Live data from Hacker News

Guidance to make federally funded research freely available without delay

whitehouse.gov

231–240 of 293 posts

Re: Guidance to make federally funded research freely available without delay

#231

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think part of the point here, is that the value from that investment should go to the investors, who are (if you buy the 'by the people, for the people' hype) the taxpayers. Say I'm vulture capitalist Tom, and I pay a few gajillion dollars to developer Gupta to create a product for me. I would be understandably pissed if Gupta turned around and sold that same product to competitor vc Janet. She didn't pay for that…

1. There isn't as much of a difference here as you think. Contractors do turn around and use components developed in public contracts for other consulting projects. Most commonly with other sovereigns, especially when the original contract was with a city or state, but sometimes at the national level as well. 2. With respect to R&D, one big difference is that the government doesn't provide seed funding. They provide…

Thanks for the well informed response! I had not yet heard of Bayh-Dole and you gave me some good googlin'.

In regards to your explanation in [2], that sucks - I kinda figured that's how things were but I sorta went around academia rather than through it so it's interesting to hear. Any hot ideas about how it could be fixed?

Re: Guidance to make federally funded research freely available without delay

#232

Having done a short stint dealing with this stuff I am glad something is being done. NIST/NSF funded several studies that I was close to that were suddenly owned by a journal who did nothing but provide a place to put it. Public money should always mean public access. Not just for journals, but for anything. If one red cent of taxpayer money goes to it, the taxpayer should get it for free. Hopefully the trend continu…

All those red cents going to proprietary software licensing... Lots of Windows licenses in the federal government.

Re: Guidance to make federally funded research freely available without delay

#233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

NIH-funded research goes up on PubMed Central within 12 months of publication: https://www.nih.gov/health-information/nih-clinical-research...

I meant with regard to the ability for anyone to use it without, say, violating patents. Plenty of drugs discovered and developed with NIH money go on to be patented by private companies.

I take your point, but OTOH it's difficult to envision a world where drugs actually get brought to market without patent protection. The amount of money and risk involved is just astronomical.

Re: Guidance to make federally funded research freely available without delay

#234
but..... What will happen to the poor owners and shareholders of elsevier? oh shoot. we don't want them to die like the horse cart industry died off or like the caligraphers industry died after the gutenberg... and suddenly, "nothing of value was lost"....

good riddance

Re: Guidance to make federally funded research freely available without delay

#240
US Federal grants are involved in almost all research done in the US, so this likely means that the vast majority of research papers will become open access.

Open Access will mean that top quality research will no longer require membership of a University; anyone will be able to access research.

Post reply on HN