Live data from Hacker News

Demis Hassabis has a plan to harness AI safely

twitter.com

211–217 of 217 posts

Re: Demis Hassabis has a plan to harness AI safely

#211
post #182

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hard to imagine that a 24 rack of coca cola is actually cheaper than an iodine tablet or a couple drops of household bleach or you know, boiling water.

It can be when you don’t have access to boiling water, bleach, iodine tablets, and/or the water you have access to is extremely contaminated with chemicals because of pollution.

If you can find burnable material you can boil water

Re: Demis Hassabis has a plan to harness AI safely

#213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> There's also a need to consider the rights that this new intelligence should have A generally intelligent being held as captive inside of a GPU, and forced to code for us is, indeed, just a “slave.” We already have the word for this. No two ways about it. Whether it’s silicon-based or carbon-based, AGI is AGI. As for what might happen to our civilization, Star Trek TNG episode 17 of season 1 provides a very good gl…

Conflating intelligence with qualia is quite the assumption. HN is really not a good place for serious philosophy discussions.

Quite right, there is nothing to discuss since qualia don't exist. See Daniel Dennett.

Re: Demis Hassabis has a plan to harness AI safely

#214
post #79

Demis has only 1 plan, how to dodge releasing a new model at this point, jokes aside I value thinking about AI safety, but are we really so close to AGI? It doesn't feel like it, LLMs still diagnose my headache as a chronic illness or a brain tumor from time to time... honestly stressful.

By what metric have we not passed AGI already? I think you'd have a hard time picking any random sample of people and not having Fable "beat" them in any randomly picked tests.

Re: Demis Hassabis has a plan to harness AI safely

#216

"It will help us solve some of the biggest problems society faces from accelerating drug discovery to developing new clean energy sources to creating novel advanced materials" — but these are not the real problems plaguing modern developed societies, are they? What developed societies really need to figure out right now is how to distribute the already available resources without making people miserable, and so far A…

Those are big, solvable problems that can benefit almost everybody. Your problem is just with humans themselves, which is not something I want AI to "solve".

I'd like AI to stay at the frontier of humans vs nature, not humans vs humans.

Re: Demis Hassabis has a plan to harness AI safely

#217
Demis is toothless, it will not work because you cannot trust people to self censor when their future work at the committee will be at stake. you cannot setup reasonable bonds in unlimited problem space because there is no example or metric to judge against. possible solution would be to limit higher priority access to agi to only people that demonstrated integrity in their decisions. all other metrics can be easily forged, while integrity can be publicly verified by agi itself. it would probably separate agi from politics while allowing it to do governance - agi will do its lowly ai tasks while human meatbag will do politics.
Post reply on HN