Live data from Hacker News

Amazon still isn't doing enough to stop bait-and-switch reviews

fullstackeconomics.com

231–238 of 238 posts

Re: Amazon still isn't doing enough to stop bait-and-switch reviews

#231

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If they commingle, I don’t feel that it will matter if you filter by seller. That’s one reason we buy much less from Amazon.

It would not matter, but Amazon used to advertise that they commingle, so I know they do, whereas I do not know for sure if Walmart and Target do or do not.

You’re right. I rarely see 3rd party sellers on Target. As for Walmart, currently there is no commingled inventory, though things could change.

Re: Amazon still isn't doing enough to stop bait-and-switch reviews

#232
post #191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple reviews start over unless you explicitly ask for all versions. This is mildly obnoxious but works okay. Amazon could easily show reviews for the current product and a nice display of predecessor products and their reviews.

This would only work with the assumption that the owners of the product listing would update the version of the product in good faith. It would only be in their interest to do so if the current version of the project would get better reviews than the older version, and what I would imagine normally happens is the old version is made better to get better reviews and is then modified to be cheaper and worse later on.

Huh? If someone acquires a garlic listing and uses it to sell can openers without updating the listing, it won’t work, because everyone placing orders will think they’re buying garlic, not can openers. The scam only works because the listing matches (approximately, anyway) the sold product. If you start sending can openers labeled as garlic to customers, your return rate will be very high and there won’t be any profit.

Re: Amazon still isn't doing enough to stop bait-and-switch reviews

#233

Personally experienced this. I bookmarked a keyboard I was interested in purchasing in a month or so. When I went back it was a completely different item with the same reviews. Just today in fact, I was looking for an office chair seat cushion and found a very telling reddit comment from 3 years ago[1]. I know Amazon has a bulletproof return policy for the most part but I don't want to be hassled with returning every…

I received a different bike light than I ordered on Amazon (a literal Chinese knockoff) and submitted it for a replacement because it worked poorly. What I got back was another Chinese not-what-I-ordered knockoff, but it worked well... So I kept it.

Even though I came out happy it further inched me to my current position of "never buy from Amazon".

Re: Amazon still isn't doing enough to stop bait-and-switch reviews

#234
post #215

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unfortunately Walmart, Best Buy, and New Egg have Marketplaces too now :(

True, but so far they are either better curated or just have less spam. B&H is my favorite as I believe it has only them as a seller.

Yea B&H seem to have their own curated products still!

Re: Amazon still isn't doing enough to stop bait-and-switch reviews

#235
post #14

Yeah, it's a pity. It use to be a no-brainer shopping at Amazon. But now, I waste more time sifting through a bunch of cheaply made home goods that I'm just more inclined to look for sturdy, well-made products elsewhere. Also, it seems like they mix the inventory from different vendors, so it ends up being a crap shoot whether you get the original, or a knock-off, and the reviews reflect that.

> I'm just more inclined to look for sturdy, well-made products elsewhere. Any tips?

I signed up for a newsletter called Modern Different that curates products. It's easier to believe the motivation while it's small.

Also asking on reddit on the appropriate subreddit is pretty helpful.

Re: Amazon still isn't doing enough to stop bait-and-switch reviews

#236

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you get their Payboo card you don't have to pay tax. Took me like 2 minutes to sign up. They just closed the program but are re-opening it in January.

Opening a line of revolving credit, with a 29.99% interest rate, and a promise of cash back rewards that match the tax you pay (rewards which you technically are supposed to pay income tax on) isn't exactly the same as no sales tax. As as for "re-opening" the program, we'll see what they actually have for a new program when it is announced.

The interest rate doesn’t matter if you use the card as cash/debit by paying it off every month. And credit card rewards are not taxable because they are considered rebates by the IRS.

Re: Amazon still isn't doing enough to stop bait-and-switch reviews

#238

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Two wrongs are two wrongs no matter which way you slice them. Still, it’s an amusing comment. Amazon is complicit in aiding a third party to commit fraud. Not all of us are just, up right, mature adults, of sound mind and strict morals. Sending them back a steaming pile of dog shit is kind of amusing.

No, because some minimum wage worker has to unpack it. You don't tskr revenge on the people responsible, but on a poor sob that just wanted to earn a living.

Why should they care, they get paid the same for packing / unpacking the fraud.
Post reply on HN