Live data from Hacker News

Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

rte.ie

231–240 of 353 posts

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#231
post #139

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article isn't about the US. However, even the US, that isn't entirely true. United States v. Causby (1946) sets the precedent that property owners own the airspace above their property to (at least) 83 feet. The FAA has exclusive sovereignty over "navigable airspace", which is considered a public highway. This navigable airspace generally begins at 500 feet above the surface in uncongested areas and 1000 feet abo…

There's a medflight helicopter pad not far from my place out in the country. It's just a small concrete pad on a lot and when it is dispatched it ascends straight up to what I'd guessed was 300' but could easily be 500' before taking off towards its destination. Landings are similar. I always thought it looked weird but now I wonder if it's because it's largely surrounded by private property.

I am near a hospital in a city and while they usually do the same thing sometimes the pilots seem intent on testing the limits of their craft/FAA regulations.

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#232
post #203
post #183

I live in a pretty quiet neighborhood, and I’m not thrilled about the idea of drones flying over my backyard all the time. There’s something really jarring about sitting outside and suddenly hearing that loud buzzing overhead. I don’t think anyone’s really asked regular people how they feel about this kind of thing.

Delivery drones are larger and therefore quieter (larger propellor = more pleasant tone and lower RPM) and fly higher than the consumer drones you’re probably familiar with.

I still find it pretty distracting. I'm just sitting there trying to chill, and there's this constant buzzing above. Not a fan.

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#234
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your strained analogy would actually be if any bank blocked one account from all bank accounts once a month.

I guess some of us count life in web requests.

Can you write up a blog post about how many months of the year you are being blocked from banking?

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#235
post #223
post #144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This article is from Ireland, but at least here in the US local governments cannot create laws governing anything that is airborne.

No but I see no reason they can't pass noise ordinances irrespective of the means employed. They can't regulate drones but they can fine you for making noise that happens to be a drone. Can you imagine if concert venues could get around noise ordinances by lifting the speakers with drones? Absurd.

The FAA has "field preemption" from Congress. Meaning any state or local law that conflicts with the FAA's stated purpose is automatically rendered moot and unenforceable. The FAAs mandate is the efficient operation of aircraft within the airspace.

So a law that bans a drone from using a massive speaker to violate a noise ordnance could be enforced, but a law against the operational noise of an aircraft could not. A city could ban a drone operator from flying over a crime scene low enough to disturb evidence, but could not ban a drone from passing over a crime scene.

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#236
post #80

Aside: It's going to be a great time when the crows, raccoons, and other semi-intelligent wildlife discover that these drones have food in them at seemingly random reward schedules. Sure, you can give the drones little tasers to keep the animals away, depending on your locality. But knowing what I know about bears and crows, almost nothing is going to stop them. Especially when some influencer jerk tries tempting a b…

actually, I've been thinking that with the encroachment of man, birds are up off the ground and are the survivors that coexist with us.

But now I wonder if we will "silent spring" them too.

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#237
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

if a drone is close enough to be hit with a rock, its operating ilegally.

Which law? Is there an FAA rule concerning minimum drone height over someone's property? I understand there's generally a maximum of 400 feet for drones, but I don't know about any rules for minimum height.

https://ageagle.com/blog/drone-regulations-usa-fly-over-peop...

https://ageagle.com/blog/european-union-drone-regulations-ex...

https://www.dronepilotgroundschool.com/kb/can-i-fly-my-drone...

https://nexttools.net/how-close-can-you-fly-a-drone-to-a-per...

https://www.easa.europa.eu/en/light/topics/flying-drones-clo...

https://www.dronelaw.pro/faa-rules-say-you-cant-fly-your-dro...

https://dspalliance.org/new-rules-for-ops-over-people-rid/

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#238

My concern is less the occasional drone and more when Google decides that all their delivery drones - already carrying cameras/radar/lidar for navigational purposes - can be used to update google maps in near realtime. The sheer Big Brother possibilities are insane. The future: "saferoom is where the pants aren't"

I live in Iowa where the governor just signed a bill that outlaws drone surveillance of private farms and farmland. I haven't read the full bill yet, so it's possible that it also outlaws surveillance of homes that aren't on farmland, but would at least be illegal to do what you're describing if you own a farm in Iowa.

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#239
post #90
post #80

Aside: It's going to be a great time when the crows, raccoons, and other semi-intelligent wildlife discover that these drones have food in them at seemingly random reward schedules. Sure, you can give the drones little tasers to keep the animals away, depending on your locality. But knowing what I know about bears and crows, almost nothing is going to stop them. Especially when some influencer jerk tries tempting a b…

I can definitely see a future time when small autonomous air vehicles start to have problems with the local wildlife, either from the thick flocks of grackles in winter or from the more mischievous neighborhood corvids.

Biggest problem already for the last 10 years. This guy uses reflective tape: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=muP8eZasOFs

Re: Can I stop drone delivery companies flying over my property?

#240
post #91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If drones have cameras and are hovering above someone's property I'd argue that's an extra incentive to the property owners to do something about it... unless we're saying it's perfectly legal to spy on anyone's property from above.

It generally is. How else do you think Google gets all those satellite pictures for maps?

Google has no satellites, the state has. They got those photos for free, probably in exchange for better software.
Post reply on HN