Live data from Hacker News

NTP at NIST Boulder Has Lost Power

lists.nanog.org

211–218 of 218 posts

Re: NTP at NIST Boulder Has Lost Power

#211

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apparently no engineers here anymore, all armchair politicians.

When the politicians take a hatchet to the underpinnings of society that we built, we have to get political.

So sad, we used to innovate and stay one step ahead of them. That’s how wealth is created.

Re: NTP at NIST Boulder Has Lost Power

#212

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But pretty high on the list that NIST NTP is important for (since it leaves the building through the internet).

If NIST NTP goes down, the internet doesn’t go down. But atomic clocks drifting does upset many scientific experiments, which would effectively go down for the duration of the outage.

Also, I forgot to mention that NIST offers (and many institutions use) a service that provides a local rubidium reference that is GPS disciplined and they give you monthly reports that tell you the offset of the timestamps that were reported so they can be corrected. These services did not suffer interruptions.

Re: NTP at NIST Boulder Has Lost Power

#213
post #132

Earlier quoted context omitted.

These claims are bullshit. You can get technical details about the clock first-hand at this link: https://www.nist.gov/pml/time-and-frequency-division/time-re... and you can see a photo of the actual installation here: https://www.denver7.com/news/front-range/boulder/new-atomic-... As you can see, the room is clearly not filled with asbestos. Furthermore, the claim is absurd on its face. Asbestos was banned in the U.…

Agreed the stated claims don't seem to make much sense. Using a point mass 1 meter away and (G*M)/(r*c^2) I'm getting that you'd have to stand next to the clock for ~61 years to cause a time dilation due to gravity exceeding 10^-16 seconds.

Actually, it's even worse than that: the design of the clock makes it so that the cesium atoms doing the actual time keeping are in free-fall while they are being observed. So it is physically impossible for any gravitational influence to change the accuracy of the clock.

Re: NTP at NIST Boulder Has Lost Power

#214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm the Manager of the Computing group at JILA at CU, where utcnist*.colorado.edu used to be housed. Those machines were, for years, consistently the highest bandwidth usage computers on campus. Unfortunately, the HP cesium clock that backed the utcnist systems failed a few weeks ago, so they're offline. I believe the plan is to decommission those servers anyway - NIST doesn't even list them on the NTP status page an…

I love these comments on HN. Now if the (otherwise very kind) guy in charge of the Bureau international des poids et mesures at Sèvres who did not let me have a look at the refrerence for the kilogram and meter could change his mind, I would appreciate. For a physicist this is kinda like a cathedral.

If you ever are in Paris, I can't recommend the Musee des Arts et Metiers enough. I believe they have the several reference platinum kilograms that are now out of spec. [1] they also have the original actual Foucault pendulum that was used to demonstrate Earth's rotation. (and a replica doing a live demo, of course)

They have so many incredible artifacts (for weights and measures but also so much more: engineering, physics, civil engineering, machining,...)

[1]: https://collections.arts-et-metiers.net?id=13404-0001-

Re: NTP at NIST Boulder Has Lost Power

#216
post #214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I love these comments on HN. Now if the (otherwise very kind) guy in charge of the Bureau international des poids et mesures at Sèvres who did not let me have a look at the refrerence for the kilogram and meter could change his mind, I would appreciate. For a physicist this is kinda like a cathedral.

If you ever are in Paris, I can't recommend the Musee des Arts et Metiers enough. I believe they have the several reference platinum kilograms that are now out of spec. [1] they also have the original actual Foucault pendulum that was used to demonstrate Earth's rotation. (and a replica doing a live demo, of course) They have so many incredible artifacts (for weights and measures but also so much more: engineering, p…

Ahhh, thank you for the tip. I live in Versailles and usually go to museums for art, but this would be wonderful as well.

The Musée de Sèvres (or Bureau des Mesures as it is called now) has the original kilogramme and meter iridium reference, hidden in the basement ;( So if the director has a change of heart, I am all in!

Re: NTP at NIST Boulder Has Lost Power

#217
post #197

It’s fine. The public pays for sci-fi clocks used by NIST and the Navy and we get shit latency over NTP and a WWVB signal that barely reaches a huge chunk of the country. CLOCKS WE PAID FOR. Jane Street gets lightning access to clocks and our pension managers get their NTP trades front run. NTP is a disgrace and an insult when it is working.

The rest of the snark/ bitterness aside ... NTP takes latency as a constraint, and accommodates for it. And far from a disgrace, NTP was a brilliant design for its time, and has proven to be far more future-proof than should have been expected.

“snark bitterness side” I see so I’m not entitled to my feelings and I’m holding it wrong. No. It’s a disgrace. The latency is shit the precision is shit and WWVB to go with it is an insult.

Future proof? Are you living in the same future I am where our trades are front run? I notice you didn’t engage with the substance of my attack at all.

Re: NTP at NIST Boulder Has Lost Power

#218
post #214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I love these comments on HN. Now if the (otherwise very kind) guy in charge of the Bureau international des poids et mesures at Sèvres who did not let me have a look at the refrerence for the kilogram and meter could change his mind, I would appreciate. For a physicist this is kinda like a cathedral.

If you ever are in Paris, I can't recommend the Musee des Arts et Metiers enough. I believe they have the several reference platinum kilograms that are now out of spec. [1] they also have the original actual Foucault pendulum that was used to demonstrate Earth's rotation. (and a replica doing a live demo, of course) They have so many incredible artifacts (for weights and measures but also so much more: engineering, p…

I don't know if you will be reading this, but I am just back from that museum. Thank you very much for the information.

I spent 4 hours to there and was surprised to see so many tourists, this is not a place I expected people visiting Paris to go to. There were no crowds though.

The top part is really great, you get to see how much people did with so little. So is the chemistry part.

I found the steel replica of the kilogramme and the meter, and of course the Foucault pendulum (in the neighboring refurbished church).

This is truly an interesting museum, on part with the museum of discoveries (musée de la découverte) which is unfortunately close now for a few years for renovations (or at lest was recently planned to be closed). Much better than La Vilette.

So thank you again!

Post reply on HN