Live data from Hacker News

CISA’s acting head uploaded sensitive files into public version of ChatGPT

politico.com

221–230 of 264 posts

Re: CISA’s acting head uploaded sensitive files into public version of ChatGPT

#221
post #203

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unfortunately it’s not so shocking anymore. The Secretary of Defense texting imminent war plans to a journalist in a Signal group kinda jumped the shark.

Secretary of War

In law, it is still the Department of Defense and Secretary of Defense, no matter what cutesy nicknames the executive branch invents.

Re: CISA’s acting head uploaded sensitive files into public version of ChatGPT

#222
post #191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not defending the buy but completely might be inaccurate. He has a masters in comp sci eng. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madhu_Gottumukkala I do realize this scholastic achievement is not indication he knows what he is doing.

And an MBA. He seems like a lot of people I know who skim through their technical degrees just to get the credentials. And my experience is that Masters is often easier to get than a Bachelors. Anyway what he did makes it abundantly clear that this person should not be head of security for anything.

meh diploma mill is a dime a dozen in University of India

Re: CISA’s acting head uploaded sensitive files into public version of ChatGPT

#223
post #191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not defending the buy but completely might be inaccurate. He has a masters in comp sci eng. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madhu_Gottumukkala I do realize this scholastic achievement is not indication he knows what he is doing.

And an MBA. He seems like a lot of people I know who skim through their technical degrees just to get the credentials. And my experience is that Masters is often easier to get than a Bachelors. Anyway what he did makes it abundantly clear that this person should not be head of security for anything.

A polygraph isn't a competency test.

It's a person reliability test and he failed it.

Re: CISA’s acting head uploaded sensitive files into public version of ChatGPT

#224
Yay, on-premise llms are what is recomended for serious use, at least US gov thinks that :) But rest of us need to pay subscriptions for 3r party businesses passing back and forth our... everything ?

In old days ppl was saying: "I have no secrets" and now we evolved into "I know how to not upload important docs" ;)

Re: CISA’s acting head uploaded sensitive files into public version of ChatGPT

#225

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Secretary of War

In law, it is still the Department of Defense and Secretary of Defense, no matter what cutesy nicknames the executive branch invents.

[flagged]

Re: CISA’s acting head uploaded sensitive files into public version of ChatGPT

#226
post #58
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"The report says Gottumukkala requested a special exemption to access ChatGPT, which is blocked for other Department of Homeland Security staff."

That they got this is shocking in itself.

meanwhile https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2026/jan/13/elon-musk...

Re: CISA’s acting head uploaded sensitive files into public version of ChatGPT

#227
post #191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And an MBA. He seems like a lot of people I know who skim through their technical degrees just to get the credentials. And my experience is that Masters is often easier to get than a Bachelors. Anyway what he did makes it abundantly clear that this person should not be head of security for anything.

A polygraph isn't a competency test. It's a person reliability test and he failed it.

> It's a person reliability test and he failed it.

It does not have the capability to say whether the person is reliable. It is a bunch of pseudoscience, basically.

Re: CISA’s acting head uploaded sensitive files into public version of ChatGPT

#228

Once again, if you or I did this, it's federal crime and federal time. But when the chief does it, it's an oopsie poopsie "special exemption".

    > Once again, if you or I did this, it's federal crime and federal time.
For a single incident? I doubt it. And, you need to show (criminal) intent. We still have no idea if this was accidental. To be clear, before this incident, he looked like just another senior IT admin. I still see it that way.

Re: CISA’s acting head uploaded sensitive files into public version of ChatGPT

#229
post #73
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Surely that must have been approved by the Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem, his former boss back in SD.

Every cause that led to this event is, in itself, quite shocking. I feel for my American friends, and hope they never again optimise their government for comedy value.

> Every cause that led to this event is, in itself, quite shocking.

accidentally based

> Madhu Gottumukkala was born in Andhra Pradesh, India

Re: CISA’s acting head uploaded sensitive files into public version of ChatGPT

#230
post #117

How is such a critical position filled with a foreign national?

I Googled for "cisa employment nationality requirements". I got a bunch of pages from CISA itself about how to apply for various jobs: recent grad, experienced specialist, and military vet. All have a bold statement under eligibility that says: "US Citizenship is required." It think it is safe to assume that Dr. Madhu Gottumukkala is a naturalised US citizen.
Post reply on HN