Live data from Hacker News

Bop Spotter

walzr.com

211–220 of 405 posts

Re: Bop Spotter

#211

Pretty sure Apple and Google already do this, just to all phones, in all homes, and not just for music, but your entire life! No consent needed. Have a nice day! :)

This comes up a lot, but the reality is that people are fairly predictable and Apple and Google don't need to literally listen (expensive) to make fairly accurate guesses about your behavior.

All they need is enough metadata.

Re: Bop Spotter

#212
post #191

I notice that on September 28 (near the top of the list, since it doesn't seem to have anything for today yet) the same Pitbull song was detected separately a little less than an hour apart, and I can't help but wonder if it was the same person listening to it on loop. Several months ago, my fiancee and I overheard someone driving outside blasting Adele's "Someone Like You" from inside our apartment, and every 45 min…

Or spotify jamming a song into everyone's algorithms, as a cynical take.

I have never looked up and played Drake or Taylor Swift, but they come up in "curated" playlists thought-provokingly often.

Re: Bop Spotter

#213

Nice. there's a selection bias as the people who play music loud enough to be heard from their cars and several genres there just don't overlap at all. if we're acknowledging that the music played from cars is neighbourhood vibe, it raises the question of whether they are interfering with the neighbourhood as well.

I was waiting for someone to sneak in a anti-car angle into this and presto what have you ! Haha

subwoofers are an invasive tech and unchecked they can wreck neighbourhoods, this project could yield data on that imo.

Re: Bop Spotter

#214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Comments like this worry me that HN is being dragged down with the wider culture wars and truthiness that’s destroying all that we have. I would hope for better in this forum.

Have you seen the latest YCombinator batch?

is this about the company that is banking on a war with China to secure their exit making cruise missiles for sea drones, or one of the other ones

Re: Bop Spotter

#215

The Mission is a variegated place. It's been undergoing gentrification for 4 decades but it never seems to get there - so much so that you could say that that's become its "thing." The exact location where the phone is placed makes a huge difference. Going from Valencia to Shotwell to the BART plazas to the Latino bars and back to the hills your soundtrack would change quite a few times.

I'm not a Bay Area person, but was visiting a few months ago and got a new tattoo at Rose & Thorn right off the 16th BART station. Took a walk around waiting for the appointment and it's crazy how fast the vibe changes from block to block.

Re: Bop Spotter

#217

Alright, who wants to go wardriving around the mission with me, blasting Never Gonna Give You Up?

You could probably locate the exact location of the microphone by driving around in a carefully planned pattern with unique, known songs playing.

Re: Bop Spotter

#218

I love everything about this. There is this undercurrent to our technology landscape. A kind of subculture somewhere in the locus of the hackersphere where a kind of punk-rock ethos rules the roost. I can only describe it as a live exploration of concepts _through_ technology, where functional fixedness is a foreign concept, including in the shared experience of social construct; everything becomes parts to be remixe…

Well put. I agree 100%. Gives me hope in a way I can’t quickly put to words.

Re: Bop Spotter

#220

Cool. And I noticed that a surprisingly high number of songs are in Spanish. So I'll venture to hypothesize that this project will identify a correlation between musical taste and preference for how loud it is played, rather than accurately capturing the "musical taste of the neighborhood". Any thoughts on that? Have you tested how loud a song needs to be played in order to be picked up?

I think there’s definitely a bias towards songs that you’re going to blast from your car with the windows down. As someone decades away from that stage of life, it would be unlikely that anything that I listen to would show up in the lists (and, in fact, skimming over a couple days’ songs, there were only three songs I recognized, although a few more artists).
Post reply on HN