Live data from Hacker News

Buddhism has found a new institutional home in the West: the corporation

guernicamag.com

231–240 of 423 posts

Re: Buddhism has found a new institutional home in the West: the corporation

#231
post #56
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My own personal experience differed from yours. In a retreat in Burma I observed a lot of traditions, which made it very clear that men had a higher standing than women. When forming a line for going to lunch, the monks were first, then the laymen, then the nuns and then the laywomen; only the monks ate on a raised platform, but not the nuns or laypeople etc. This was not just old books, which nobody cared about, but…

There is sexism in Buddhism. I stayed at a Buddhist temple in Germany and there where way more rules for the nuns than the monks. > "It is extremely important to note that world religions [...] are, naturally and inevitably, in large part compendia of rules for managing daily life." - John A. Hall, Ideas and the Social Sciences, 1993 This is why I think it's a good thing that western Buddhism exits. It gets rid of al…

> It gets rid of all the bad stuff.

That’s laughable. Who decided what “the bad stuff” was? The early adopters were people who rejected western religions but projected western, individualistic culture onto eastern traditions.

Re: Buddhism has found a new institutional home in the West: the corporation

#232
post #49

I always find it weird how western "promoters" of Buddhism are so gung-ho on the meditation part, pretty much disregarding everything else. Having met quite a few Buddhists (also my partner) who were raised by Buddhist parents, I'm yet to find a single one who meditates at all. That's not even that big of a part of "mindfulness". After reading a monk's book (Essential Chan Buddhism by Guo Jun), I have a feeling it's…

Is there any kind of documentation of how modern religions are experienced by normal practitioners? A book [edit: or, more realistically, a book series] would be great, but some kind of film documentary series seems to me like an even better fit. I've gone looking for that sort of thing in the past and come up empty-handed. I'm thinking interviews and a combo of descriptions or footage of any religious practices or services that aren't considered too secret or sacred or whatever to allow outsiders to see it.

It's easy to find teachings and scattered accounts of some elements, but I'd be very interested in this kind of thing even for relatively familiar-to-me things like various Christian sects (to be any good, this would surely need a bunch of entries for every major religion, including Buddhism, because there are so many difference in how they're experienced by different traditions or in different cultures)

Material about priestly or monastics experience of religions is easy to find, but the experience of lay practitioners and their views on the religion (which may differ a lot from what the priests or monastics say) seems harder to come by, especially any kind of systematic or cohesive treatment rather than just scattered pieces here and there.

Re: Buddhism has found a new institutional home in the West: the corporation

#233
post #14

In Italy, in the '90s, we had a popular tv program with comedians doing sketches. One of those sketches was written and interpreted a guy who used to work in important advertising agencies. The sketch had a corporate manager who always started as a calm and devout supporter of buddhist-like tranquility in the workplace, all meditation and zen and care for personal wellbeing; by the end of the sketch his schizophrenic…

The TV show Silicon Valley also satirises the aggressive, egotistical CEO (a character called Gavin Belson). Belson spends some time at a Buddhist retreat which seems to impart nothing from his experience. The attraction to Buddhist ideas are only at shallow, surface level. He also employs a full-time spiritual adviser. Even the adviser looks out for opportunities advantageous to him and manipulate situations. It's a…

My favorite moment in perhaps the entire show is where Gavin Belson has a (mild) flash of self insight and asks:

> GB: Have I just surrounded myself with sycophants, who tell me whatever I want to hear, regardless of the truth?

> Spiritual advisor: ... no?

> GB: Thank you Denpok, I really needed to hear that.

Re: Buddhism has found a new institutional home in the West: the corporation

#234
post #14

In Italy, in the '90s, we had a popular tv program with comedians doing sketches. One of those sketches was written and interpreted a guy who used to work in important advertising agencies. The sketch had a corporate manager who always started as a calm and devout supporter of buddhist-like tranquility in the workplace, all meditation and zen and care for personal wellbeing; by the end of the sketch his schizophrenic…

> I bet such a sketch would cause outrage these days. I remember the times when people whose pastime was to get offended at stuff were ridiculed by most of the society. For all our social progress in this millennium, we regressed in many ways people don't readily notice. This was mostly an American thing in the past; but it spilled into Europe over time.

We have regressed by overturning abortion, enacting subversive election laws and in general destroying the fabric of democracy.

Re: Buddhism has found a new institutional home in the West: the corporation

#235

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are many varieties of Buddhism. It is a mixture of eastern culture and knowledge in general, including many generations of empirical psychotherapy, religion, philosophy, etc. Some varieties of Buddhism, like some schools of Zen, do focus heavily (or entirely) on meditation practice. Scientific research suggests that meditation has a real effect on the brain. To me it seems completely rational and expected that…

> There are many varieties of Buddhism. It is a mixture of eastern culture and knowledge in general, including many generations of empirical psychotherapy, religion, philosophy, etc. Some varieties of Buddhism, like some schools of Zen, do focus heavily (or entirely) on meditation practice. Zen does not traditionally focus heavily nor entirely on meditation practise, for example it has a heavy amount of ritual and ch…

> Overall there is no Buddhist lineage over a century old that I'm aware of that has its primary focus on meditation.

Do you mean specifically in Japan? Because many of the Tibetan lineages have Dzogchen [1] or Mahamudra [2] meditation as their primary focus and go back a thousand plus years. There are even lineages of householder or itinerant yogis called Ngagpa [3] that have long traditions of meditation training, going back to Tilopa, Saraha, and the other Mahasiddhas of Bengal. I practice with a Tibetan Ngagpa from time to time (Dr Nida) [4] and have also gotten a chance to practice with a Baul teacher from modern Bengal [5], and it's interesting to note how even though the lineages have split in their outward appearances, there are quite a lot of similarities in their teaching of meditation.

Anyway, that's all to say that in many Tibetan Buddhist lineages the meditation practice has been an unbroken, primary focus of the teachings. It wouldn't be surprising if that wasn't the case in other traditions.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dzogchen

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahamudra

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ngagpa

[4] https://perfumedskull.com/2017/05/30/the-white-robed-dreadlo...

[5] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7JZ4__GTbjA -- here Parvathy Ma is performing a doha attributed to Bhusuku aka Shantideva and is referencing the burning Nalanda.

Re: Buddhism has found a new institutional home in the West: the corporation

#236
post #14

In Italy, in the '90s, we had a popular tv program with comedians doing sketches. One of those sketches was written and interpreted a guy who used to work in important advertising agencies. The sketch had a corporate manager who always started as a calm and devout supporter of buddhist-like tranquility in the workplace, all meditation and zen and care for personal wellbeing; by the end of the sketch his schizophrenic…

That reminds me of Monty Python's cheese shop sketch. [1]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hz1JWzyvv8A

Re: Buddhism has found a new institutional home in the West: the corporation

#237
post #14

In Italy, in the '90s, we had a popular tv program with comedians doing sketches. One of those sketches was written and interpreted a guy who used to work in important advertising agencies. The sketch had a corporate manager who always started as a calm and devout supporter of buddhist-like tranquility in the workplace, all meditation and zen and care for personal wellbeing; by the end of the sketch his schizophrenic…

> I bet such a sketch would cause outrage these days. I remember the times when people whose pastime was to get offended at stuff were ridiculed by most of the society. For all our social progress in this millennium, we regressed in many ways people don't readily notice. This was mostly an American thing in the past; but it spilled into Europe over time.

https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Political_correctness

Re: Buddhism has found a new institutional home in the West: the corporation

#238

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>That some (on the left) have picked up on academic usage of some words or models is perhaps more accurate, and the misuse of words and terms. That is absolutely true. And there has even been some pushback from the academics who coined these terms. But, in the end, words are tools, and tools meet a need, and there was apparently a great need for a new narrative that explained personal feelings of failure and self loa…

I recently discovered Sam Harris, and started going down a bit of a rabbit hole that is his body of work. He has his critics, and I haven't spent enough time in his materials to have a fully formed opinion of my own, but I found that following his work unearths some interesting insights about these culture wars. His arguments about religion and society's collective unwillingness to have an honest conversation about i…

You state more eloquently what I wanted to respond as a comment. I am not interested in left/right, I am interested in outcomes that make people feel more valued, more part of a community, more prosperous. If there is one thing I know for sure is that entrenching yourself in your insert favourite beliefs here and shutting others out is not helping or helpful.

Certain outcomes seem to be more favorable using typical left wing policies and others using what’s thought of as right wing. Finding out which is which is far more interesting.

Re: Buddhism has found a new institutional home in the West: the corporation

#239
post #198

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, this Chen person is so so wrong. She says that meditation is for some monastic elites, but that is far from the truth. Who even chose to publish her book? Buddha himself said to Ananda that several thousand of his household desciples attained Nirvana. Not only did these "laymen" did meditation, they even attained Nirvana.

> She says that meditation is for some monastic elites She did not quite say that. She said that it was only practiced by monastic elites up until the early 20th century: "Meditation was not at all a mainstream lay practice in Buddhism. It only became popular in the early twentieth century, when Buddhist reformers such as the Burmese monk Mahasi Sayadaw, founder of modern Vipassana meditation, promoted it as a lay Bu…

> She said that it was only practiced by monastic elites up until the early 20th century:

Very wrong, too.

In Buddha's time itself, there were laypeople doing meditation.

I am wondering who even published her book?

Re: Buddhism has found a new institutional home in the West: the corporation

#240

Anyone who has read the Dhammapada can tell you exactly why the rise of Buddhism is a good thing. America's tendency to wrap everything up in a fancy package and slap a dollar sign on it might be annoying, but meditation is free - Ignore the noise. Transcendental Meditation (TM) has been doing this for a while now[1]. But it's not a big deal because outrage bait articles didn't make it a big deal. Please argue about…

I recall a former cult member turned therapist and cult expert Steve Hassan mentioning TM as problematic, he is the first reviewer quoted by this book about the topic

https://www.tmdeception.com/

Post reply on HN