Live data from Hacker News

Pebble Index 01 – External memory for your brain

repebble.com

231–240 of 615 posts

Re: Pebble Index 01 – External memory for your brain

#231
post #99

I'll be honest, after seeing a nightmare situation where a smartring battery inflated and cut off circulation to a finger, I will never ever buy a ring with a battery in it.

I suppose it would be possible to design the ring so that any pillowing would occur only in outwards expansion.

Re: Pebble Index 01 – External memory for your brain

#232
post #61

You can buy a rechargeable e-ring with several sensors and even a tiny screen for like 20$ on AliExpress. 75$ for a non-rechargeable, e-waste ring with just a button and a mic is insane.

Point is to not having to take it off at all, as next thing is going out without it and losing that convenience. Though I guess they can also invent a finger-mounted powerbank for it; I remember buying a case with an embedded powerbank for one of my earlier Android phones...

Re: Pebble Index 01 – External memory for your brain

#233
Something like this isn't very practical for me. I just pull out my phone and dictate or type when I need to take notes. If I can't pull out my phone, I probably have gloves on or am in a loud environment.

A gesture on the watch that just starts the recorder seems a lot more practical, this ring just adds an unnecessary complication. Plus, $100 is a lot for something that they don't want you to service.

I'd rather much have a lot of big programmable buttons on the watch itself and have a smaller display or a separate BLE remote with lots of buttons.

Re: Pebble Index 01 – External memory for your brain

#234
post #65

(Pebble founder) Happy to answer any questions you have!

Are you still considering implementing the feature as a Pebble app as well? As someone who is very forgetful I like the low-friction external memory concept, but it would be nice if I could try it out (admittedly sub-optimally) before jumping in with a second device. It could also be a nice option for Index owners to keep a similar flow even when they don't want to wear the Index for whatever reason.

In general I really like the idea of a local-first, privacy-first, one-way/low-interaction digital assistant regardless of the form factor. A big frustration I have with Gemini as a voice assistant is that I have to wait out the other half of super simple interactions like setting a timer or making a note.

Re: Pebble Index 01 – External memory for your brain

#235
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

this is a device that would potentially last years though, not months — if you're in the niche of needing something like this you're paying less than $10 a month (maybe as low as $5)... doesn't net out too terribly in exchange for not charging

Right, and an Oura would be usable for a decade because it has a rechargeable battery.

sure but the Oura does a bunch of unrelated stuff specific to health and also has to be charged twice a week? they're not even comparable products

Re: Pebble Index 01 – External memory for your brain

#236

Earlier quoted context omitted.

this is a device that would potentially last years though, not months — if you're in the niche of needing something like this you're paying less than $10 a month (maybe as low as $5)... doesn't net out too terribly in exchange for not charging

We did it guys, we made physical devices usable only if you treat them as a SaaS otherwise you're sol when battery runs out

that's a pretty lame take, all I did was break down the cost to the lifespan of the device

it's useful to think of a lot of things this way, I also justify clothing purchases on a rough estimate of cost per wear

Re: Pebble Index 01 – External memory for your brain

#237
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Two year of average use"?

I’m not talking grammar, I’m talking convention. Think of it more like this: If I was selling you a car and said it would last for years, then would you expect it to fall apart after two years? I certainly wouldn’t. When talking about small quantities we tend to specify an exact number (two, three), however as the range becomes larger and less exact we use generalities (years). Because of this “years” would typically…

Even given that convention, with your example, a car is a far steeper investment than this ring. The more you invest in something, the more you expect to get out of it, and this ring is designed for a very low investment point, while still being highly durable (there are other similar rings out there at even lower investment points, but they probably won't survive anything beyond a sprinkle).

Re: Pebble Index 01 – External memory for your brain

#238
post #96

Instead of a stand-alone piece of e-waste, how about this: a device with the same format (a ring and an button) but the only thing it does is trigger the pebble watch to start recording a message. This way the microphone isn't needed, just the radio (and much weaker radio at that), and the battery will last exponentially longer. Then just expose the charging terminals so that we can at least hack the device with cust…

Then just put the button on the watch? In fact, why isn't this just a button on the watch?

If you had read the post you would know the answer.

Re: Pebble Index 01 – External memory for your brain

#239

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Then just put the button on the watch? In fact, why isn't this just a button on the watch?

Because you need to use your other hand to press that button, instead of the adjacent finger.

> Because you need to use your other hand to press that button, instead of the adjacent finger.

Funnily enough, I've used my nose to tap my watch when my hands are full

Yes, I've gotten some strange looks

Post reply on HN