Live data from Hacker News

ChatGPT Atlas

chatgpt.com

211–220 of 768 posts

Re: ChatGPT Atlas

#211
post #71

Anyone feel like OpenAI is acting like Google lately? They announce a lot of products/features and then kill them when they realize people don't use them[0]. They also announce products way before they're ready for launch, just like google[1]. - GPT Plugins? (HN went crazy over this, they called it the "app store moment"...) - GPTs?! - Schedules? - Operator? - The original "codex" model? [0]: I know, the diff is that…

yeah the custom GPT announcement was literally a carbon copy of steve jobs announcing the app store down to the mannerisms and tics. You could tell they were doing it to give VC and private equity the pavlov bell "ring ring! this company is apple!" and remember the sora announcement just a couple weeks ago? oh you guys are tiktok and instagram reels now too? cool... everything that openAI does is laser focused on val…

> everything that openAI does is laser focused on valuation valuation valuation

idk it seems like a company filled with product and engineering where people are thinking of cool product ideas and shipping them. They don’t have to all hit, but it doesn’t seem bad to try them.

Re: ChatGPT Atlas

#212
post #122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't care about whether it's Chromium because of browser wars, I care about whether I can block ads.

I was able to add ublock origin lite as an extension & it seems to work the same as Chrome.

It can block sponsored chat response content too? And agentic behaviors that act on behalf of sponsors?

Re: ChatGPT Atlas

#213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>It's one thing to build a predictive model on your demographic, spending and location and income information in order to target and sell you advertisements, and quite another thing to build a model of your cognition itself by recording you If Atlas is successful, there's no reason why Google won't try to mimic it. They already have Chrome and Gemini, all they'd have to do is put Gemini directly into Chrome, dedicate…

They already have Gemini for chrome which no one uses.

Not sure how you can say that. Half the time you do a search the answer comes from Gemini. It might be the most used, without anyone doing it deliberately.

Re: ChatGPT Atlas

#214
The agent mode is really disappointing. I thought OpenAI would try to be more innovative with how the agent interacts with webpages, but it looks like it's the same DOM parsing and screenshot workflow the rest of the AI browser agents use. Giving the agent full access to the page is a recipe for disaster.

We have better tools for this now. This is a draft video I put together for the W3C demoing WebMCP. It blows their agent mode out of the water, and you can even use in-browser models for inference (see the end of the video)

https://screen.studio/share/hbGudbFm

I've been working on this full-time after putting out the MCP-B/WebMCP Hacker News post.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44515403

Re: ChatGPT Atlas

#215
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My web browser runs as root? Atlas runs as root? Atlas is a keylogger that indiscriminately watches what I type? Are any of these things true?

I assume they mean a web browser has root access to everything you do online, which is so far-reaching nowadays that it's not far from having root over your whole machine in terms of actual exposure.

Indeed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45659156

Re: ChatGPT Atlas

#217
post #15

If you think this is useful... remember technology like this would make totalitarian leaders foam at the mouth. If you thought that ads are creepy, Atlas is a root level keylogger service. Why would you want an AI company scraping and recording all of your browser interactions. Yes Google already does this via Chrome. It's one thing to build a predictive model on your demographic, spending, location and income inform…

>It's one thing to build a predictive model on your demographic, spending and location and income information in order to target and sell you advertisements, and quite another thing to build a model of your cognition itself by recording you If Atlas is successful, there's no reason why Google won't try to mimic it. They already have Chrome and Gemini, all they'd have to do is put Gemini directly into Chrome, dedicate…

> If Atlas is successful, there's no reason why Google won't try to mimic it.

Regulation.

Re: ChatGPT Atlas

#219
post #192
post #15

If you think this is useful... remember technology like this would make totalitarian leaders foam at the mouth. If you thought that ads are creepy, Atlas is a root level keylogger service. Why would you want an AI company scraping and recording all of your browser interactions. Yes Google already does this via Chrome. It's one thing to build a predictive model on your demographic, spending, location and income inform…

After skimming the product page I'm still not sure what extra data exactly everyone is so confident is being gathered/used in a way that Google wouldn't already be doing in Chrome. As far as I can tell, most of these features are already integrated into Chrome but with Gemini. What exact feature in Atlas would need to log your every keystroke? Could they be doing that? Yes. But so could Google and in both cases they'…

Our trusted computing base should be small, built from open-source, and not under the control of one company.

But sadly, here we are.

How do we know GMail can't steal your bank account info and Chrome can't steal ... everything from your web browsing, or impersonate you?

All they have to do is be pressured by a government: https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Bills_Legislat...

Post reply on HN