Live data from Hacker News

Progress bars still lie

web.eecs.utk.edu

231–232 of 232 posts

Re: Progress bars still lie

#231
Progress Bars I Have Loved:

* Tells people what stage we're on. "Downloading", "Installing", "Cleaning Up".

* Can make bar for each step or guesstimated across all steps, either is ok.

* Do not show sub-step time estimates. If you show time estimates at all, do it for the whole process.

* Bar represents definite knowable progress: files moved, MB downloaded, etc. It thus never moves backward. If the stage has nothing knowable, make the bar full-width and stripey as a spinner equivalent.

* Able to open a verbose view that shows log stuff: actual numbers and filenames. The MacOS installer has this and good lord it was important when the MacTeX bug hit

Does this surface information that unempowered users don't need? Sure. Their eyes will just glaze over and it'll be fine.

Re: Progress bars still lie

#232
With Internet cut off, Netflix slowly moves the progress bar to 25%, waits a long time, and gives up.

We have a kettle at work that shows a two-digit temperature in celcius (100=boiling). When you ask it to bring 94+ degree water to 100, it slowly changes the number from 94 to 100 without turning the element on.

Clearly enough people prefer to be lied to.

Where will it end...

Post reply on HN