Live data from Hacker News

The Plumber Problem

hypercritical.co

231–240 of 253 posts

Re: The Plumber Problem

#231

As a writer myself: I have actual experts review what I write. That's about the best you can do. I think I read that The Big Bang Theory makes sure all the science is accurate. I wouldn't know.

I know a nuclear physicist who got paid to go through the scripts and turn "CHARACTER: [insert science thing here]" into dialogue

Re: The Plumber Problem

#232
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We use cows for the same purpose - we eat them instead of shoveling grass straight into our mouths, even though in some strict sense the grass contains more caloric energy. Or, we eat vegetables even though the energy in them is less than all the solar energy that falls on them. But of course the calories in grass and sunlight aren't accessible to us. It's not impossible to imagine some parallel situation where human…

Synthetic organisms would have a very different opinion of consumption than we do. Sustenance is much more than calories for us. Not so much for them.

Use your imagination. Maybe some biological process in genetically engineered humans can sort uranium isotopes more efficiently than a centrifuge. That would make them a net producer of "energy" by a reasonable definition.

Re: The Plumber Problem

#233
post #77

Every computer movie with a hacker ever: hacker opens an excel spreadsheet and types in a bunch of gibberish "I'm in the mainframe."

Oh, for the days when you could run a murderous android with a 6502! https://www.pagetable.com/?p=64

Robocop, by comparison, was running on MS-DOS. :-)

Re: The Plumber Problem

#234

There was an era where CGI was used to simulate somewhat real or imagineable behavior. If it’s a fantasy movie, I don’t care about bizarre effects. But something like Fast and Furious it’s just completely ridiculous to me. It’s just boring and lazy. Films like Grand Prix or Ronin have spectacular car scenes w/o being stupid.

The first F&F movies did it well, except the millions of gears, but otherwise it wasn't too bad.

The first F&F movies didn't seem to consult someone who knows anything about cars.

Re: The Plumber Problem

#235

I worked in theatre for years and audiences have a very high suspension of disbelief (much higher than for film or TV). Except for things related to the military, specifically uniforms. If you have a modern military uniform in your show, then it has to be _perfect_. Any errors you make will be glaring to someone who wore that uniform and it will take them out of the show. IME almost any other factual errors in a stag…

It seems as though Hollywood rarely cares to get the military aspect right. Or sometimes even close. Not just the uniforms, but almost everything related. I'm a US Army veteran and those errors are glaringly obvious to me.

Re: The Plumber Problem

#236
The worst example I can remember was in the movie The day after tomorrow, where cold air from the statosphere dropped down to ground level and instantly freeze dried people.

Now, granted the stratosphere is cold. But it’s also at very low pressure, and what happens to air when you compress it, say by moving it from the stratosphere to the ground? That’s right, it heats up. If you were to bring a packet of air down from the stratosphere, letting it heat adiabatically as it compresses to one atmosphere, I’d expect it to be hot enough to burn people rather than freezing them.

I rather enjoyed seeing Los Angeles being torn to pieces by multiple simultaneous super-tornadoes, though.

Re: The Plumber Problem

#237
post #220

In the movie 300, after Leonidas and the 300 decide to march North towards Thermopylae. The valley & mountains in the background are REALLY from Sparta, Grecet. The producers made had sent crews to take enough photos and videos of the valleygt to accurately portrait the landscape. It was eerie to watch the movie (I grew up in Sparta) and see the mountains all around as they really are. BUT (big but here) they march S…

That's a kind of funny one, where being more accurate made it worse: if they just had entirely made-up scenery, it probably would have bothered you a lot less!

That's why you use comic sans for example mockups: Suspension of disbelief so no one nitpicks the placeholder font as wrong and we all agree this is a pretend diagram.

Re: The Plumber Problem

#238

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reminds me of the YouTube channels that try to play what the animated piano or guitar is playing, and it’s almost always wrong. But sometimes, in surprising situations, it was animated correctly.

That sounds dope, got any examples? Unrelated kinda - does anyone remember seeing some videos of a guitarist basically PLAYING some speeches? Like, there was a background of a speaker giving a speech or dialogue in a movie and this dude is PLAYING the speech with really weird jazz chords and they’re notated on the top of the screen. Very weird and specific I know LOL

https://youtu.be/08tK1RBTJRg

https://youtu.be/qn0jtZwpe8A

Re: The Plumber Problem

#240

In the Matrix humanity is enslaved to use them as an energy source. But the 2nd law of thermodynamics requires that any energy harvested would be, by definition, less than the energy of the food required to sustain their bodies. Therefore the plot makes no sense, because they should just shovel the food directly into the computer and skip the humans.

The Black Mirror episode “Fifteen Million Merits” is the same. And in fact, it directly shows humans being used to generate electricity, so it can't be explained away.
Post reply on HN