Live data from Hacker News

I trusted an LLM, now I'm on day 4 of an afternoon project

nemo.foo

211–215 of 215 posts

Re: I trusted an LLM, now I'm on day 4 of an afternoon project

#211
post #209
post #145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was just today trying to fix some errors in an old Linux kernel version 3.x.x .dts file for some old hardware, so that I could get a modern kernel to use it. ChatGPT seemed very helpful at first - and I was super impressed. I thought it was giving me great insight into why the old files were now producing errors … except the changes it proposed never actually fixed anything. Eventually I read some actual documentat…

Eventually I read some actual documentation... For the best of both worlds make the LLM first 'read' the documentation, and then ask for help. Make a huge difference in the quality and relevance of the answers you get.

And hope the docs aren't too large. LLMs tend to confabulate more with longer contexts.

Re: I trusted an LLM, now I'm on day 4 of an afternoon project

#212

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm sorry, what?

> It feels more like I’m able to Matrix-upload docs into my brain like Trinity learning to fly a helicopter Did you puzzle about this sentence specifically? Imagine you don't know jack about flying helicopters, then Tank uploads the Helicopter Pilot Program (TM) directly to your brain; it would feel like magic. Conversely, if you know a lot about helicopters, just not enough to fly a B-212, and the program includes i…

[flagged]

Re: I trusted an LLM, now I'm on day 4 of an afternoon project

#214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It feels more like I’m able to Matrix-upload docs into my brain like Trinity learning to fly a helicopter Did you puzzle about this sentence specifically? Imagine you don't know jack about flying helicopters, then Tank uploads the Helicopter Pilot Program (TM) directly to your brain; it would feel like magic. Conversely, if you know a lot about helicopters, just not enough to fly a B-212, and the program includes i…

[flagged]

My horrible grammar has to be a giveaway it didn't, ha ha.

Re: I trusted an LLM, now I'm on day 4 of an afternoon project

#215

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I mean 2 years ago they were at about the same place, theres been very little practical gain from gpt4 in my opinion. No matter the model the fundamental failure cases have remained the same.

Reasoning models like o1 or QwQ absolutely destroy 4o in coding, let alone GPT-4 circa 2022.

This is not my experience at all, o1 fails in the same way 4o does.
Post reply on HN