Live data from Hacker News

Why Young Men Go to War

medium.com

221–223 of 223 posts

Re: Why Young Men Go to War

#221

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I normally wouldn't respond to someone being downvoted, but I genuinely want to help people like yourself see this another way. The child beating scenario is a hypothetical. A 1:1 mapping with today's situation is that this child would be in Shanghai. I could fly over and try to save that child. Or, I could rely on those people that are surrounding the child already to have a more vested interest than I do as someone…

It was not a metaphor. You said you would never fight unless someone took a swing at you. If you walked down the street and spotted a person beating another helpless person to death, would you stand by and do nothing because you had not been attacked? Also, drop the condescending tone in your response about 'helping people see another way'. I gave you a simple hypothetical and you dumped a page of text without answer…

I did answer you, very clearly. If you understood my response you'd know that I would help that person. The issue is that your supposition has no correlation to the wars in the mideast and US involvement at all.

Re: Why Young Men Go to War

#222
post #181
post #177

Because there are army recruiters in american high schools... This for me was an unbelievable experience as a German, where if the army would be involved with any kind of school it would be a major scandal. But while in high school in america it was normal to be propagandaed on during your lunch hour.

Perhaps there is some historical reason for this.

What history could a western country have to be the only one to recruit for the army in schools?

Re: Why Young Men Go to War

#223
post #222
post #181

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Perhaps there is some historical reason for this.

What history could a western country have to be the only one to recruit for the army in schools?

A country formed through revolution which only fights its wars overseas.
Post reply on HN