having it here is a strategic disadvantage. Meanwhile, China's "social credit" is just like a US credit score, which in most countries is an illegal thing to do.

This is completely bipartisan, both US parties take turns shitting on their two greatest enemies: the Bill of Rights and (almost completely defeated at this point) antitrust law. Those are painted as China's advantages: that they don't have to respect anyone's rights and that their government directly runs companies. 1) Neither of those things are true, and 2) they just ignore that China manufactures things and invests in infrastructure (which US politicians as individuals have no idea how to do because they are lawyers and marketers), and pretend that everything can be reduced to gamified finance and propaganda tricks.

It's the "missile gap" again. The US pretended and marketed that Russia had an enormous amount of nuclear weapons in order to fool us into allowing US politicians to dedicate the economy to producing an enormous amount of nuclear weapons.

The result, the child of the Oracle guy owns half the media, and uses it for explicitly political purposes that align with the administration (whichever it may be.)

Re: TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues

#238

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A NYT columnist Jamelle Bouie suggested (in jest) that the next Democrat administration send armed IRS agents to gated communities in Florida, to "investigate tax fraud". But this is exactly why all citizens should be concerned about the infringement of rights happening in Minnesota. If it is allowed without prosecution, you are next.

Why would anyone be opposed to the IRS catching tax cheats? This seems like such a bone-headed take. In any case it’s also historically illiterate, the IRS has long been used as a political weapon, infamously against “Tea Party” activists.

> infamously against “Tea Party” activists

that claim was disproved by the way

but, it is famously how the feds managed to get Al Capone

Re: TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues

#239
post #169

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you think anti-ICE videos are being blocked in China?

> Do you think anti-ICE videos are being blocked in China? Of course not, but other stuff is. Interestingly, my understanding is government pressure forces Douyin to be more "positive" and "encouraging" than Tiktok (i.e. outrage is an easy way drive engagement with obvious negative externalities, and that path is blocked).

Then the GP statement is still correct.

"The forced US hosted tik-tok sale is all about hiding information from the US public that most people in the rest of the world have easy access to."

Re: TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues

#240

It feels like federated networks with open-sourced feed algorithms are the best path forward. If AI removes any technical limitations, and automates content management, what's stopping a content creator from owning what they create and distributing it themselves? How can centralization continue to survive?

Why do so many tech people push this "federation is a panacea" idea despite all evidence to the contrary? I don't get it.

First, the obvious: if federation was clearly superior, it would've won. No medium since email has been federated and even that's dominated by a handful of players. Running your own email server is... nontrivial.

Second, users don't care abou tthis. Like at all.

Third, supposedly tech-savvy people don't seem willing or able to merely scratch the surface of what that looks like and how it would work.

Fourth, there's a lot of infrastructure you need such as moderation and safety that would need to be replicated for each federated provider.

Lastly, zero consideration is given to the problems this actually creates. Look at POTS. We have spam and providers that are bad actors and effectively launder spam calls and texts. You need some way to manage that.

Post reply on HN