Live data from Hacker News

This Voice Doesn't Exist – Generative Voice AI

blog.elevenlabs.io

231–240 of 279 posts

Re: This Voice Doesn't Exist – Generative Voice AI

#233
post #92

Still sounds pretty fake to me. There’s a hurriedness to the speech and a monotonic uniformity in enunciation that is uncannily machine. Good to know that voice actors will have jobs for a while longer…

Yeah right. You would never pass a blind test on this.

I think the narritive one would pass a blind test.

The conversational one wouldn't, although it could pass for a bad (human) voice actor.

Re: This Voice Doesn't Exist – Generative Voice AI

#234

Why someone should listen a voice when is faster to read the blog post ?

Why are all people exactly the same? It's odd that the audio book business went out of business years ago because people only want to read.

And yes this was a snarky answer because even if you don't realize it, it was a snarky question.

Re: This Voice Doesn't Exist – Generative Voice AI

#235

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My YouTube feed is currently filled with videos of whitehats hacking into Indian scam call centers. Most of the time, the giveaway is the callers' Indian accent. If you could simply type into a box and speak with an American accent, it would be really hard to get caught. We're opening a pandora's box here if I'm honest. I'm hardly one for pro-regulation, but good God, we're playing with things here that can really hu…

> If you could simply type into a box and speak with an American accent, it would be really hard to get caught. Not really. If they say "kindly do something", they are Indian scammers.

"Hey chatGPT, write a short script convincing someone that I'm from a small town in America"

Re: This Voice Doesn't Exist – Generative Voice AI

#236

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My YouTube feed is currently filled with videos of whitehats hacking into Indian scam call centers. Most of the time, the giveaway is the callers' Indian accent. If you could simply type into a box and speak with an American accent, it would be really hard to get caught. We're opening a pandora's box here if I'm honest. I'm hardly one for pro-regulation, but good God, we're playing with things here that can really hu…

There are a lot of words and phrases that indicate that you are speaking Indian English, separate from the accent. Using "learning" as a noun is a very common one in tech.

If you can use AI to create a fake voice, you can also use AI to create a prompt for the voice

Re: This Voice Doesn't Exist – Generative Voice AI

#237
post #111

Okay can I ask a question that has been bothering me for a long time? Why do seemingly all these text-to-speech programs attempt to produce spoken voice based solely on raw text ? Why don't they consume a MIDI-like text-markup language where you can write phonetic pronunciations along with markup about the emotion, volume, speed, etc.? I feel like this is a huge unnecessary roadblock holding back this kind of technol…

There are solutions that let you use curves like in an audio program to define inflection and pitch, speed of speaking, etc. Some of the competitors of this post's service do that.

Re: This Voice Doesn't Exist – Generative Voice AI

#238
As someone working on singing synthesis, I know how hard it is to get that last 10% quality that makes a human listener instantly recognise if the voice is real or generated.

These are really impressive results! For anyone interested, my team’s singing work: https://youtu.be/LPy20zSWhZA)

Re: This Voice Doesn't Exist – Generative Voice AI

#239
post #85

No mention of any other competitors that've been doing this stuff for several years? Uberduck? Fakeyou? Coqui? 15?

This appears to give by far the best results that I have seen. Can you link to a speech sample that you think is similar in quality to the article?

Re: This Voice Doesn't Exist – Generative Voice AI

#240

> Not only can they be more cost-effective without compromising on quality... That feels dishonest. Even if this AI is just as good at speaking as a professional voice actor (which I'm not sold on), a voice actor does more than just read the line. In ideal circumstances, they have a lot of context for what their character is doing and feeling. Is this potentially a good option for saving money on video game voices? Q…

>Even if this AI is just as good at speaking as a professional voice actor (which I'm not sold on)

I think the 'narration' example was voice actor quality. The other two were slightly off.

Post reply on HN