Live data from Hacker News

FCC to eliminate gigabit speed goal and scrap analysis of broadband prices

arstechnica.com

211–220 of 221 posts

Re: FCC to eliminate gigabit speed goal and scrap analysis of broadband prices

#211

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What a strange accusation. One of the liberal places I read is here, where the discourse usually isn’t that far from Reddit Politics just with more self-righteousness (sometimes, most of the time it’s okay). Why would you doubt that I read legitimate conservative sites? I read enough to know how brigaded Reddit Conservative is, that’s not real. I spent a lot of time with an actually balanced source of news.

You're outting yourself as an unreliable narrator - HN isn't liberal, it's typical moderate neo-lib. Youre assuming HN must be liberal because it's somewhat critical of Trump. You're reverse-engineering your position. HN isn't critical of Trump because they're libs, they're critical of Trump because he's bad and the policy is bad. I mean, raising the deficit by trillions in exchange for A REDUCTION in public services…

> HN isn't liberal

Hot take.

Turns out there is larger diversity of thought with conservative voters. Not everyone has to agree or like every action. Immigration alone if it’s handled as it has been will lead to President Vance.

Re: FCC to eliminate gigabit speed goal and scrap analysis of broadband prices

#212

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Interesting that there is a significant price disparity between locations for what is ostensibly a global service. … is it? Why wouldn't a corporation use any and all data available to them to price discriminate as hard and as much as they possibly can? > my corner of Ohio either. We have 3 fiber providers in the area I … am not sure I believe that. Everywhere I think I have ever lived, broadband is a local monopol…

In Kitsap county the municipality owned lines can be used via a service contract with any number of service providers. Kinda a monopoly and kinda not.

… so it's another Chattanooga. These are highly exceptional cases, compared to most of the nation.

(They seem to work well, from what I've read of them.)

Re: FCC to eliminate gigabit speed goal and scrap analysis of broadband prices

#213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's a pretty reductionist take. Here's what I think is a more reasonable one. If I told you your job was to keep the house clean, but made you come back to me for permission to pick up socks, but told you that absolutely didn't give you permission to pick up shoes , waited 8 months to reply to your request for permission to vacuum, denied you authority to decide what pieces of paper are trash and which are importa…

Yes. But it's important that you accept the yacht afterwards . If you get the yacht in advance , it's a bribe, you see.

Right. It's a bribe if you accept it in advance. If you accept it afterwards, it's just a salary.

Re: FCC to eliminate gigabit speed goal and scrap analysis of broadband prices

#214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

That’s the kind of unkind and rather toxic comment I would expect on Reddit, not HN. Unimpressed.

Do you think I wanted to impress you or anyone really? GP was beating a dead horse so I said something. Somehow you ended up caring. I’m almost certain there are better uses of your time. Certainly has no influence on my opinion. Honestly people who hold Hacker News like it’s sacred are exhausting. Your opinions and mine need not mix, just use your thumb to move on?

Re: FCC to eliminate gigabit speed goal and scrap analysis of broadband prices

#215
post #32

My building recently got wired up with a local ISP taht is offering gigabit fiber for... $25/month. AT&T Fiber or Verizon Fios will tend to start at $60-90/month as an "introductory" price where your bill just keeps going up $10-20/months every yera unless you go through the dance of calling up and threatening to cancel every year. So you could be paying $140/month when a new customer is being charged half that. Chat…

I live in the SF Bay Area where Sonic offers 10Gbit connections for $60/month. They’re a medium sized local provider with excellent support and great prices, and they’re making money doing it . If “economy of scale” were uncapped, Comcast should be a fraction of that price.

Did they raise prices or is it location based? I pay 50

Re: FCC to eliminate gigabit speed goal and scrap analysis of broadband prices

#216
post #6

This seems to be good for Starlink at the expense of the fiber providers?

Rural fiber at my lake home went from $35/mo for 100/100 to $89.95 this year. On a 12mo contract. Starlink got my business after VZW forced their 5G boxes to use 5G and not allow forced LTE usage. 5G is unusable there with 60-100/0.03. I force my phone to use LTE and all is well but 5G just does not work. I hate giving Elon money but it’s the only affordable month-to-month option now.

[dead]

Re: FCC to eliminate gigabit speed goal and scrap analysis of broadband prices

#217

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

There is a LOT of data on Trump/Russia out now. I find it hard to believe anyone informed is still using that. It’s kind of an intellectual red flag my man. The smarter liberals have moved on to just hating Trump for being himself. Do the true believers here think that the I formation Gabbard is releasing is fake? We’ve had it for 9 years now about Ohrs and FusionGPS and FBI lying to FISA.

https://x.com/nicksortor/status/1948007087151190074

I read 25 of the first documents 46 pages. Sure looks bad.

Re: FCC to eliminate gigabit speed goal and scrap analysis of broadband prices

#218

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Data caps? Does it really offer that speed at peak times though? Are oversubscription of backhaul infrastructure disclosed? In semi-rural hill country TX, 2.5 Gbps symmetric from an internet co-op is $90 USD/month without data caps.

> Data caps? I'm sorry, is this some American problem I'm too European to understand?

Why the identity bashing? Data caps exist in many countries including Australia.

Re: FCC to eliminate gigabit speed goal and scrap analysis of broadband prices

#219
post #136

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Data caps? Does it really offer that speed at peak times though? Are oversubscription of backhaul infrastructure disclosed? In semi-rural hill country TX, 2.5 Gbps symmetric from an internet co-op is $90 USD/month without data caps.

It keeps that speed at peak times without any issues, low pings, fast download speeds. With such internet connection the server is bottleneck, so if I download Linux distro I often choose torrent download option. There is no official data caps too.

Nice. Any throttling noticed? Or is it such surplus and predictable bandwidth that there's not really any slowness or limitations?

Re: FCC to eliminate gigabit speed goal and scrap analysis of broadband prices

#220
post #136

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It keeps that speed at peak times without any issues, low pings, fast download speeds. With such internet connection the server is bottleneck, so if I download Linux distro I often choose torrent download option. There is no official data caps too.

Nice. Any throttling noticed? Or is it such surplus and predictable bandwidth that there's not really any slowness or limitations?

I have never noticed throttling, however I am not a "heavy user", just an average one.
Post reply on HN