Live data from Hacker News

How Britain built some of the world’s safest roads

ourworldindata.org

211–220 of 269 posts

Re: How Britain built some of the world’s safest roads

#211
post #188

A more enlightening chart: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in...

Thanks. This is from

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in...

Browsing through this I found:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/14/Accident...

What is up with poisoning in the early 40s?

Re: How Britain built some of the world’s safest roads

#212
post #176

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You make it sound like motorbike riders are practically unregulated, but in a sense it's the opposite. A few decades ago, 125cc bikes were mostly for learners practising before taking their test. But successive governments have made it harder and harder to get a full license - so loads of riders just stay on learner bikes forever. So the status quo is, in a sense, the result of very strict regulation.

It's the Deliveroo, Just Eat etc crowd too. CBT and off you go. No incentive for further training.

driving instructors told me they get indians straight up offering to buy CBTs with cash lol.

Re: How Britain built some of the world’s safest roads

#213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Interestingly, I saw data from a road safety programme for young people that showed skid pan training actually made young men less safe not more, because they became even more overconfident about their ability to “react quickly” if bad things happened. Turns out that a bit of humility and slowing down are the main skills needed to avoid accidents!

That's true, on the other hand it made young women safer. This happened in Norway when the skid pan was made a compulsory part of the course a couple of decades ago and the insurance companies soon noticed an increase in reckless driving among young men but the opposite in young women.

    > an increase in reckless driving among young men but the opposite in young women
This is fascinating. Does anyone know the root cause here?

Re: How Britain built some of the world’s safest roads

#214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Then you get the two wheeled side of the fence. You can do a one day compulsory basic training course and convince a trainer you know what you're doing, then drive on the road with everyone on a 125cc motorcycle (or 50cc at 16 years old), and then repeat the CBT every two years to keep on the road. It's only if you go for the full license that you need to study for theory as a prerequisite, so long as you keep out of…

You make it sound like motorbike riders are practically unregulated, but in a sense it's the opposite. A few decades ago, 125cc bikes were mostly for learners practising before taking their test. But successive governments have made it harder and harder to get a full license - so loads of riders just stay on learner bikes forever. So the status quo is, in a sense, the result of very strict regulation.

getting a full motorbike license is also expensive. there's a chicken and egg problem, which is that for an unrestricted license you must do the Mod1 and Mod2 on a 600cc bike or greater, which ofcourse you're not allowed to ride if you're on a CBT.

so you have to pay a school, and itll cost in total probably £1k or a bit more. when i did it, the guys also told me, there's basically only one company now that provides insurance for instructors/riding schools.

motorbiking i think is becoming less of a guy thing and more like skiing - an expensive, occasional thrill, but very much an upmarket upper-middle-class type of activity. there were more girls than guys at my lessons too, which was pretty surprising at first, but not really once you consider the prior.

which was very much at odds with the instructors, who were all guys' guys - when they got into it at 16, motorbiking was much cheaper than a car, and had a real economic argument to make (it was much cheaper all-round) - today, if you add up the insurance, protective gear, bike, and school money, you will be on-par with a car, which is far more practical.

Re: How Britain built some of the world’s safest roads

#215

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Montana would be amazingly safe based on your metric.

No actually on that metric Montana is one of the most dangerous and Massachusetts is one of the safest.

    > Massachusetts is one of the safest
For those unaware, Boston (largest city in Massachusetts) has a reputation for incredibly aggressive drivers (so does New York City). Is Massachusetts relatively safer because it has so few freeways? I find it hard to believe this can be explained by "quality of drivers". Another idea: Maybe local police are very, very strict about drink/driving, thus reducing the number of deaths.

Re: How Britain built some of the world’s safest roads

#216
post #188

A more enlightening chart: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in...

Thanks. This is from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in... Browsing through this I found: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/14/Accident... What is up with poisoning in the early 40s?

The page for this graph links to the source of the data, which is at: https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/all-injuries/deaths-by-demograph...

As I suspected, poisoning most likely includes drug overdose. They have this comment about the 2023 data:

> #1: Poisoning: 100,304 deaths

> Largely due to the opioid epidemic affecting millions of people in the United States

You can see more recent data than 2004 in their interactive charts. It is interesting to see that deaths from road accidents has much reduced for teenagers and young adults, compared to the rest of the population.

Re: How Britain built some of the world’s safest roads

#217

I wonder if there will be a reversal in pedestrian deaths with the rise in larger cars. I live in a large UK city and it is mad the number of SUVs you see driving around.

Is the rise in SUVs about (displaying/increasing) social status? I am curious why people in the UK "need" SUVs. In many areas of the US, having a huge car is about social status.

Re: How Britain built some of the world’s safest roads

#218

Our driving test standards are also high, having spoken with US colleagues, much higher than state-side (although I imagine that varies from state to state). The theory test you must pass before taking your practical also now includes a hazard perception test - you are shown multiple videos and must click when you first perceive a hazard - the earlier you click after the hazard presents the higher your score - but if…

In New York state, virtually EVERYONE fails their first driving test. Rare exceptions. Second test pass is standard.

I kind of assumed every state does this.

Re: How Britain built some of the world’s safest roads

#219

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A favorite past-time back in the day was driving at night from pub to pub along the 'back roads' (B-roads specifically in the UK) as fast as 'possible'. There were typically no street lights, however lights from other vehicles showed up alerting you to any possible danger. It was fun at the time, but i wouldn't do it now .. lol ..

I went to a wedding in Devon recently, friend of my wife’s whose family are all farmers and her brother was joking that it’d be fine to drive back drunk because the car would just bounce off the hedgerows…

Safety first. More hedgerows!
Post reply on HN