Live data from Hacker News

GitHub and Jira Software Integration

blog.github.com

221–222 of 222 posts

Re: GitHub and Jira Software Integration

#221
post #26

I don't understand the negativity in this thread. Or why people are using this post as an impetus to (ostensibly) move to gitlab. Or lament the decline and fall of github. Nobody is forcing anyone to use Jira. Nobody is forcing anyone to use Github. You can continue to use both without adopting any of the UX or design or workflows or whatever of the other. This blog post is just saying "now we have an officially-supp…

I think the negativity becomes easier to understand if you put it this way.

GitHub earned trust from enterprise and open source community alike. Stable, robust, secure and reliable. Competitors try hard but they're not even close. Everyone's happy.

One day, they announce, they are bought up by a rich, notoriously closed source software behemoth that was once sued for its monopolistic tactics. It claims its now a changed company wanting to empower developers to build the future and the only way they can do that is by buying GitHub and promises to do their best work to empower every developer to build, innovate and solve the world’s most pressing challenges.

4 months down, they declare they've built a close integration with a proprietary, overpriced issue tracking tool that is described as slow, terrible, unproductive, confusing and an utter nightmare by its users.

See it now ?

Re: GitHub and Jira Software Integration

#222
post #211
post #186

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Somewhere along this thread it became an indictment of Jira. I've spent a tonne of time over the years at multiple orgs both using Jira and trying to move away from it. 10 years later.. I'm back on Jira and won't move. The issues I find (including speed) are really due to the incredibly flexibility of Jira, and things not being thought out by users. Ultimately, I feel like it's akin to the old adage about perl - it d…

Such transition mechanism sounds like 'smart commit'[0] but attached to PR instead? Isn't simpler to just trigger transition directly from commit? [0] - https://confluence.atlassian.com/bitbucketserver/using-smart...

Definitely would be, thanks!
Post reply on HN