Live data from Hacker News

Reddit banned me for developing Geddit

buzl.uk

221–230 of 252 posts

Re: Reddit banned me for developing Geddit

#221
post #118
post #74

I unplugged from Reddit when they did this and my life is much better. Reddit had a good community and content in the early days, but as it grew in popularity and squeezed profit the value dropped. I think it’s funny that early LLM projects were bootstrapped by scraping Reddit. I guess it was better than random garbage from common crawl, but the world has moved on.

Huh... Moved on to where?

I hear Usenet is getting a bit more popular again. Also traditional forums for those niche topics.

Re: Reddit banned me for developing Geddit

#222

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Maybe this is a pattern common to most all group-oriented social media Channel operator drama was a major thing with IRC back when it was popular (sometimes ending to like channel splits or even whole netsplits if the people involved were related to the server operators, bot/flood wars, etc), so yeah, there isn't anything specific to Reddit about it. I wasn't part of it but i am pretty sure you'd see the same patte…

> despite the romantization, i somehow doubt that Usenet was all roses before the "Eternal September" Usenet was the best discussion platform I've ever used. People who posted questions to comp.lang.c without first reading K&R were commonly killfiled. People who posted questions to the comp.infosystems.www.authoring newsgroups without first reading relevant W3C specs were commonly killfiled. It was awesome. Can anyon…

Maybe it's because I'm not at the top % of developers but it feels like this would go over the top for the issues of most developers. I'd guess very few people need to go into uncharted territory nowadays unless using some tiny tool with no documentation to begin with. It's always a big warning light when I notice I'm going deep into anything as it usually means I'm using it for an unintended purpose.

Most of my issues, especially before LLMs have been regarding misunderstanding documentation, knowing I'm somehow misunderstanding it and just needing someone to rephrase it since I'm burnt out going in circles yet have to finish X before the end of the day so I can't let it marinate in my head.

My impression is that communities trying hard to enforce doing your research prior to asking often end up skill issueing plebians. In that line of thinking it might be cool to see a "question difficulty" option on sites like SO. I've never really had a question where I couldn't roughly gauge how complicated it is and if trying to answer questions it'd be cool to be able to roughly filter like you'd do in leetcode.

Re: Reddit banned me for developing Geddit

#224

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I thought the site was getting worse because that's the natural life cycle of image hosts and Reddit decided to become an image host. HN is avoiding it because somebody else pays to run it and there's zero images or videos. Also re: politics, stuff the federal government does affects me a lot whereas most local governments seem pretty similar and powerless. If the pendulum can swing so broadly ever 4 years I'd better…

How can the federal government impact you more, when anything from building permits, roads, garbage collection impact your daily life regularly? The last mayor of my city decided to make the entirety of the fields in front of my house (in Italy, countryside near Rome) buildable and completely ruined the view from my house and filled it with traffic.

Abortion and trans rights and stuff

Re: Reddit banned me for developing Geddit

#225
post #209
post #201

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Being able to "follow communities regardless of where they are rooted" just means that I can follow each one of the dozens of c/linux, c/opensource, c/funny. Each with their separate comment threads on similar submissions. Why would I want to do that? Sure, you can pick a random one like fediverser.network apparently does. Looking at one line from the list, I see that r/manga points to ani.social/c/manga which has 56…

> Why would I want to do that? Differences in policy. There are wildly different ideas about what is and isn't acceptable. > Sure, you can pick a random one like fediverser.network apparently does. Looking at one line from the list, I see that r/manga points to ani.social/c/manga which has 561 subscribers, when lemmy.ml/c/manga has 3,480. What? That's not random. There was drama. The lemmy.ml admins are hostile to a…

> That's not random. There was drama. The lemmy.ml admins are hostile (...)

That just makes it worse. Not only is it too large a field to bring a community together, but it's a minefield?!

Re: Reddit banned me for developing Geddit

#227
post #21

I moved on reddit back in Digg exodus days. Been there more than 15 years. Got banned recently mentioning that some Palestinians are terrorists. Mods cursed at me in the PM when I reported them to admins, Admin permanently banned my account. It's just a radical left echo-chamber now, which sucks because there are lot's of interesting niche sub forums. I wish someone would actually invest in competing product, with le…

Check out lemmy. Pick an instance: can start with https://lemmy.world or host your own. It's where everybody flocked to. It's decent, has decent content, decent users. If you don't like the mods/censorship you can host your own or go choose a new instance. content will be the same, mods will be different and what they mod will be different

Lemmy is an even worse leftist echo chamber that suffers from the same problems as reddit.

Re: Reddit banned me for developing Geddit

#228

Ironic that they can only ban you on account basis, but you can still continue using it via Geddit because it does not rely on authentication.

I noticed that. It's like Reddit staff delusionally believe that Reddit accounts have any value any more - when they get banned for any random "offense" (e.g. refusal to support Israel) and you just make a new one, they have no value to you. Moderators know this too, which is why they immediately jump to permanent bans - anything less isn't strong enough since you can just make a new account.

Re: Reddit banned me for developing Geddit

#229

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because the advertising model is very weak on Reddit, it's just a sponsored post with no differentiation most people skip past. No video or image to catch interest. Plus, the users are self segregated, what a dream. Imagine you wanted to sell drop shipped backpacks. All you'd need to do is create and prime, or buy, a dozen or so accounts, and start recommending your own brand subtly in every recommendation thread in…

> People trust Reddit because they assume they're other real users. Many advertisers already know and take advantage of this. It's nearly impossible at this point to know who or what is authentic. That's what advertisers would like their customers to believe. The truth is closer to: advertisers are lazy, Reddit users aren't complete idiots, subreddits are moderated, and spammers are (rightfully) despised. Effective s…

[flagged]

Re: Reddit banned me for developing Geddit

#230
post #225
post #209

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Why would I want to do that? Differences in policy. There are wildly different ideas about what is and isn't acceptable. > Sure, you can pick a random one like fediverser.network apparently does. Looking at one line from the list, I see that r/manga points to ani.social/c/manga which has 561 subscribers, when lemmy.ml/c/manga has 3,480. What? That's not random. There was drama. The lemmy.ml admins are hostile to a…

> That's not random. There was drama. The lemmy.ml admins are hostile (...) That just makes it worse. Not only is it too large a field to bring a community together, but it's a minefield?!

Your parent is exaggerating. The admins from .ml are not persecuting anyone, not exposing anyone and not even kicking out the existing subscribers that are ok with following the rules of the instance. The "drama" is just that they were clear they are not interested in hosting NSFW content and are not interested in providing a space for the hentai/loli/furry crowd. They defederated from ani.social because ani.social communities were posting loli, and that was it.
Post reply on HN