Live data from Hacker News

PayPal raises fees for most domestic transaction types to 3.49% + $0.49

paypal.com

231–240 of 249 posts

Re: PayPal raises fees for most domestic transaction types to 3.49% + $0.49

#231

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Merchant fees for both debit and credit cards are significantly lower in all EU countries (and UK), compared to the US, thanks to the interchange fee regulation (IFR) that caps interchange fees at 0.2% for debit card and 0.3% for credit cards. This translates into much lower merchant fees. Even a tiny startup with zero transaction volume can easily get less than 2% on their physical card transactions (using something…

"Also, merchants are banned from adding surcharges for debit and credit card transactions in the EU & UK." Any pointer to this legislation would be appreciated. The local swimming pool lately started adding the transaction fees to the ticket after the sale.

In the UK, the relavent legislation is the Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012 (amended by the Payment Services Regulations 2017).

The ban on surcharges for credit & debit cards has been in force since January 13th, 2018.

Further details here: https://www.businesscompanion.info/en/quick-guides/pricing-a...

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/payment-surcharge...

Re: PayPal raises fees for most domestic transaction types to 3.49% + $0.49

#232

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Merchant fees for both debit and credit cards are significantly lower in all EU countries (and UK), compared to the US, thanks to the interchange fee regulation (IFR) that caps interchange fees at 0.2% for debit card and 0.3% for credit cards. This translates into much lower merchant fees. Even a tiny startup with zero transaction volume can easily get less than 2% on their physical card transactions (using something…

Sure, but then add in 21% VAT tax. Not defending the US but a 3% fee + (0%-11%) added sales tax doesn't seem like it would be a bigger "weight on the system" than a 21% VAT tax

The 21% is used to evolve and invest in a country which ultimately will lead to further economic growth whereas the 3% is used to enrich CC companies.

Re: PayPal raises fees for most domestic transaction types to 3.49% + $0.49

#233

When I moved to the Netherlands, I was at first irritated that my credit cards weren't accepted anywhere. But as the debit (maestro) card transactions are often free [1], paying 3%+ to a card service does seem exorbitant. For online payments, the Dutch use the IDEAL system, which is even easier than online credit cards. This also prevents vendor lock-in, like Amazon. And, the banking apps make it super easy to send m…

The problem with iDeal is that there is 0 consumer protection. If you pay for an order using a credit card and it’s a scam, you do a chargeback. If you pay for an order using iDeal and it’s a scam, the money is gone the moment you pay. There is no way to get the money back.

There is no customer protection because the payment system is not broken and insecure by design (e.g., hand your secrets over to an unverified entity and allow them to charge random amounts of money), plus there is no insane 3% fee. All those "benefits" that CCs argue to offer do not add up to the value of 3% of all your transactions.

Re: PayPal raises fees for most domestic transaction types to 3.49% + $0.49

#234
post #189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Looking back, I have to imagine that this 3%+ tax on all American transactions must put a weight on the system. I 100% agree. It's pretty absurd that all merchants have to pay a 3% fee on the vast majority of their transactions with no real alternative. And I realize crypto gets a bad rap around here, but I really do think stablecoins offer an interesting way around this. It's an open standard that anyone can build…

> (and before someone yells "crypto fees", there are already solutions that can drive these well below $0.01 if we're just sending payments between 2 parties) Can you specify what you're referring to? As someone who frequently yells "crypto fees" my understanding is most low-fee options either (a) require transfers within a centralized ecosystem, (b) aren't likely to scale effectively as a system (e.g. bitcoin's ligh…

Payment/State channels exist today. Is there a difference between your (c) hypothetical future ideas and hypothetical future scaling problems? Lightning works today. Try Breez Wallet https://breez.technology/ or Strike https://strike.me/ and tell me what your experience is like.

Re: PayPal raises fees for most domestic transaction types to 3.49% + $0.49

#235

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm yet to find a European that complains about the EU's caps on interchange fees for debit and credit cards. Is a regulation like this unfathomable for most Americans?

Folks in the US are so used to corporations stepping on them a balanced discussion about this (where both parties agree that you being exploited is not okay, but maybe disagree on the solution) is no longer possible.

It's bizarre how in the US, companies unionize against consumers, instead of the other way around.

Re: PayPal raises fees for most domestic transaction types to 3.49% + $0.49

#236

When I moved to the Netherlands, I was at first irritated that my credit cards weren't accepted anywhere. But as the debit (maestro) card transactions are often free [1], paying 3%+ to a card service does seem exorbitant. For online payments, the Dutch use the IDEAL system, which is even easier than online credit cards. This also prevents vendor lock-in, like Amazon. And, the banking apps make it super easy to send m…

I like iDEAL. My bank is dutch (bunq) although i live in Belgium, i got to use it a few times. I don't know if it's really easier than cards though given all the tools that are available for cards now, from auto fill to contactless. To be honest, google pay / apple pay are just so damn convenient. Being able to just hold my phone and have payment happen in a second is fantastic. And here in Europe let's not forget vi…

Android supports contactless debit card payments too, depending on your bank.

Re: PayPal raises fees for most domestic transaction types to 3.49% + $0.49

#237

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People use PayPal, Venmo, Revolut, etc mostly for convenience. You just need a phone number or email to send a payment, compared to a bank/wire transfer where you first need to obtain the account number you’re sending to. All of these services (including PayPal) charge no fees for personal payments. Just to merchants for commercial transactions, which often come with buyer protection, free credit/payment plans for th…

My bank app, ING, lets me send a payment request link as a text, via whatsapp, etc. Which is a nice way of not needing account numbers to send money.

But does it offer an API to do this? No. So it's useless for merchants who'd like to offer it as an alternative payment method.

I believe this would work, but I'm not an influencer: https://medium.com/@mariusandreiana/open-letter-to-banks-ple...

Re: PayPal raises fees for most domestic transaction types to 3.49% + $0.49

#239
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's no way to do peer to peer direct bank transfers in the US. Also, in the US, credit card providers accept all liability for fraud, as a consumer there's no way you will ever lose money to credit card fraud.

ACH does work, but it's just not accessible via an API and such.

How do you send money via ACH? I've never figured out a way to do it. Unless you're talking about the common "link an account" functionality where you do trial deposits, etc...

Re: PayPal raises fees for most domestic transaction types to 3.49% + $0.49

#240
post #161
post #157

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do they? Can I get an immediate refund for anything if I don’t like the item? I can with my Amex. No questions asked under $1000.

That doesn't sound like a feature I'd want to pay fees towards enabling but I'm likely missing something - what kind of up-to-$1000 purchases are you making where you might not even like the item?

I have used it multiple times for headphones. “Return protection”. Generally they’ll cover restocking fees if you make a claim.
Post reply on HN