1Password for SSH and Git (Beta)

I stopped my subscription to LastPass and bought a 1Password subscription because LastPass discontinued their native macOS app and went with an electron wrapper. But the new LastPass client was slow, glitchy, and broke OS integration (It lost a lot of features. I tried to report some of that, and their support team ignored me). The 1Password experience already seems to have more robust features than my experience with LastPass, so I am happy with the switch. I really hope they can preserve all that through the transition, or that they maintain the native client!

I use it for this as well.

P.S: I'm not one to write "me too" comments, but there's no upvote count visibility for users. And since a designer working at 1p has eyes on the thread, it might make sense to add "me too" comments?

This is 1Password 8 dependent, so unfortunately I doubt I'll ever use it.

The 1Password 7 app on macOS is a beautiful native app. It "fits" in macOS, it follows macOS design paradigms.

1Password 8 does not. It is a weird self-designed UI toolkit that is well inside the uncanny valley scenario - it is a UI design that feels like it is trying to approximate all of the major platform desktop UIs without committing to actually feeling like any given platform - so it feels wrong everywhere. Honestly it would be better if it was totally different to any of the main platforms instead of vaguely approximating them. I don't care what devtools or toolkits they use to achieve what they do, I care about the end UI feel, and it's just awkward on all platforms to me.

Additionally, 1Password 8 removes the single most used feature for me - 1Password Mini - and replaces it with Quick Access. Quick Access is much more awkward to use, especially with a mouse. Everything with Quick Access involves more UI interactions than it was before. The reasoning for this is that it "feels weird" to implement parts of the app twice - but for me 1Password Mini is essentially a browser extension equivalent for every other app on your system. Quick Access is an awful replacement for that.

I really prefer 1Password 7 on macOS to 1Password 8, and I honestly prefer it on Windows too. The replacement of native apps with something that really feels like a web page in a window - with issues like context menus being stuck inside the window, or web-page style modals - is just not what I expected, and it's not what I want. Yes, it lets AgileBits bring updates to platforms more quickly because it's essentially the same backend & UI on every platform. However, as an individual user I don't need more from my password manager than 1P7 already does.

Sadly, it seems the target for AgileBits (especially with the influx of VC cash) from the outside at least is just growth and the big payouts that come from enterprise deals - individual user usecases don't matter any more. Just look at how much of a production they made out of restoring categories as an option to the sidebar. And their core featureset - form filling - is less reliable than ever for me.

I feel that there's absolutely a hole in the market here for a password manager product aimed at individuals or small families that works on at least macOS, Windows, iOS and Android - and feels native on each platform.

edit: oh, and I utterly abhor the 1Password PR style - trying to make things seem weirdly casual on serious topics, but especially the misdirection/redirection approach they always take to critiques or support queries. Just look at their support forums for any thread on purchasing standalone licenses - they always drive the discussion into "isn't our online product amazing?". Critique of features in 1P8 always becomes "but for me it's amazing" in some way. It's frustrating as hell to engage with as they never seem to actually accept criticism in any way without trying to redirect it to something somehow positive.

> They have somehow screwed up the very basic functionality of filling in passwords on any browser I try

UGH YES. When I started using 1P (2015ish?) it was simple and reliable, and I feel like I fight it more than I use it these days.

I support your request for basically making the "notes" field for 1Password entries into a field type, so you can have multiple ones.

Having said that, I admit I generally haven't missed them for the use case of SSH keys, even though I do occasionally store those in 1Password -- I use the Secure Notes feature for that. Copy the key to the clipboard with "cat ssh.key | pbcopy", make a new Secure Note, paste. I suppose it hadn't occurred to me to do anything else in part because, well, I can't -- but also because I don't think of these as username/password combinations, I think of them as "SSH for server foobar," and the search feature works perfectly well for that.

This is arguably a workaround instead of the ideal, but I actually use Secure Notes pretty frequently. WiFi base station passwords, recovery keys, personal access tokens, stuff that in general doesn't fit the "web site with username and password and possibly 2FA key" model I'm fairly sure I started this before 1Password even had a "Notes" field.