Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

blogs.microsoft.com

221–230 of 344 posts

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#221

Really. I used chatGPT quite a few times to summarize corporate spam emails to me. So this now makes things deliciously ironic: 1. BS Manager jolts down a few lines then AI outputs pompous bullshit from the raw bullshit she wrote. 2. I get the bullshit email and then use AI to distill the bullshit down to the essential bullshit

Considering the "discusion" I just had trying out ChatGPT (3.5, I believe), Step 2, is a bit distant.

It was impressive on general information, but as I got to more specific questions, I got a lot of vague and vaguely incorrect responses. When I provided a specific paper on the topic, it provided similar generalizations.

The weird thing is that it completely fabricated the author's name. No part of the name was anywhere in the paper. Called on the error, ChatGPT then said, "sorry for the error, it's really [Different_Name_2]". Called on that error, it then said similar "sorry for the error it's really [Different_Name_3]", then [Different_Name_4], and [Different_Name_5]... Wrong dates also, but it finally did get the date right (displayed right above the line saying "Author"..."). It also hallucinated employers for these fabricated authors.

It never did provide the right info. When I specifically prompted it with "ou did find the correct date information. Right under that there is a line saying "Author:" and following that, there is the actual author's name and employer. Can you parse and answer me with that actual information about the author?"

It first responded with a red error message. Repeated, it hallucinated ANOTHER fabrication...

I'm just astonished about the way this thing doubles down on it's hallucinations.

This really is the invention of infinitely scaled bullshit.

Edit: Definition of BS is speech or writing produced not specifically to lie or tell the truth, but with utter disregard for the facts. E.g., a BS artist just spins tales that sound good, with neither malicious or deceitful intent, but also with zero care about truth.

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#222

My first thought is, "gross"... now we'll have to wonder whether Manager X is even paying attention to the emails they're reading and responding to, or doing any actual work or thinking. Could lead to a world that's even more tilted towards politics and socially engineering your way up the ladder, versus competence and skill.

I was thinking about this last night. The new AI tools are like performance enhancing drugs in sports. Especially in bodybuilding, there was a really painful transition from the world of non-PEDs to PEDs. They solved that by going to natural and non-natural competitions.

Other sports didn’t handle it so well (baseball, cycling, etc)

Just as people were asking “did Lance / Sammy / Barry / Arnold really do that incredible feat without juicing?” I think that we will now be asking “did Janice really write that blog post or was it GPT-4?”

Scary world

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#223
post #191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am a DevRel so I work on the business side of the company but my intended readers are developers. Even though I was a skeptic at first, now I am a believer in practical usage of AI. I really struggle with writing CTAs or conclusive remarks. My writing style is dry and I write technical articles in a step by step manner assuming the reader has no to little understanding of the subject matter. I feel like developer d…

Writing can be improved. If your position requires better writing try to improve it, not replace your lack of skills with an AI. Using a AI is the same as to pay someone else on Fiverr to write the emails for you.

No. Using AI for this will increase your writing skills as long as you put more than 0 effort into it.

He's presumably not doing 1) paste his draft into ChatGPT, 2) paste the ChatGPT output into the text editor, 3) click publish.

If your objective is to create a well-written and effective document (rather than having AI autowrite some useless email), you wouldn't just blindly publish the ChatGPT output. You would read through the text that ChatGPT outputs and spend a minute reviewing what it wrote and tweaking it to your liking. Over time, as you read the corrected well-written version of your original poorly-written content, your brain naturally picks up on the differences and learns how to write well.

I've experienced this personally with Grammarly. I had very low expectations going in, and I still don't like some of its suggestions, but over time as you see and apply the corrections it suggests, you naturally end up learning and improving your writing skills. It's a great learning tool.

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#225
post #191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am a DevRel so I work on the business side of the company but my intended readers are developers. Even though I was a skeptic at first, now I am a believer in practical usage of AI. I really struggle with writing CTAs or conclusive remarks. My writing style is dry and I write technical articles in a step by step manner assuming the reader has no to little understanding of the subject matter. I feel like developer d…

Writing can be improved. If your position requires better writing try to improve it, not replace your lack of skills with an AI. Using a AI is the same as to pay someone else on Fiverr to write the emails for you.

Why?

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#226
Here's the GPT4 summary of the url:

Microsoft introduces Microsoft 365 Copilot

Microsoft has introduced Microsoft 365 Copilot, a next-generation AI-powered productivity tool integrated into Microsoft 365 apps, including Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook, and Teams. Copilot harnesses large language models (LLMs) and combines them with data in the Microsoft Graph to streamline work processes. It aims to unleash creativity, unlock productivity, and uplevel skills by providing assistance in writing, analyzing, collaborating, and automating tasks.

Microsoft 365 Copilot also offers a new feature called Business Chat, which works across apps and data to perform tasks using natural language prompts. The tool is designed to provide accurate, relevant, and contextual responses based on users' business data and context. Microsoft 365 Copilot is built with security, compliance, privacy, and data protection in mind, ensuring an enterprise-ready AI solution. The company plans to bring Copilot to all its productivity apps and will share more details on pricing and licensing in the future.

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#228
post #221

Really. I used chatGPT quite a few times to summarize corporate spam emails to me. So this now makes things deliciously ironic: 1. BS Manager jolts down a few lines then AI outputs pompous bullshit from the raw bullshit she wrote. 2. I get the bullshit email and then use AI to distill the bullshit down to the essential bullshit

Considering the "discusion" I just had trying out ChatGPT (3.5, I believe), Step 2, is a bit distant. It was impressive on general information, but as I got to more specific questions, I got a lot of vague and vaguely incorrect responses. When I provided a specific paper on the topic, it provided similar generalizations. The weird thing is that it completely fabricated the author's name. No part of the name was anywh…

[deleted]

Re: Microsoft 365 Copilot – your copilot for work

#230
post #191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Writing can be improved. If your position requires better writing try to improve it, not replace your lack of skills with an AI. Using a AI is the same as to pay someone else on Fiverr to write the emails for you.

Yep, but its cheaper and easier to use AI. Its just a tool; just like spellcheck is a tool.

I still don't use spellcheck, and my writing turns out fine.

These tools are fine for casual writers. However, people who write as their primary craft should work to improve their craft. AI (and spellcheck) are just crutches.

Post reply on HN